Jump to content
  • Advertisement

Journal

Sign in to follow this  
  • entries
    122
  • comments
    246
  • views
    90766

Dehah

Sign in to follow this  
Daerax

342 views

So they have scrapped GCSE home coursework in math. I think this is perhaps the most idiotic thing that I have heard the government come out with in some time. The only discordant note in an otherwise brilliant labour conference this week.

Am I the only one who thinks this is a stupid overeaction to internet copying? I can think of many ways to counter it without such knee jerk reactions. One suggestion would be stop overloading teachers so they can pay more individual attention to students and not treating them like generic members of a collection.

For example here is an idea:

How weird would it be if teachers were acquainted enough with students to say, "Hmm this is not johnny's work, he does not usually structure his arguments in this manner, nor does he construct his diagrams that way or layout his papers that way". What a strange idea that! In fact those internet solutions often smack of a certain genericity or are overly mature.

Once caught plagirizing it would do to discuss as to why, offer help and give a second chance to redo it properly while making clear that you, the teacher is approachable at the slightest hint of any problem. Unfortunately this is overly ideal as students generally do not care to ask for help nor do bureaucratic engagements allow one much time to attend to students.

A way round this and done by many is to have discussions about coursework, however, rather than just have it be optional, let such discussions as well be interwoven into the class cirriculum.

Here again we see supreme ignorance of mathematics by the general community as they say, lets cut math coursework but keep everything else becuase you know, math is just rote memorization anyways and since it is so rigid and uncreative, copying cannot be detected. Plus, nevermind that math skills are not doing so well in the nation lets make it worse by making sure that people are not learning but memorizing and stressing over exams! So they can despise math more and ask such silly questions as 'but of what use is math anyway?'. Disgusting. There is no better way to learn math or anything than by doing. By offering specially formulated problems which will take the students the breadth of the topics covered, problems which require and encourage creative and original thinking (something that our culture currently discourages) all to be persued at the leisure of the student in their freetime at school or at home over some extended period of time, more would be learned by the students than by any other method. such carefully constructed coursework are of much better use in testing gained knowledge than some stylized math exam which can be done with little thought beyond that which may done by rote - this is made even easier if past papers are made accessible.

If coursework copying is truly such a problem then perhaps not only should such generic work not be given but a variety of carefully crafted problems tailored to the demographics of a class. Again an idealization where there is an assumption that the teachers have enough time to treat their students as humans, humans with interests.

Rebooted, I have not had continous internet access for a while but have finally replied here :)
Sign in to follow this  


7 Comments


Recommended Comments

Personally I would have liked to seen more maths corsework (i.e. at A-Level), so students can actualy show they can use the maths they've learnt to solve a problem rather than just, do this integral, invert this matrix etc.

Oh and happy birthday.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Quote:

Rebooted, I have not had continous internet access for a while but have finally replied here :)
Ah, thanks! A belated happy birthday from me too [grin]


On coursework:
I heard about this on the news, but not in too much detail. Are they just scrapping maths coursework?

I don't really understand that. It's unlikely English coursework, as an example, would be scrapped. Some other subjects also depend very heavily on coursework. In these subjects, the problem will still remain, and the only solution is yours. So yeah, this is just the wrong approach. It has to be due to the government wanting to be seen to be doing something, or just misunderstanding of the subject.

Share this comment


Link to comment
*Hijacks post*

Happy Belated Birthday!!!, I hope it was a good one and sorry I missed it[sad]..I've been so busy at work (crappy payroll stuff for the council) and, any time now I have on the pc is taken up by, either looking around for other jobs or managing my football teams on XpertEleven!. Perhaps I'll find time over the next 2 weeks to write up my journal with wots happened in my life - depends if anyone's interested of course! [wink] [grin]...keep well!.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Yayyy thank you Evelyn. Im glad you were able to make it to wish me a happy birthday. so nice. I definately would want to read your entry as well as any sane or semi-sane person. :D

Rebooted, Thanks! The impression I got was that math was definately getting the ax but I believe the others may get it as well, maybe later? Not clear atm.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Yayyy thank you Evelyn. Im glad you were able to make it to wish me a happy birthday. so nice. I definately would want to read your entry as well as any sane or semi-sane person. :D

Rebooted, Thanks! The impression I got was that math was definately getting the ax but I believe the others may get it as well, maybe later? Not clear atm.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Advertisement
×

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

GameDev.net is your game development community. Create an account for your GameDev Portfolio and participate in the largest developer community in the games industry.

Sign me up!