Jump to content
  • Advertisement
  • 08/04/19 04:56 AM

    The One Sound All Games Need and How To Use It

    Audio

    Panagiotis Kouvelis

    Immersion in games is all about making the brain of the player believe – at least in some amount – that she or he is there.

    We sound designers, have a couple of basic tricks up our sleeves, to create that exact effect in the listener’s brain.

    One of those tricks is a basic noise drone, that carries the identity of the place that the action takes place. Audio engineers and sound designers in films, refer to it as the “roomtone” and it is also know as the “presence”.

    We, at SoundFellas Immersive Audio Labs, like to call that type of sound the “noise print”. The “noise” part of the name comes from the fact that this kind of sound is categorized as noise. And the “print” part of the name relates to the indentation or mark made on a surface or soft substance, like with a fingerprint. Hence, noise print.

    I find that part of any soundscape very important, that is why I regularly extract the noise prints from any environmental recording I capture for my ambience libraries, and I include those extracted loops as isolated/separate sound files. To do that I use specialized techniques and tools, usually used in forensic audio analysis. Those technologies combined with specific techniques allow me to extract only the frequencies that give the identity of the place and nothing more or less.

    If you do that, the soundscapes you are going to create for your game, will be very agile. Creators working in games or film, can use them in combination with the isolated sound effects that can also be extracted, to create a vibrant and dynamic soundscape for the players. In essence, the game developer can develop stochastic algorithms that play back noise prints and isolated sound effects together to render the environment’s sound dynamically according to the state of the game. Creators working in augmented, virtual or mixed reality experiences get great benefit from the agility this methodology offers, to create dynamic and life-like environments that blend with the real or virtual environments of their choosing.

    Quote

    NOISE PRINTS (AKA ROOMTONES) ARE BASIC NOISE DRONES THAT CARRY THE IDENTITY OF THE PLACE THAT THE ACTION TAKES PLACE.

    Immerse%20the%20player%20into%20your%20g

    Is your player exploring a haunted castle at dusk or ready to take a lethal jump from a skyscraper to complete the mission? In which era is the action taking place? What time of day? Is there civilization near or it’s a post-apocalyptic setting? All this information can be delivered via the environmental noise print. - Image(s) by Alexander Andrews, Filip Mroz and R. H. Lee on Unsplash.

    First a definition

    But to unlock the full potential of the noise prints, to create an immersive atmosphere for your games, we must go a little further down the rabbit hole.

    First, let’s look into a definition, Wikipedia offers a good one:

    In filmmaking and television production, presence, also known as room tone, is the “silence” recorded at a location or space when no dialog is spoken. Presence is similar to ambience, but is distinguished by a lack of explicit background noise.

    Every location has a distinct presence created by the position of the microphone in relation to the space boundaries. A microphone placed in two different parts of the same room will record two distinct presences. This is because of the unique spatial relationship between the microphone and boundaries such as walls, ceilings, and floors, and other objects in a room.

    Presence is recorded during the production stage of filmmaking. It is used to help create the film sound track, where presence may be intercut with dialog to smooth out any sound edit points. The sound track “going dead” would be perceived by the audience not as silence, but as a failure of the sound system. - Excerpt from Wikipedia.

    Different%20environments%20have%20differ

    Different types of environments, have different noise prints. A cathedral, a laboratory, a forest, a big city experienced from the rooftops. A major part of the aesthetic is the noise print, also called roomtone or presence. - Image(s) by Michael D Beckwith, Stefan Kunze, Sergei Akulich and R. H. Lee on Unsplash.

    Basic attributes

    As we see, noise prints are very important parts of a good design. Actually, together with the reverberation (more on that in another article) carry most of the weight of creating immersion.

    Anyone that played Limbo, Alan Wake, Mirror’s Edge, The Swapper, Metro: Last Light, Far Cry, SOMA, The Vanishing of Ethan Carter, Metroid Prime, Silent Hill, Doom and of course BioShock to name a few, experienced that deep immersion feeling I’m talking about. Those games utilize great use of different noise print loops to create the first layer of the environmental sound and signify the player of the location and point in the story’s timeline.

    Let’s highlight the most important parts of the definition that we gave above.

    It’s distinguished by a lack of explicit background noise.

    That means that the noise print loop should not have any features that can be perceived as being something specific. Only the pure noise (random energy) should be included in this sound, to allow for the ambiguity that this kind of sound has in nature. Of course, if a noise print for example, represents an industrial production setting, it can have low frequency rumbling coming from the machines. But it shouldn’t contain and pattern of repeatable sounds that gives out specific behaviors of the machines, like the pumping of a molding press or the air release of a pneumatic robot arm. Those sounds can be played back on top of the noise prints and given randomization sound properties and 3D location within the game’s world, to simulate better the environment and its behaviors and to create a dynamic soundscape for the player to immerse in.

    Every location has a distinct sound, it’s like a fingerprint.

    Not only you should not use the same noise print for each type of environment, but also probably change it as the time of day changes in the environment you create. Of course you could utilize using the same noise print for specific or similar environments within your game, as a way to mentally tag those environments and put them under the same family. That creates a good atmosphere that also works like a user interface element. Informing the player that ‘now you are in that kind of place’. Very powerful if you classify your game’s locations right. A good idea further down this methodology, is to group your game’s locations according to the narrative of your game.

    Digital (complete) silence is going to be perceived by the audience as failure of the sound system.

    Or even worse, failure of the creators to produce a quality product. A safety rule is that your executable should be engineered to ensure that a noise print will always playback no matter what happens. Even in states that only music would suffice, playing the noise print of the level that is loading, or a generic noise print that sets the mood of the game, will bind the music even more with the atmosphere of the game and the emotional side of your game’s story. It will make music stronger for the player. Furthermore, if the sound stops completely in some point, usually on loading levels, loaders, menus, etc. The player will start noticing the sounds from her own room, the street noise from outside of the room, the air-condition unit, the computer’s fans cooling the processors, and many other noises that take away her brain from the world of the game and pulls it back in the real world. Very uncool.

    Quote

    NOISE PRINTS TOGETHER WITH THE REVERBERATION CARRY MOST OF THE WEIGHT OF CREATING IMMERSION.

    Best practices

    OK great, we got a good handle on what kind of sounds the noise prints are. As promised from the article’s title, here are the basic tips on how to use them in order to get the most of them, brought to you directly from the SoundFellas internal knowledge-base.

    Combine them with the reverberation

    Use them with reverb. That will glue them with the rest of the sounds that pass through the same reverb, which creates a psychological bond of the location and the player, making a part of the player’s mind believe that it is located at that place. If you have locations in your game that can be categorized in specific types of environments (For example, some of the rooms belong to an industrial setting and some of the rooms belong to a vast forest), you can filter the same noise print with different reverberation settings, relative to the material properties of each of your game’s rooms. That way, all rooms that share the same setting use the same noise print but have different reverb. Using this technique you can create variation throughout your game’s rooms and location sets, but with consistency between them, increasing the perceived quality of your game’s atmosphere.

    Smoothly transition between noise prints

    Use a scripted mechanic to cross-fade between them when the player is changing between distinctive locations. You can get the distance between the 2 location clear limits and the position of the player character in your game, and transform those numbers to a percentage of how much to lower the volume of each noise print’s loop, according to the position of the player’s character. That way you provide smooth transitions between the locations the player character is moving. Be careful, if the noise prints are very similar, during same volume levels flanging may appear. To avoid it, test your level’s transitions in a good listening environment or with a set of headphones.

    Use specified loudness levels

    Keep the loudness level true for all noise prints, unless you are intentionally going for some creative sound design. Yes, a forest’s noise print played back louder that it should could be perceive like a broken refrigerator or a metal construction site and vice-versa. Of course, if you feel adventurous, you can try using various noise print in different volume levels, to dress-up locations in your game’s world and listen to the result. A little random experimentation never hurt any designer, it’s actually a recommended practice for discovering new experiences. A quick advice, be cautious when raising the volume level as it can introduce clipping distortion (a nasty noise) even when the audio meter shows a signal level below zero. Also don’t forget that sound mixing eventually works in an additive way, adding signals together. So the end result of your game’s sound is the sum of all signals that play back together. A good practice is to always check the final audio bus of the framework’s mixing system for good volume levels.

    Never stop never-stopping

    Use the noise prints sound even in the loading screens, as a way to introduce the next level/room, or use a specific noise print that sets the mood for all the game. Even better, create an application-wide fallback algorithm that fades in a specific noise print every time that the game has no sound at all or the state machine loads utility screens like menus, credits, network settings, etc. To do that, you should check out the documentation of the game development framework you use, in order to find out if it supports sound instances that are not destroyed during scene/level loading.

    Classify, organize and rule them all

    Group them differently to create consistency and empower the emotional aspect of the game. Some taxonomy ideas include but are not limited to:

    • Open, closed and special spaces.
    • Kind of environment, urban, industrial, natural, unnatural.
    • Day or night.
    • Friendly and hostile environments.
    • Game states.
    • Story-line position.

    You get the idea. 😉

    Conclusion

    I think that we can all agree, that the subject of noise print usage in games is a very interesting one, and I would urge you to experiment with it and see by yourself what it can bring to your game’s aesthetics.

    You could combine, create your own, and develop an algorithm that switches between the roomtones according to tags that flow back from the game logic, or even mix 2 or 3 roomtones according to what combination of location types and game states. That can create very strong immersion not only for the virtual location, but also used as a subconscious way of guiding your story.

    So, what do you think about noise prints? Are you using them in your games? Do you have any experience to share by implementing noise prints in your game's code? Any ideas you like to share?

    Write in the comments below, I'll be very happy to discuss with the vibrant community of game developers!



      Report Article


    User Feedback


    Very interesting article! Thank you very much for sharing your insights :)

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    25 minutes ago, ptietz said:

    Very interesting article! Thank you very much for sharing your insights :)

    Thank you! I'm glad that you found my article interesting and I hope also informative. 🙂

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Interesting read, I didn't know such a thing existed. I tried looking for some examples of noise prints/room tones, but they didn't seem audible at all. Even at max volume, maybe it's supposed to be that way? Does it only work in combination with other sounds? Could be that my office environment is just too loud.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    On 8/9/2019 at 1:14 PM, Mussi said:

    I tried looking for some examples of noise prints/room tones, but they didn't seem audible at all. Even at max volume, maybe it's supposed to be that way? Does it only work in combination with other sounds? Could be that my office environment is just too loud.

    Thanks!

    It's very interesting that you mention the volume of noise prints. Actually, if you make big changes in volume the noise print of a forest can sound like something entirely different. Did you tried our own noise prints? You can download enough samples to experiment (and use them commercially in your projects), from our free "Starter Megapack" bundle, that we offer at our website at SoundFellas. In our libraries we normalize the loudness of the noise prints using what is called a perceived loudness algorithm, with some enhancements of our own 😉

    That allows you to:

    1. Handle all noise prints easy together, in groups or by code.
    2. Use subtractive mixing, which is the best way to mix, especially for interactive audio playback (default game playback mode).

    The way that you should use our noise prints, is to drop them in your project and then subtract volume from the mixer, until it sounds fit for the soundscape that you are building.

    For the listening environment, it depends. You have to try many different listening scenarios and equipment cases, in order to pass some mandatory quality control for the sound of your game.

    Which game engine do you use?

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Turns out my office environment was just too loud, at home with my headset on I can clearly hear the sounds.

    Thank you for the elaborate answer! I have next to no experience in dealing with sound so this all new and interesting for me.

    On 8/11/2019 at 9:55 AM, Panagiotis Kouvelis said:

    Which game engine do you use?

    I've worked with multiple, depending on the project (Unity, Unreal, Tombstone). Are there engine specific tools that you'd recommend diving into?

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    On 8/13/2019 at 1:16 AM, Mussi said:

    Turns out my office environment was just too loud, at home with my headset on I can clearly hear the sounds.

    I'm very glad to hear that you are starting to notice those things. Your environment may or may not be similar to the one of the player(s). An interesting thought to say the least. 😉

    On 8/13/2019 at 1:16 AM, Mussi said:

    I've worked with multiple, depending on the project (Unity, Unreal, Tombstone). Are there engine specific tools that you'd recommend diving into?

    If I had to recommend something it would be anything that has:

    • Ability to playback noise print loops using 2 buffers to crossfade between them when they change to ensure no clicking noise from the player's sound card.
    • Random sound containers with 3D randomization of the source to randomly layer one-shots over the noise prints.
    • Reverb that can be applied to a location and morphed / interchange when player is on another location.

    That basic functionality allows for good implementation of ambience sounds. At least the modular way we at SoundFellas produce our ambience libraries, for maximum immersion.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites


    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Advertisement
×

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

GameDev.net is your game development community. Create an account for your GameDev Portfolio and participate in the largest developer community in the games industry.

Sign me up!