Jump to content
  • Advertisement
  • entries
    383
  • comments
    1075
  • views
    353418

Wii want to use our left hand!

Sign in to follow this  
Trapper Zoid

235 views

Random Thought for the Day
I've started reading game manuals purely as light entertaining reading once again. I'm not sure that's healthy...


Inkscape Tutorial Comments and Suggestions Still Welcome!
I've put a link to the Inkscape tutorial at the top of my journal. Although I'll be posting about other things here I'm still happy to receive any feedback or suggestions as comments.


Wii are not amused - part 2
I was thinking of posting this yesterday, but the Inkscape tutorial deserved a day all on its own free of my mad console rantings.

I've noticed an increase in the general excitement over the imminent release of both Nintendo and Sony's offerings in the next generation of consoles. Media services have been spewing out heaps of new interesting details, and even though I haven't been actively seeking them out they've trickled down through the internet. For example the religious fanboy wars seem to be on the rise in the Lounge.

As an aside from my main argument - why exactly is there such a argument between fans of various consoles? I suppose I fall under the Nintendo camp as presently the only console I have is a Gamecube, but it's not like I don't recognise that the PS2 and Xbox are fun too. I certainly don't have a grudge against Microsoft - maybe a little against Sony due to their scrapping of the AIBO that I played around with for Robocup a few years back, and their arrogant stance in marketing. And it's not like I think Nintendo are flawless - hence the point of this post.

Back to the point: I am a fan of Nintendo, and despite the stupid name the Wii is the console I'm most looking forward to. I would be interested purely on the strength of Nintendo's first party titles alone, but the new interface seems extremely interesting and offers the potential for whole new ways to play games. As such, I was debating with myself whether I should buy a Wii on release with a copy of the latest Zelda game (one of my favourite Nintendo series!), or whether I should wait to see if the Wii holds up to its potential.

However yesterday (just before I posted my Inkscape tutorial) I was glancing through the Slashdot headlines and I saw something that has made me start to doubt the strength of the Wii. Apparently in the Wii version of The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, Link will be right-handed Travesty! Apparently the developers noticed at E3 that most people were using the Wii controller in the right hand, so they decided to make a mirror version of the game to make Link a righty. I sure as hell hope this is optional, because I don't like the sound of right-handed Link one bit.

Now you might think I'm overreacting a little (well, I am a bit for dramatic effect [smile]), but as a lefty myself Link's handedness has been part of what I liked about the hero. It was part of who he was. Link - pointy ears, likes weary green, has a silly floppy hat and is left-handed. Making him right-handed just seems -wrong. It's like giving Mario a clean shave.

It's also made me question their ability to port The Legend of Zelda to the Wii. Previously I was assured by my opinion of Nintendo's reputation in control systems - they've been pioneers in both the hardware and software side of control, and it's not like they'd screw up the control system of one of their flagship titles. But this fix just seems a little - hackerish to me. Mirroring the entire world to make Link right-handed based on reactions at E3? Surely they'd have noticed a problem of that nature in their internal testing?

More importantly though, it's also made me question the whole suitablity of the Wii for left-handed players such as myself. Part of the whole power of the Wii controller system, at least from what I've read, is to allow players to mimic the actions of hand held items. I'm quite strongly left handed, and prefer to use my left hand for writing, throwing and holding racquets and bats in sports. But if Nintendo is prepared to turn their famously left handed Link into a right hander, that suggests there's a strong element to handedness inherent in their controller. If righties find it unnatural to control a left hander with their right hand, then presumably lefties will likewise find in unnatural to control a right hander. And if Nintendo, famed for their control systems, decides to go with favouring right hands for Zelda it doesn't bode well for the left-handed features in other games too. I don't want to have to use my right hand to hold the remote in a sports game, for example, as it feels entirely bizarre to me. It would totally negate the benefit of designing the Wii controller to mimic natural actions.

So given all that, now I doubt I'll buy a Wii until I have a chance to properly play with it myself. Or at the least, until left handed reviewers that I trust to give an unbiased account gets his or her left hands on it. It's a pity though, because from the pictures I've seen it looked like the Wii controller was pretty lefty friendly (at least compared to ergonomic joysticks and mice - damn stupid right handed things). But that doesn't matter a jot if the software is biased towards right handedness.

To look on the positive side of things though, if I did have to use my right hand to control Wii games, at least I'd become more ambidexturous, which might come in handy if I lose my left arm to a wheat thresher or to a Viking raid.


Oh yeah, reminder that you can comment on the Inkscape tutorial as well as my Wii rant. Wouldn't want to distract all y'all.
Sign in to follow this  


7 Comments


Recommended Comments

Actually, that's one of the things I'm rather worried about as well, I know there are some arcade games that, while not unplayable, can be rather annoying to play left-handed. Then again, most DS games have managed to have left and right handed controls, hopefully developers for the Wii follow suit.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Quote:
Original post by Kaisel
Actually, that's one of the things I'm rather worried about as well, I know there are some arcade games that, while not unplayable, can be rather annoying to play left-handed. Then again, most DS games have managed to have left and right handed controls, hopefully developers for the Wii follow suit.

I don't own a DS, but I've heard that it's particularly good for that. I'd assumed the Wii would follow suit, but "right-handed Link" is definitely not a good sign.

Share this comment


Link to comment
That's actually a pretty good point. I hadn't thought about whether they would support left handed gameplay or not.

I suppose it really depends on the game. For instance, I bet sports games like Wii sports will have it as a preference, but I don't know about games like Zelda. The right-handed link might back up the more sinister theory.

If nothing else, I'm buying the Wii to amass my old library of Genesis games. Although, I don't think they'll be offering Shaq-fu for download[lol]

Share this comment


Link to comment
Quote:
Original post by Stompy9999
The right-handed link might back up the more sinister theory.

Maybe they think us southpaws need to me more dexterous?

Even Latin has no love for us lefties [sad].

Share this comment


Link to comment
Your Inkscape tutorials are the shit. I think im gonna try using it to make the art for my next game. I like how it doesnt make things look blocks, which is a definatly a +

Now I know you have been up to alot latley but im pissed at you!!! You stole the show at the 1W1B contest and thats where I first heard of you and started to follow you, but you havent been doing any games since, WTFIUWT? (what the fu*k is up with that?).

Are you currently working on a project? Dont want to? Whats going on? Are you interested in doing just art from now on? ETC...

Share this comment


Link to comment
Quote:
Original post by ShoeStringGames
Now I know you have been up to alot latley but im pissed at you!!! You stole the show at the 1W1B contest and thats where I first heard of you and started to follow you, but you havent been doing any games since, WTFIUWT? (what the fu*k is up with that?).

It's a long tale, mostly of my general laziness and inability to stick with a project for more than a month (not a very exciting tale, frankly). It's pretty much chronicled in this journal, but it might be a good idea to do a summary in a journal post to give me a well needed kick in the pants.

Quote:
Are you currently working on a project? Dont want to? Whats going on? Are you interested in doing just art from now on? ETC...

Short description - yes, I'm working on a project; a puzzle game presently called "Ice Slider". Given it isn't that clear what the hell I'm doing (understandable; my journal posts are all over the place) I should probably make a journal entry completely dedicated to explaining that.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Advertisement
×

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

We are the game development community.

Whether you are an indie, hobbyist, AAA developer, or just trying to learn, GameDev.net is the place for you to learn, share, and connect with the games industry. Learn more About Us or sign up!

Sign me up!