Another update

Published January 14, 2007
Advertisement
Another game has been disqualified, and there's a fourth that the other judges have brought to my attention that I'll be making the call on tomorrow. Do you folks think I should disclose which entries have been disqualified now, or should I not and let people find out when all the scores are up?

Also, a bit of good news about the judging system. Based on feedback from last year, we'll be providing a lot more information about entry results - it won't just be "these guys win; the rest of you go away." A full ranking will be available, and entrants will be able to view both the average judge scores *plus* all the judges comments - and the judges have always made (in many cases extensive) comments this year. Every game could use improving in at least one way, and hopefully these comments will guide people in the best way to do that.

(Do you think the comments and score breakdowns should be made visible to everyone?)

It's my hope that many of the contestants won't stop working on their games simply because the contest is over; another month or two of organised work and a number of high-quality games could emerge from this.
Previous Entry 4E5 update
Next Entry Ho hum
0 likes 4 comments

Comments

sirob
Quote:Do you folks think I should disclose which entries have been disqualified now, or should I not and let people find out when all the scores are up?

I think you should privately let the entrants know their entry has been disqualified. I know there is at least one person dying to know if his entry was disqualified or not, and theres not much point in waiting if the decision is final. As for making it public, I don't personally see any rush to let everyone know which entries didn't make it. We can wait for the final results to see that.

Quote:(Do you think the comments and score breakdowns should be made visible to everyone?)

I can't really think of any reason why not to. Considering the entries themselves are public, hearing what others have to say about them could only spark productive (hopefully) discussion about the subject. I don't see much point in keeping this private if the scores are made public.

Can't wait to find out :). Good job organizing everything, sounds like you really implemented some of the comments from last year.
January 14, 2007 03:45 PM
Drilian
I second what sirob says. While I'm dying to know which games are disqualified, I'm relatively confident that I'm not in that list. I can wait to find out with the rest of the gaming public...but it's probably best to give those entry authors a heads-up. I know I'd want one.
January 14, 2007 08:11 PM
Ravuya
I'd like to see why the games were disqualified; I don't particularly care which games they are.
January 15, 2007 12:02 AM
Terminatore3
yes, i think you should disclose who has already been disqualified, im getting pretty worried about my game.us :)
January 15, 2007 01:54 PM
You must log in to join the conversation.
Don't have a GameDev.net account? Sign up!
Profile
Author
Advertisement
Advertisement