Different character progress systems
Banned - Reputation: -585
Posted 29 November 2012 - 10:19 PM
progress systems such as skills based or level up, talent points etc..
What do you think would be the best?
First I want to talk about classes.
In Ultima Online for example the game was skill based instead of class based..
but you still could choose a class when creating char.. warrior, mage etc.. or do custom.
It didn't make you into that class though it just chose what skills you start with.
But even though the game was skill based.. we always called eachother names such as if we had a bunch of different classes.
Like mage, dexer, axer, nox mage, thief etc
So that can be the first thing you can choose to think about..
Maybe it's better to have games skillbased instead of class based.. because it stillis kindof class based even though its skill based but it opens up for a loooot more customization and classes that might not exist otherwise.
Now will do game be skillbased or levelup based?
I mean even though you could kinda do both for example that when you level up you receive points that you can place in skills.
You could do so from fighting you only get combat points to place in combat skills.. so you cant kill monsters to become a better tailor for example.
Or do you want it to be so you only improve the skill that you are using?
It works great for spells like magic and melee but I guess it works ok for other skills too it just makes the game really all about afk macroing then.
standing still afk macro hiding for example..
You could place skills in different groups somewhat what I mentioned just before..
So you have a combat group of skills that have a max cap of for example 300 skill points and each skill in that combat category has max cap of 100 each so you you can only max for example 3 skills out of the 7 that were available.. or bring 6 skills to 50skillpoints each. etc.
You could also use talent points like WoW did..
I mean you can really do a lot of creative things i havent even mentoined.
So lets all brainstorm and be creative together and talk about what IN YOUR OPINION is the best and why.
Moderators - Reputation: 4711
Posted 30 November 2012 - 02:31 AM
I generally like skill-based systems, though I have seen some pretty terrible ones too. I much prefer "flat" skill based systems to "tree" skill based systems. A tree system often requires players to permanently waste points on prerequisite skills they don't want before they are allowed to spend points on the skills they actually are interested in, and some tree systems require the player to choose between mutually exclusive branches. A "flat" system means 1 skill point can be spent by any character in the game to learn level one of any skill in the game. (Except skills which are rewards for specific quests or dungeons; it's very cool if some skills have to be unlocked by gameplay, though preferably it should not require a high level to do, if the game has levels. (Skill-based systems are highly compatible with levelless RPGs.) And doing quests or dungeons to unlock or upgrade a skill seems like a better option than grinding using that skill.
My ideal system would be one where playing long enough would enable me to have my character learn EVERYTHING. And it shouldn't take a month to earn a skill point at high levels either. Also I like a feature where I can "forget" all my skills, getting the skill points back to re-spend them. (Probably sacrificing reputation points to do so.)
Crafting IMO should have a different system from combat skills. Crafting should be advanced by crafting, but not grinding; it's much better to require the player to craft tools and appliances as prerequisites for crafting various types of items. For example, crafting a knife to enable skinning, crafting a firepit to enable basic cooking, crafting a cauldron to enable advanced cooking, crafting a kiln to enable pottery, etc. The player is paying time and materials to advance, but they have more fun and feel like they are getting more for their efforts than leveling up crafting by crafting 10 of the same useless item and failing at half of those attempts. (Yuck.) It might be ok for exploring skills, like swimming, shapeshifting into a faster form for traveling, improved sensing of gatherables, etc. to be paid for from the same skill point pool as combat skills; this could cause an economic problem if skill points are hard linked to player levels though.
A different idea for a skill-based combat system is a tactical combat system where the skills are placed onto units (e.g. pet monsters or hired NPC fighters) rather than onto the player. The number of skills which can be placed onto any one unit can be limited, and that limit could be increased through some kind of gameplay (either leveling up the player's monster-breeding skill, or gaining exp on that individual unit, or capturing a higher-level variant of that unit from the wild, or crafting a "+1 skill slot potion" and using it on the unit, etc.) The skills themselves might be craftable too, perhaps as a scroll or rune or gem of some sort. I think this kind of system might be more interesting than just putting the skills on the player, because you might want to use a skill on more than one unit of your team, and whenever you get a better or prettier base unit you might need to buy or make a whole set of skills for it... it's just a more complex system and thus has a lot of potential to be interesting for players to interact with.
Phone game idea available free to someone who will develop it (Alphadoku game - the only existing phone game of this type is both for windows phone only and awful. PM for details.)
I want to help design a "sandpark" MMO. Optional interactive story with quests and deeply characterized NPCs, plus sandbox elements like player-craftable housing and lots of other crafting. If you are starting a design of this type, please PM me. I also love pet-breeding games.