Members - Reputation: 267
Posted 29 July 2014 - 01:45 PM
This is an UI heavy strategy/rpg. Although the game is played on a (simple) 2D map, it is largely turn based and only vrey rudimentary animations occur.
Interaction mostly occurs by selecting actions on secondary screens. The UI isn't very complex in itself but comprise a large number of screens.
Due to the largely static gameplay I hope to add a bit of animation an particle effects to updates and other changes.
It is common to add lots of decoration to the UI for this type of games, but I have avoided that for a cleaner look.
Previously my games have been smaller and fairly simple. In these cases, the standard UI lib - with a few tweaks - have been enough, and for this project I also know that it's quite possible to use the normal UI lib to implement the game.
However, my fear is that in choosing a standard UI lib the types and amounts of effects will be affected, so that the UI ends upp avoiding the more extravagant features that I would not think twice before adding had I used a 2D graphics engine for games.
On the other hand, sticking to the UI framework would minimize power consumtion, and provide a lot of nice text components.
On the other hand, the game is fairly power hungry for other reasons, and there is minimal text input.
For the first version here it's for iOS - so UIKit vs Cocos2D/SpriteKit.
Members - Reputation: 580
Posted 30 July 2014 - 06:01 AM
I am not sure I understand your question/concerns. Provided you are only targetting iOS platforms, I suppose the standard UIKit would be suitable and provide you with sufficient functionality/flexibility to roll your own themes/styles.
Also, you seem to be opposing UIKit & the Cocos2D framework - why not use both?
I have had good experiences using both the UIKit and Coreframework (for generating/rasterizing the GUI's theme/skin sheet procedurally) - on the other hand, if you are looking to target other platforms (eg. Android) you may want to either ensure the platform-specific details of the GUI are decoupled from the game as much as possible, and/or look for a cross-platform GUI solution.