difficult problem
Started by gershon kats, Oct 02 2001 05:58 PM
17 replies to this topic
#6 Members  Reputation: 326
Posted 03 October 2001  11:08 AM
quote:
Original post by silvren
Hi,
Could anyone please help me with this homework problem:
prove that there exists no solutions for:
X^n + Y^n = Z^n where n > 2
soon please coz I need to hand this in next week.
/Mankind gave birth to God.
You silly person you. I don''t have 300 years to try and prove that.
   
Blue programmer needs food badly. Blue programmer is about to die!
#7 Members  Reputation: 1114
Posted 03 October 2001  12:28 PM
Ahh, I remember seeing a show about that very problem once^^
I think some guy did end up proving it, but they never told exactly what the solution was.
Dekuchan
DK Art (my site, which has little programmingrelated stuff on it, but you should go anyway^_^)
I think some guy did end up proving it, but they never told exactly what the solution was.
Dekuchan
DK Art (my site, which has little programmingrelated stuff on it, but you should go anyway^_^)
#9 Anonymous Poster_Anonymous Poster_* Guests  Reputation:
Posted 03 October 2001  07:15 PM
about 150 pages long
#11 Anonymous Poster_Anonymous Poster_* Guests  Reputation:
Posted 04 October 2001  04:00 AM
I have some ideas that involve elliptical equations and modular forms, but I''m not sure it''ll work. I''ll get back to you in eight years or so.
#14 Members  Reputation: 122
Posted 04 October 2001  05:12 AM
quote:
Didn't he prove that x3+y3 does NOT = z3
Euler is credited with proving X^n + Y^n != Z^n where n > 2
for n=3 and subsequent cases for specific values of n have been proven by other mathematicians throughout history.
However, it was proven for all cases of n>2 by Andrew Wiles (in 1994 I think, could be wrong as this is from memory) by proving the the ShimuraTaniyamaWeil conjecture.
Just a irrelevent (but highly interesting) piece of information for any budding mathematicians...
[Edited: Sorry Dobbs. My mistake. You are completely correct.]

Supercytro
Edited by  supercytro on October 5, 2001 4:56:48 AM
Edited by  supercytro on October 5, 2001 5:15:25 AM
#15 Members  Reputation: 164
Posted 04 October 2001  06:31 AM
Supercytro, you are just plain wrong. Fermat''s theorem was there are NO nonzero integer solutions to x^n + y^n = z^n where n>2, so python_regious was right, x^n + y^n != z^n for n>2.
There are however solutions to x^n + y^n + z^n = c^n for n=3 and n=4. Maybe this is what you meant?
There are however solutions to x^n + y^n + z^n = c^n for n=3 and n=4. Maybe this is what you meant?
#16 Members  Reputation: 259
Posted 04 October 2001  02:27 PM
Hope you have at least nine years to prove this!
Andrew Wiles, a Cambridge mmathematician, showed that x^n + y^n != z^n for all n > 2.
Elliptical equations and modular forms are understood by few mathematicians anyway. Good luck!
Regards,
Mathematix.
Andrew Wiles, a Cambridge mmathematician, showed that x^n + y^n != z^n for all n > 2.
Elliptical equations and modular forms are understood by few mathematicians anyway. Good luck!
Regards,
Mathematix.
#17 Members  Reputation: 122
Posted 04 October 2001  10:01 PM
Bad bad mistake by me earlier. Edited my post. Thanks Dobbs for catching that. I guess my test for whether anyone was paying attention paid off ;)
Next time I'll actually read what I write before posting.
Whilst programming, I've found "!=" and "==" are a common cause of quite a few logical errors.
Apologies to python_regious for misreading your post as well.
I knew this but unfortunately it wasn't what I meant. It was just a stupid mistake unfortunately, and not a misunderstood post by me.
Edited by  supercytro on October 5, 2001 5:07:43 AM
Next time I'll actually read what I write before posting.
Whilst programming, I've found "!=" and "==" are a common cause of quite a few logical errors.
Apologies to python_regious for misreading your post as well.
quote:
x^n + y^n + z^n = c^n for n=3 and n=4
I knew this but unfortunately it wasn't what I meant. It was just a stupid mistake unfortunately, and not a misunderstood post by me.
Edited by  supercytro on October 5, 2001 5:07:43 AM
#18 Moderators  Reputation: 1373
Posted 09 October 2001  02:53 AM
I''m closing this thread and several others because the question appears to be a school homework assignment from a math class. The purpose of homework is to teach students to build their comprehension of a subject and their problemsolving skills, possibly with the assistance of other students in the same class or teachers of the class. Especially for math problems such as the one posed here, it is absolutely NOT appropriate to seek the answers from folks outside one''s class or school.
These forums are to be used for assistance in game development activities only.
Graham Rhodes
Senior Scientist
Applied Research Associates, Inc.
These forums are to be used for assistance in game development activities only.
Graham Rhodes
Senior Scientist
Applied Research Associates, Inc.