Jump to content
  • Advertisement
  • 07/16/99 05:58 PM
    Sign in to follow this  

    Lifecycle and Duration of Game Design

    Game Design and Theory

    GameDev.net
    Lifecycle and duration of game design
    from Usenet Posting on comp.games.development.design

    >Recently instead of desiging 3d graphics technologies I found myself
    >workingon a bona fide game design. Boy, it was/is a lot of work! I
    >was surprisedat how much work it took.

    Yep, that's usually the feeling. We designers can't get no respect in this industry ;-)

    >I realize now that it's a position one could be paid to do fulltime,
    >because it's that much work.

    Not many companies are willing to do it, though, and I am not sure that I disagree entirely with their point of view. Although personally, I would like nothing more than to spend all of my time designing games, there are good reasons why a designer should take on another role. For example:

    1. Most of the design work takes place before production begins. Once the design doc is written, keeping it up to date, making the occasional judgment call and making sure that the product follows your vision nicely isn't really a full-time job. Two days a week, maybe three on a big project, but not much more. So, unless you are a consultant working part-time, either you lead the art or coding team, or you get to work on the *next* design project; and since that one is all new and exciting, you devote most of your effort to it, and you spend less and less time on the game in production. That means that the *producer* now has free reins ;-) and that the game is left without global creative direction. Not a good thing.
    2. Despite common misconceptions, design work can be quite exacting. Unless you are unusually versatile and resourceful, you will need some time to recharge your creative batteries after a large project. Otherwise, you may burn out, and turn out a Project N+1 which looks surprisingly like Project N.
    3. Sometimes, having a full-time designer on a project in production is a catastrophe waiting to happen, because he may get bored, and if so, he'll keep designing. He'll keep thinking of really cool new traps for the next level (which requires the level designers to re-write their floor plans and 3D models), or he'll have this great new idea for a monster's attack (which requires re-writing the character animations and changing the sound effects, and maybe adding a new feature to the level editor), etc.

    At a rate of 2-3 full designs a year, plus however many dozens of failed treatments would be required to hit the 2-3 good ideas, you could justify a full-time designer easily; with an average product budget of 2 million bucks, the 25-50K the design will cost is insignificant from a financial standpoint. But to be a good full-time designer, you need to be very versatile, have lots of energy, be able to focus on several projects in parallel, and to know when to *let go* and stop tinkering with a product. Not many people I have met can do that.

    >Does anyone have any keen insights into the lifecycle of the game design
    >process? How long it'll take you?

    I have spent 50-100 hours on trivia games and play-by-emails, 150 hours on action games (I can't draw, so that doesn't include actual mapping of levels, graphic bibles and stuff like that), about 200-250 on sports simulations, and I expect to spend about 300 on the online world I will be working on in the next few months (including a fair but limited number of scenarios for missions). I have also noted that 25 hours a week is about as much efficient design time as I have in me; the law of diminishing returns takes over in a big way at that point.

    I have posted an article on my game design methodology on my web site at http://pages.infinit.net/idjy/games/designprocedure.html

    Not very detailed, because it is based on a two-hour lecture I give at a local school, but it may give you a few insights.

    >How you know when you're stuck, and how to overcome it?

    In software engineering terms, game development is the stereotypical "exploratory prototyping" project. You may not understand the requirements of the project very well when you start out, so you design/prototype/playtest iteratively. The prototype may be code, cardboard, playing cards, or just a preliminary design doc, depending on the type of project.

    >What are your favorite game design tools? Mine are pencil, paper, and
    >modeling clay.

    Mine are an iterative design methodology of which I have gathered parts here and there and which I am comfortable with, word processor, a well-stocked bookcase and lots of cardboard.

    With all the games coming out with scripting languages these days, it might be a good idea to use an existing commercial product of the same genre as a prototyping tool for your own game; this way, you can try out a few things before writing a line of code, and you can keep experimenting as you go along. Never tried that one before, but I will probably do it in the future. Techniques I use include building a table-top board game as a prototype; works much better for trivia games and simulations than for FPS's, but can be done in a few hours. I also run through several versions of design docs, each with its own specific purpose (i.e., qualitative listing of functionality, scheduling priorities, describing major AI algorithms, etc.), and distribute them to as many competent designers as time and legal restrictions allow.

    --
    Francois Dominic Laramee
    Game Designer and Artificial Intelligence Researcher
    francoislaramee@DEATHTOSPAMMERS.videotron.ca
    http://pages.infinit.net/idjy



      Report Article
    Sign in to follow this  


    User Feedback


    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Advertisement
  • Advertisement
  • Latest Featured Articles

  • Featured Blogs

  • Advertisement
  • Popular Now

  • Similar Content

    • By JohnSmith011
      Talking Smileys is a free emoji app in which you get to have access to tons of different animated smileys in different categories and for different moods and situations. 

      So, if you are looking for an entertainment app to send funny animated emoji and emoticons, download Emoji Talking Smileys for free on your Android device, browse through available categories and have fun sending cool talking stickers. Download the best Funny Emoji Gif app and let's Enjoy :)

      Talking Smileys main features at a glance:
      """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
      • Easy to use talking animated emojis with voice
      • High-quality smileys and emoticons
      • Different categories including Love, Anger, Holiday, LOL, Animals, Sport, Girls, Kids, and Funny
      • Share favorite emoji to social networks
      • Search emoji
      • Always updating with new funny stickers
      • Fun for all ages
    • By Shaarigan
      Dear reader,
      for an upcomming ARPG hobby project I'm looking for a 2D/Concept Artist to design the game's characters, races, monsters and places. Are you in search of a challenge and want to work on a game with a unique story told in it's own universe developed with state-of-the-art technology? Then this might be your chance!
      I'm a long time gamer, designer, developer, board game fan and hobbyist board game author, passionated in games since age of 6 with addiction to video games. Working as senior in the games industrie at day, at night tinkering at my very own game engine and ideas for games I want to make with it popping into my mind from time to time. While most of them stay at the idea level, a few have become real game projects at least in planning and I created w complex universe arround all those games during past 20 years.
       
      The Game
      The game this post is about is a hack-and-slay action role-playing game in a steam punkt and fantasy mixed setting of a world far in it's own history. A world once home for a high spiritually race called the ancestors, now a place of political riots, misery and cult of gods and other things that let the player explore the abyss of humanity facing a big evil that throws it's shadows over the imperial capital. The player will explore dark and scary places of long forgotten cultures with one of 6 playable races in cooperative multiplayer.
       
      Your Tasks
      Design the races and characters belonging to the story Design the enemies the player will fight against up to the boss monsters Design the places based on the story Design other elements of the game (like HUD look and feel)  
      Requirements
      At least some experience in 2D art and design Good communication skills and a reliable response time Disciplined self-reliant and motivated work style Fluent in spoken and written English A Discord account At least 5 hours per Week to work on this project  
      Considered a Plus
      Knowledge of the German language As passionated as I am for letting others be part of interesting worlds Working as professional in the industry too  
      I offer
      No money at the moment because I'm working in my spare time and at my own charge, but a friendly, motivated and passioned teammate in a highly professional work environment, technical knowledge from a long-term industrie professional and and a share once the game is in a polished state.
       
      Dear reader, thank you for taken the time to read the full post and if you have any questions or want to work with me/us, please feel free to send a PM or Discord Message with a short introduction and a brief time schedule so I/we have an overview to plan further development.
      Thank you in advance!
      P.S.
      See also https://www.gamedev.net/forums/topic/701862-writer-for-hackn-slay-arpg/
       
    • By Shaarigan
      Dear reader,
      for an upcomming ARPG hobby project I'm looking for a Story Writer/ Story Designer to give the story a heart and body. Are you in search of a challenge and want to work on a game with a unique story told in it's own universe developed with state-of-the-art technology? Then this might be your chance!
      I'm a long time gamer, designer, developer, board game fan and hobbyist board game author, passionated in games since age of 6 with addiction to video games. Working as senior in the games industrie at day, at night tinkering at my very own game engine and ideas for games I want to make with it popping into my mind from time to time. While most of them stay at the idea level, a few have become real game projects at least in planning and I created w complex universe arround all those games during past 20 years.
       
      The Game
      The game this post is about is a hack-and-slay action role-playing game in a steam punkt and fantasy mixed setting of a world far in it's own history. A world once home for a high spiritually race called the ancestors, now a place of political riots, misery and cult of gods and other things that let the player explore the abyss of humanity facing a big evil that throws it's shadows over the imperial capital. The player will explore dark and scary places of long forgotten cultures with one of 6 playable races in cooperative multiplayer.
       
      Your Tasks
      Transfer existing basic points of Races, Cultures and the History into an encyclopedia used by game designers and developers Fill in the gaps so that anything becomes plausible and interesting Plan and design the characters that will take part in the story Plan and design the places based on the encyclopedia Polish the games story  
      Requirements
      At least some experience in character design Good communication skills and a reliable response time Disciplined self-reliant and motivated work style Fluent in spoken and written English A Discord account At least 5 hours per Week to work on this project  
      Considered a Plus
      Knowledge of the German language As passionated as I am for letting others be part of interesting worlds Working as professional in the industry too  
      I offer
      No money at the moment because I'm working in my spare time and at my own charge, but a friendly, motivated and passioned teammate in a highly professional work environment, technical knowledge from a long-term industrie professional and and a share once the game is in a polished state.
       
      Dear reader, thank you for taken the time to read the full post and if you have any questions or want to work with me/us, please feel free to send a PM or Discord Message with a short introduction and a brief time schedule so I/we have an overview to plan further development.
      Thank you in advance!
    • By SixElephants
      The connections between a Grandfather and his Grandson withstood the greatest of hardships.
×

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

GameDev.net is your game development community. Create an account for your GameDev Portfolio and participate in the largest developer community in the games industry.

Sign me up!