Jump to content
  • Advertisement
  • entries
    6
  • comments
    0
  • views
    1040

How to decide between AR and VR for your upcoming app?

shahidmansuri

1031 views

Joe air-taps Dan’s picture to video call him. Dan picks the call and appears, in front of Joe, Dan’s life-size hologram, floating in the air. In very Sci-fi style, Joe drags the hologram, rests it on a table and pins it.

The call wasn’t very different from a regular Skype video call, except it was taking place in Augmented Reality (AR) between Microsoft HoloLens, rather between PCs or Smartphones.

The Head Mounted Display (HMD) wore by Joe made the audience believe that he is about to demo some upcoming Virtual Reality (VR) tech by Microsoft. The demo ended in huge applause and gave the audience a sneak-peek what video calls in future will look like.

VR and AR are two futuristic technologies that are going to change the way we, humans, perceive technology. It’s natural of App developers to look at these technologies with great hope.

While AR technology has been in work for a long time now and is relatively a common place in mobile apps, today, the credit of reviving VR goes to 2012’ Kickstarted project “Oculus Rift: Step Into the Game” by then unknown startup Oculus. Facebook later acquired Oculus for $2 billion and inspired (perhaps forced) Google to make inroads to VR technology.

Google Vs Facebook: the next platform war

Google, rather than developing a standard PC-connected VR device like Oculus Rift, decided to leverage on the well-established it controls, which led us to Google Cardboard and, later, Daydream. Google’s setting involved a VR kit consist of a HMD and a smartphone. Google released three SDKs for developing apps for cardboard on various platforms: Android, Unity Gaming, and iOS.

The SDKs triggered the first set of VR applications developed for smartphones and the world hasn’t looked backwards since.

Perspective Reality

Cardboard’s successor Daydream, owing to only a handful of Daydream-ready phones and the VR headset Daydream View costing many times the cardboard, is far from a success. But it’s the only native VR SDK available for a mobile platform with Apple conspicuous by its absence in this field, bringing Facebook and Google on the verge of a VR supremacy war. In case you were wondering, unlike its predecessor, Daydream doesn’t support iOS, at least not yet.

Is it Apple vs Google again?

Both Google Tango and Apple ARKit look promising but are yet to reach their full potential. This might give rise to another platform war between the two tech giants. Apple ARKit supports every iPhone 6s and 7 out there and is a clear winner here. Google Tango at this stage supports a couple of handsets by Asus and Lenovo, neither Pixel-s nor Galaxy-ies.

Nevertheless, iOS and Android app developers determined to include either of the technologies in their upcoming apps in a pursuit of futureproofing them have a lot of paths to take at least when they are thinking AR.

Daydream may not look like an overly capable project Google hyped for after all; it’s the only feasible platform to develop VR apps on. There is no need to look elsewhere.

VR and AR can add value to any app regardless of its category. But how to choose between these two when developing an app or a GAME?

  1. Games

It’s hard to decide between the two when developing games. AR and VR both tend to blur the lines between real and virtual world. However, VR looks like the missing block in the games that are drawing up on ‘reality’. First Person Shooters (FPSs), today, are growing closer to reality with real life graphics, spine-chilling sound effects and, frantic animations. On top of that, FPSs increasingly include AI engines and physics engines to give a gamer a perception of reality. However, all the action take place in front of a screen placed at a distance from a viewer, which leads to substantial loss of quality by the time the images travels to the viewer’s eyes, broadening the gap between perception and reality.

 

AR and VR

 

In VR, the screen inside the HMD is placed directly on viewers eyes, giving the user a perception that he is not playing the game, but in it.

Spider-Man Homecoming VR Experience is a fun and thrilling first-person game if you have a capable PC and either an Oculus Rift or HTC Vive. Or else you can try VR Roller Coaster on Google Cardboard.

If your game needs to interact with the real-world locations (think Pokémon Go), AR is what you need. Otherwise, VR is the way to go.

  1. Video Streaming apps

For the reason described above, a piece of video content provided taken in 360-view is sure to leave your viewers awestruck. They can move around, revolve wearing the HMD and can actually see what is happening behind the action. VR doesn’t look like very great an option in this category of apps. Apple Developers looking at ARKit with great hope. Sorry!

  1. Video Calling

The Skype call made on HoloLens I believe is the best rendition of Augmented Reality to date, not as a gimmick but as a technology that actually makes, otherwise, boring and dull video calls interesting and useful at the same time.

AR is suitable in case of Video Calling apps because you need to see the world on either side of the call. VR will cut you on your side of call. I am not saying VR is not happening in Video Calling at all but the HoloLens demo, suddenly, makes developing a standalone video calling apps so much sense.

Imagine interacting with the world around the person you’re on a call with, annotating objects of your interest and zooming them in and out while the call is still running and he is interacting with yours.
 

 

 



0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Advertisement
  • Advertisement
  • Blog Entries

  • Similar Content

    • By MiTi
      Dear everyone, this is my newest game, please check out and give me feedback. Thanks for your consideration.

      Overview: Cross n Puzz is a creative and addicting word puzzle game. It not only challenges your brain but also improve memory and other types of cognitive function.

      For IOS: https://itunes.apple.com/app/crossword-puzzle-image/id1435575074

      For Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.caag.crosswordnpuzzle

      Game trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stNuktpJH44&feature=youtu.be
      Crossword Puzzle Image Trailer Official.mp4  
    • By mtjscott
      Hey, so i've created a disk in unity (2D mobile) that will be shot forward if you drag it back and the further you drag it from the start point the more force will be applied to the impulse similar to the 8ball pool drag to shoot mechanic on miniclip. However, when I applied a script that allows the main camera to follow the ball it broke the mechanic since the balls position is calculated through the camera in world space. So I created a bool that locks the camera in place until the ball is released so the calculation would happen before the camera starts to move. This works however the ball now rubber bands back and forwards close to the start position.
       
      If anything needs more explaining then i'd be glad to do so. I've only been coding for about a week so you'll have to bare with me. Any help is appreciated. Thank you very much.
       
      Here's What happens:
      https://gyazo.com/f211e50f32ac59437a93dad7295a14be
      (screencap gif of the game viewer)
       
      Here is the shoot script:
      using System.Collections; using System.Collections.Generic; using UnityEngine; public class Shoot : MonoBehaviour { [SerializeField] GameObject Disc; [SerializeField] float multiplier; Vector3 initPos; private Rigidbody2D rb; public static bool ballIsReleased = false; bool recordingDistanceDragged = false; private void Start() { rb = gameObject.GetComponent<Rigidbody2D>(); initPos = transform.position; } void OnMouseDrag() { recordingDistanceDragged = true; if(recordingDistanceDragged == true) { transform.position = Camera.main.ScreenToWorldPoint(new Vector3(Input.mousePosition.x, Input.mousePosition.y, 10)); } else { transform.position = initPos; } } void OnMouseUp() { ballIsReleased = true; } private void FixedUpdate() { if(ballIsReleased == true) { rb.AddForce((initPos - transform.position) * multiplier, ForceMode2D.Impulse); Debug.Log("ball is released"); recordingDistanceDragged = false; } else { ballIsReleased = false; } } }  
      Here is the camera follow script:
      using System.Collections; using System.Collections.Generic; using UnityEngine; public class CameraFollow : MonoBehaviour { private Vector2 velocity; public float smoothTimeY; public float smoothTimeX; public GameObject player; private void Start() { player = GameObject.FindGameObjectWithTag("Player"); } private void FixedUpdate() { if (Shoot.ballIsReleased == true) { Debug.Log("camera can move"); float posX = Mathf.SmoothDamp(transform.position.x, player.transform.position.x, ref velocity.x, smoothTimeX); float posY = Mathf.SmoothDamp(transform.position.y, player.transform.position.y, ref velocity.y, smoothTimeY); transform.position = new Vector3(posX, posY, transform.position.z); } } }  
    • By GameDev.net
      It's no secret that what makes or breaks a VR experience is whether or not the player feels immersed in the VR world you've built. Here are a collection of tested guidelines for creating a more captivating VR experience.

      Introduction
      In recent years, virtual reality (VR) technology has progressed exponentially to enable immersive environments in which users feel a heightened sense of realism—that “you’re really there” feeling in the created environment. Across the board, CPU performance, GPU performance, VR headsets’ visual fidelity, and VR-enabled software have all advanced tremendously.
      Games are the most obvious beneficiaries of VR technology and are already beginning to make the most of it. Other software genres can benefit from VR’s immersive capabilities as well, including education, training, and therapeutic usages.
      However, as with many new technologies, it’s easy to implement VR that looks cool on the surface but has fatal flaws that pull you out of the immersive experience or ultimately make you wonder why someone went to the trouble of creating the software. Developers run the risk of having an initial “Oh, wow!” quickly become “What’s the point?”
      Read more
    • By GameDev.net
      Arizona Sunshine* found success in the VR space after following Intel® Guidelines for Immersive VR Experiences. See how they became the fastest-selling non-bundled virtual Reality title to date.

      With a dazzling launch in early 2017 that saw Arizona Sunshine* become the fastest-selling non-bundled virtual reality title to date, and instant recognition as the 2016 “Best Vive Game” according to UploadVR, the zombie-killer game is not just another VR shooter. Combining immersive game play with intriguing multi-player options, this game takes full advantage of VR capabilities to promote playability in both outdoor and underground environments.
      Through its association with Netherlands-based Vertigo Games and nearby indie developer Jaywalkers Interactive, Intel helped add sizzle to Arizona Sunshine by fine-tuning the CPU capabilities to provide end-to-end VR realism. The power of a strong CPU performance becomes apparent with every jaw-dropping zombie horde attack. From the resources available when a player chooses and loads a weapon, to the responsiveness of the surrounding eerie world, the immersive qualities of the VR interface make it easy to forget that it’s just a game.
      Read more
    • By sosnol_gaming
      The massively popular memes "Bongo Cat" has been made into a smartphone game!
       
      Welcome to Bongo Cat DUELS! Wild West is waiting for you. Fight vicious enemies, upgrade cat skills and buy new guns.
       
      FEATURES:
       
      -Participate in duels;

      -Get money and experience for winning;
       
      -Open new duels;

      Google Play:
      https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.IceSky.bongo_cat_duels
      Youtube:
       
×

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

We are the game development community.

Whether you are an indie, hobbyist, AAA developer, or just trying to learn, GameDev.net is the place for you to learn, share, and connect with the games industry. Learn more About Us or sign up!

Sign me up!