Jump to content
  • Advertisement
  • 08/06/99 02:40 PM
    Sign in to follow this  

    Game Design Docs (USENET Discussions)

    Game Design and Theory

    <%Topic="Game Design DOC's (USENET Discussions)"%>
    Game Design DOC
    from Usenet Discussion on comp.games.development.design

    I am in the process of writing a game design doc.. And I was wondering if anybody knew of any sites that I may use as a reference in how to set up the document properly. Basically what to include, how detailed it should be etc.

    1. Look at www.gamasutra.com. They 're putting some articles of gdmag on their site.

    The article's title about game design documents is " Creating a Great Design Document " By Tzvi Freeman , August, 1997.

    2. Check out "Inside Electronic Game Design", Arnie Katz, Laurie Yates, Prima publishing, ISBN 1-55958-669-9

    Complete manual to write a game proposal + tips + general game design issues + more

    > I know this has been discussed before, but I couldn't find any references
    > in my archives: where can I get a sample (or real) game design document?
    > Any examples or suggestions would be appreciated (this might also be a
    > good topic for the FAQ).

    It's true, I don't know of where you can find any. But they might not be of a lot of help anyway.

    As I understand it (and as I've found), game design docs vary widely depending on genre, resources (if you're using a pre-designed engine or system of some sort, much less has to be designed), and designer.

    Obviously, a game design doc for a skill-based tabletop RPG will be of little help to a flight simulator designer. Just as a design for a side-scrolling action game won't help a collectible card game designer much.

    Basically, be as structured as you can, as logical as you can, and as complete as you can. Don't code any algorithms for your design document, but be as specific as possible about everything you design. In a hack-and-slash RPG, sketch out monsters. In a tabletop wargame, describe what the counters will look like (e.g. what numbers will be included, and where).

    Communication is key. It is enough to be the keeper of the vision if you're a novelist. You don't need people skills. But game creation, like film-making, is a team sport. There is enough room for artistic latitude for everyone involved. The hierarchy must be clear however. And there must always be a final voice. This sure strikes a familiar note, doesn't it? Back to that GDC roundtable about fascism vs. communism in game design? But as I said then, artists on film crews compartimentalize. They've understood hierarchy and happily worked within one for decades. An Art Director or Cinematographer concentrates on his or her area of expertise, and can be personally gratified and publicly awarded for success apart from the success of the complete product. In this unstructured morass we call a gaming "industry" everyone not only wants to be the keeper of the vision, but they're encouraged to be -on every single product they work on-. And this isn't art. It's anarchy.

    Brian Upton wrote:

    > "Brandon Van Every" wrote:
    > >Recently instead of desiging 3d graphics technologies I found myself working
    > >on a bona fide game design. Boy, it was/is a lot of work! I was surprised
    > >at how much work it took. To arrive at a good game design, I found it
    > >taking as much time as to plan a 3d collision engine, invent an algorithmic
    > >scheme for polygon visibility, etc. More experienced game designers among
    > >you might say "well duh, what did you expect" but heretofore I always
    > >thought game design was the relatively easy part of the job. I realize now
    > >that it's a position one could be paid to do fulltime, because it's that
    > >much work.
    > >Does anyone have any keen insights into the lifecycle of the game design
    > >process? How long it'll take you? How you know when you're stuck, and how
    > >to overcome it? When you can know the answers and when you can't, i.e.
    > >you're waiting on some other aspect of the game to become clear?
    > Right now I'm working on defining Red Storm's default production
    > pipeline. It's a template for how the average project should run and
    > is intended to provide a framework for planning.

    You're wise in what you're doing here Brian. I've found this to be extremely important in the process of producing a quality product. If you don't, 'others' in the company will determine the timeline and it _won't_ be based upon design needs. Designer will then find themselves struggling to design game components after the coders come asking for them. NOT the way to get a cogent design done.
    > We're allocating three months preproduction for the average project.
    > The bulk of the game design is done during that time (along with the
    > technical design, the style guide, the budget and the schedule). It's
    > assumed that the designer will continue to contribute to fleshing out
    > and tuning the title as it progresses but will also have time to
    > initiate the process of other projects.

    Three months should be enough for all games except perhaps some of the highly detailed simulations. The research for them may take a bit longer. Make sure the designer has access to the team members during this time so the game design fits within the technical capabilities and to get ideas from them. There's usually more than one way to skin a cat and if the programmers who's going to do the code has a method that results in the same outcome then incorporate that into the design. It will help reduce the questions and misunderstandings further down the road.

    I'm a firm believer in the designer staying involved in the project right to the end. A designer is the 'keeper of the flame' and will be able to spot divergences from the design quicker than anyone else.
    > It's hard to describe how I know I'm stuck. It's like handling a
    > wooden ball and feeling a rough bit. A good design feels smooth no
    > matter which way you turn it.

    Well said.
    > >I would also add that coming up with an idea for a game is NOT game design.
    > >That's only the 1st step. Game design is taking an idea for a game, and
    > >turning it into a fully specified system of rules that results in a "fun"
    > >game.
    > Hmmm ... would you say the "fun" is *emergent* from the rules ... ?
    > :)
    > >What are your favorite game design tools? Mine are pencil, paper, and
    > >modeling clay.
    > A whiteboard.

    Indispensable!! ;-)

    Jim Harler

      Report Article
    Sign in to follow this  

    User Feedback

    There are no comments to display.

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Advertisement
  • Advertisement
  • intellogo.png

    Are you ready to promote your game?

    Submit your game for Intel® certification by December 21, 2018 and you could win big! 

    Click here to learn more.

  • Latest Featured Articles

  • Featured Blogs

  • Advertisement
  • Popular Now

  • Similar Content

    • By GameDev.net
      Originally published on NotesonGameDev.net October 27, 2008
      Jenova Chen, creator behind the multi award-winning student game Cloud and flOw, co-founder of thatgamecompany, is dedicated to expanding the emotional spectrum of video games and making them available for a much wider audience. And how did Jenova "make it" as an independent developer? With a lot of support and a drive for innovation.
      Can you tell us a little bit about your interest in game development and where it all started?
      When I was 10 years old, my Dad, who worked in the software industry, took me to a special Computer Programming school for kids hoping I'd become Bill Gate's one day. However, I had no interest in learning programming; instead I got to play my very first computer game at the school. And from that point on, video games were pretty much my obsession.
      My first attempt in making video games happened when I was 12, and my enthusiasm quickly faded due to a bad 5 inch floppy disk which carried a week's worth of my work. When I went to college around 1999, I was pretty much bored with the math and programming, and I started to put all my spare time on digital animation and 3D graphics.
      At the time, there were no domestic video game development studios in China and video game education was also a vacuum. And by accident, I met some very enthusiastic students in the college who wanted to make video games. It seemed like a good place where I could put my digital art skill to use. Once the training started, the adventure and joy from game development has never stopped.
      Speaking of college... What was your role in Cloud and how did it come to be?
      My first big student team project in the grad school at USC Interactive Media Division was not Cloud but Dyadin (IGF 2005), where my role was lead artist. It was the first video game made by student team in our division. The big success brought a lot of attention to the school, therefore the school started a grant to encourage students to team up and make more innovative games. The grant was open to the entire university.
      As one of the applicants I came up the rough idea of making a game about clouds and rallied around students and faculties. Once the cloud game idea won the grant and got funded by the school, we put a team together. My role was team lead. As a result I worked with the team on many aspects of the game: gameplay prototyping, game design, story and all the visual arts.
      What do you think made Cloud the 2006 IGF Student Showcase Winner?
      Being one of a kind--a fresh emotional experience that's different from anything on the mainstream market.
      Following Cloud, you went right on to working on flOw. How did Cloud's success influence you?
      It's not the success part of Cloud influenced me but the failure of Cloud. So many people downloaded our game, including people who never played games. I guess they were lured to the childhood fantasy. As a result, their lack of game knowledge prevented them from enjoying the relaxing experience---instead, their frustration of learning how to control the game ruined the experience.
      I learned from Cloud that there is a huge market for games that evoke a different emotional experience. However, new markets mean new audience. In order to search for a design methodology that enables a game to satisfy both experienced gamers and not so experienced ones, I started the flOw project.
      Interesting concept to work with! How was flOw conceptualized and developed?
      As part of my master degree thesis at USC, flOw, the original web game, was made for the sole purpose of testing whether the design methodology I developed based on Flow theory works. In the academia, there was a lot of many research about how to use an A.I. to read player's performance and alter the gaming experience. However, through playing those games myself, I feel there are so many cases where the A.I. can't assess player's true feeling based on rigid formulas.
      As a side effect, the false reaction of the A.I. broke my "sense of control", a key condition to enter the Flow state. Therefore, through learning successful video games with mass appeal, I came up a different approach to adjust the difficulties of the game. I call it Active Dynamic Difficulty Adjustment, which uses player's choice to change the difficulty of the gaming experience.
      The trick is to embed the difficulty adjustment choices in the core gameplay mechanics so that when player makes those choices, he won't feel interrupted from the core gameplay. In flOw, player's only action is swimming and eating, and the way the player engages different content with different difficulties is also through swimming and eating. And the result of the testing was amazing
      flOw is now available on PS3, something that indie developers aspire to. How did you make the leap to console?
      My business partner Kellee Santiago and I were very lucky to have studied at the USC Interactive Media Division where we took a class called business of interactive entertainment. It's that class that opened our eyes that starting up a company and chasing your dream is not a fairy tale; instead it's something totally possible for normal people like us who had no money, but a passion.
      We had a sneak peek at the great potential and promising future of video games through Cloud. And we really hope the maturing of video games as an interactive medium could happen faster. We want to push the boundary of video games and allow more people around the world to see games like Cloud, to awaken the dormant market so that more people can join us to further expand video games' emotional range and meet various needs from the public. Not just things made for excitement and leisure but also things that are thought evoking and deeply emotional. With that goal, we started to pitch the grand idea of Cloud, the commercial version to almost all the publishers in North America.
      Quickly, we realized that based on the experience we had fresh out of school and the ridiculous budget we asked, there was simply no one who would take the risk with us. It had to be the timing and pure luck that we encountered the opportunity of making games for the digital distribution platform for next generation console like Wii and PS3. Both of Sony and Nintendo were going to launch their new gaming consoles, and they were both dying for new content on their digital distribution channel.
      The fact that flOw was a rather complete game concept made with two students in three months helped us to convince Sony that they could trust us for a much smaller game than Cloud. And then the leap was made.
      Well that's great! What are you working on now?
      We are finishing up our second title for Sony's Playstation Network, Flower. A game that is a sister piece after Cloud and flOw. Our version of a video game poem dealing with our inner desires towards the wild nature and urban life.
      What would you say is the biggest challenge you've faced so far as an indie?
      The biggest challenge is to grow up, to become experienced from inexperience. We made so many mistakes in running a startup company and in game development. Though we've overcome all the challenges, the taste is still yummy pain.
      Heh heh. What about your biggest triumph then?
      Thatgamecompany is still up and running. And we are making games that we believe will push the boundary of what video games can communicate.
      What advice do you have out there for those aspiring to join game industry as an indie?
      Really consider indie game developer within our industry. Just look around at what's happened in the past two years. How many of your favorite indie games have shown up on the commercial platforms? How many highly reviewed video games are from independent studios? This is the golden time of independent video games. We see so many talented new faces coming out of school and even veterans who left the big studios to form their company and chase their dreams. The renaissance of video games is already happening.
    • By blesseddisciple
      So I have a decent amount of JavaScript experience now and decided I was gonna lower my head and start cranking out some 2d games, partly to learn, partly to have fun. Afterall, HTML5 canvas is such an easy and enticing medium. I love the JavaScript implementation of it. But after literally struggling for a week to get basic game functionality working I have had enough of the little stupid bugs that pop up with JavaScript. Don't get me wrong, I still love the language for scripting. I'm just not going to spend 20 mins coding and 5 hours debugging just because the language is crap.
      I've decided to return to my previous endeavor, Java. I like Java a lot and the only reason I haven't pursued more in the way of game development is just for the fact that Java is limited to mobile or PC apps that may never see the light of day unless it's hosted on some obscure Java game hosting website that is populated with 2,000 half developed games that no one will ever care about. BUT, still, I enjoy hand coding and I know C# but don't feel like using Visual studio and I really don't wanna hand code C# on the .Net or whatever. I use Visual Studio for business apps (ASP.NET) but I don't wanna build a game with it.
      So, does anyone have any points to share about why moving to Java for game development is not smart? Besides the whole, "Java is slow" thing. I mean things that might make it harder in JAva to make games vs. in other languages. Please share your thoughts. 
    • By andrii_k
      Hi all! We are a team of two programmers developing a turn-based browser strategy, and we need someone to help with the art.

      It is a card+board strategy. Every player has a castle, and in their turn can move units and play cards.
      Current art is partially placeholder, partially original (contributed by some friends),
      but we'd love to have somebody joining the team and taking care of the visual side.
      Main tasks are drawing cards, objects on the board and interface elements.
        A prototype is available here https://lords.world (needs at least two people to play properly, but you can play against a dummy bot to get an idea).
      Please pm if interested. Best regards,
      Andrii and Serge

    • By Octolancers
      Hi there, my name is René, and Im a pixel artist, this is my first post here and Im kind of exploring my own freelancing possibilities in the field.
      Please excuse my english, Im from the chaotic Venezuela, I'm currently living in Colombia, and looking forward to know another beautiful country and culture.
      I have years of experience working professionally on 2d and 3d animated pieces for a wide variety of cases, but I'm a bit tired of rendering times, illumination artifacts, rigging and binding stuff here and there, processor slowness, plugins mismatch, plugin bugs, plugins outdated, licensing updates, corporative projects, that's a good reason, and found a lovely branch on the field that embraced my like a cotton cloud on a shiny day, Pixel Art.
      Then I begun a surprisingly productive journey on Fiverr a few months ago, until a guy got my attention with a interesting project that I'm about to begin. So I had to put my Fiverr status on standby for a while.
      While we take our time to start that project, my mind and hart asks for a taste of the Patreon experience, and so I've been thinking for a while of doing something related to the Cyberpunk dystopia, but as I have no time to do another project, I thought releasing graphic assets packs in some way, so I've been relating this and that and figuring maybe in some developers community I could let know this to begin with.
      There are so many styles and mechanics on the gaming possibilities that I want to release a wide range of assets for general purposes, but inside a unique world theme, so I made my mind over this Cyberpunk topic now, but if things go well, I would need to ask to the audience for a new Theme.
      This is my on my avatar hehe by the way, just a pic to express a bit of my animation skills.
      I established my corner on Patreon already, but I have little knowledge of the platform, so any suggestions are welcome, and you are welcome as well to visit and comment any inquiry related to the topic.
      Check it here: My Patreon
      Thanks for reading. Have a nice day!
    • By jb-dev
      I've recently added a mini map on the right upper corner of the screen.
      With this the player can now see in which room it's currently in.
      That mini map get updated when the player moves to another room.
      In the future most rooms will be hidden until the player discovers it by either moving to a new room or, in the case of hidden rooms break a breakable wall or open the locked door.

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

GameDev.net is your game development community. Create an account for your GameDev Portfolio and participate in the largest developer community in the games industry.

Sign me up!