• Create Account

What's wrong with my tangent calculation?

Old topic!

Guest, the last post of this topic is over 60 days old and at this point you may not reply in this topic. If you wish to continue this conversation start a new topic.

2 replies to this topic

#1EngineCoder  Members

246
Like
0Likes
Like

Posted 14 May 2012 - 10:13 AM

Some of my triangles render as if they're pointing away from the light. I can fix them by rotating their UV map upside down.
void Mesh::generateTangents()
{
for (size_t v = 0; v < m_vertices.size(); ++v)
{
m_vertices[ v ].tangent = Vec4( 0.0f, 0.0f, 0.0f, 0.0f );
}

m_tangents.resize  ( m_indices.size() );
m_bitangents.resize( m_indices.size() );
bool degenerateFound = false;
for (size_t f = 0; f < m_indices.size(); ++f)
{
const Vec3& p1 = m_vertices[ m_indices[ f ].a ].position;
const Vec3& p2 = m_vertices[ m_indices[ f ].b ].position;
const Vec3& p3 = m_vertices[ m_indices[ f ].c ].position;

const TexCoord& uv1 = m_vertices[ m_indices[ f ].a ].texCoord;
const TexCoord& uv2 = m_vertices[ m_indices[ f ].b ].texCoord;
const TexCoord& uv3 = m_vertices[ m_indices[ f ].c ].texCoord;

const TexCoord deltaUV1 = uv2 - uv1;
const TexCoord deltaUV2 = uv3 - uv1;

const float area = (deltaUV1.u * deltaUV2.v - deltaUV1.v * deltaUV2.u);
Vec3 tangent;
Vec3 bitangent;
if (std::fabs( area ) > 0.00001f)
{
const Vec3 deltaP1 = p2 - p1;
const Vec3 deltaP2 = p3 - p1;
tangent   = (deltaP1 * deltaUV2.v - deltaP2 * deltaUV1.v) / area;
bitangent = (deltaP1 * deltaUV2.u - deltaP2 * deltaUV1.u) / area;
}
else
{
degenerateFound = true;
}
Vec4 tangent4( tangent.x, tangent.y, tangent.z, 0.0f );
m_tangents[ f ]   = tangent4;
m_bitangents[ f ] = bitangent;
}

if (degenerateFound)
{
std::cout << std::endl << "Warning: Degenerate UV map in " << name << ".  Author needs to separate texture points in mesh's UV map." << std::endl;
}
m_vbitangents.resize( m_vertices.size() );
// For every vertex, check how many faces touches
// it and calculate the average of their tangents.
for (size_t vertInd = 0; vertInd < m_vertices.size(); ++vertInd)
{
Vec4 tangent( 0.0f, 0.0f, 0.0f, 0.0f );
Vec3 bitangent;
for (size_t faceInd = 0; faceInd < m_indices.size(); ++faceInd)
{
if (m_indices[ faceInd ].a == vertInd ||
m_indices[ faceInd ].b == vertInd ||
m_indices[ faceInd ].c == vertInd)
{
tangent   += m_tangents  [ faceInd ];
bitangent += m_bitangents[ faceInd ];
}
}
m_vertices[ vertInd ].tangent = tangent;
m_vbitangents[ vertInd ] = bitangent;
}

for (size_t v = 0; v < m_vertices.size(); ++v)
{
Vec4& tangent = m_vertices[ v ].tangent;
const Vec3& normal = m_vertices[ v ].normal;
const Vec4 normal4( normal.x, normal.y, normal.z, 0.0 );

// Gram-Schmidt orthonormalization.
tangent -= normal4 * normal4.dot( tangent );
tangent.normalize();
// Handedness. TBN must form a right-handed coordinate system,
// i.e. cross(n,t) must have the same orientation than b.
const Vec3 cp = normal.cross( Vec3( tangent.x, tangent.y, tangent.z ) );
tangent.w = cp.dot( m_vbitangents[v] ) > 0.0f ? 1.0f : -1.0f;
}
}


I'm calculating my bitangents in the vertex shader and multiplying them with the handedness sign. I'm transforming my camera and point light position from world space to object space by multiplying them with inverse model matrix before transforming them to tangent space. If I visualize my TBN vectors, normals are pointing away from the surface and tangents and bitangents are orthogonal.

void main()
{
gl_Position = u_modelViewProjectionMatrix * vec4( a_position, 1.0 );
v_texCoord = a_texCoord;
vec3 bitangent = normalize( cross( a_normal, a_tangent.xyz ) ) * a_tangent.w; // .w is the handedness.

mat3 toTangentSpace = mat3(
a_tangent.x, bitangent.x, a_normal.x,
a_tangent.y, bitangent.y, a_normal.y,
a_tangent.z, bitangent.z, a_normal.z
);

vec3 mDirToLight  = normalize( u_lightPosition.xyz  - a_position ); // Light position is in object-space.
vec3 mDirToCamera = normalize( u_cameraPosition.xyz - a_position ); // Camera position is in object-space.

v_dirToLight = toTangentSpace * mDirToLight;
v_viewDir	= toTangentSpace * mDirToCamera;
}


Edited by EngineCoder, 14 May 2012 - 12:23 PM.

My iOS 3D action/hacking game: http://itunes.apple....73873?ls=1&mt=8
Blog

#2LorenzoGatti  Members

4075
Like
0Likes
Like

Posted 15 May 2012 - 02:00 AM

tangent   = (deltaP1 * deltaUV2.v - deltaP2 * deltaUV1.v) / area;
bitangent = (deltaP1 * deltaUV2.u - deltaP2 * deltaUV1.u) / area;

I don't think you can trust your UV coordinates to point in the right direction: deltaUV1 and deltaUV2 and area can have "bad" signs and any sign change determines whether your normal (implicit from the choice of tangent and bitangent) points towards the front or the back.

Can you explain how do you relate UV coordinates to triangle facing?

Omae Wa Mou Shindeiru

#3EngineCoder  Members

246
Like
1Likes
Like

Posted 15 May 2012 - 11:22 AM

tangent   = (deltaP1 * deltaUV2.v - deltaP2 * deltaUV1.v) / area;
bitangent = (deltaP1 * deltaUV2.u - deltaP2 * deltaUV1.u) / area;

I don't think you can trust your UV coordinates to point in the right direction: deltaUV1 and deltaUV2 and area can have "bad" signs and any sign change determines whether your normal (implicit from the choice of tangent and bitangent) points towards the front or the back.

Can you explain how do you relate UV coordinates to triangle facing?

Most tutorials do it that way, like: http://www.terathon.com/code/tangent.html
My iOS 3D action/hacking game: http://itunes.apple....73873?ls=1&mt=8
Blog

Old topic!

Guest, the last post of this topic is over 60 days old and at this point you may not reply in this topic. If you wish to continue this conversation start a new topic.