Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Browser Obsolesence, or "Firefox? big deal!"

Sign in to follow this  


Okay, so now I check out Dashboard. It's not revolutionary; Linux desktop environments have had applets like this for a good while (think gDesklets), and LiteStep and Samurize make them possible for Windows, too. What is interesting is that Dashboard is the first such offering from a "major" (and I have to put that in quotes because, at less than 5% of the total desktop computer market, you can legitimately be considered minor) OS vendor. In particular, watching the part of the QuickTime video where a Dashboard widget is used to search for flight information, I began to wonder how Orbitz and Expedia, et al, would react to this. Now, admittedly, there is no indication that the ability to purchase tickets is included in Dashboard, or ever will be, but once users get used to searching for flights without launching a web browser, they'll begin to ask why they can't buy them from that local interface.

Full Disclosure: I recently switched back to IE from Firefox after the latest browser update (1.0.2, I believe) caused slowdowns and instability. Is that the source of the problem? I don't know, nor do I care. I'm enjoying using IE again, even without tabbed browsing, plus it automatically logs into GameDev.net, something I could never get Firefox to do no matter how many times I deleted and recreated my cookies.

I don't even miss password manager that much.

Which brings me to browser obsolesence (and this started out as an addendum to my enthused gushing over Spotlight and Mac OS X Tiger). I've never understood why everyone makes a big deal over Firefox gaining ground on IE. So what? The browser remains important for now, but will become increasingly less so - as a standalone component. As web services proliferate, and not only the .NET variety but also XML-RPC and SOAP, local applications will be able to transparently query remote data stores for the information that is pertinent to the individual user. iTunes Apple Music Store (aka iTAMS - go figure) is an online application, but can not be accessed without iTunes (well, it can, but it requires some creative hacks) or via the browser. It is integrated into the local iTunes application that resides on the user's hard drive, transparently querying the online data base and conducting transactions.

In that light, in the larger scheme of things, so what if Firefox overtakes Internet Explorer? Where the real work should be progressing is in developing and popularizing the Gecko layout and rendering engine as an efficient, accessible, cross-platform way of embedding a standards-compliant web presentation component in your application.

Firefox is a very good browser, but as digital convergence occurs - and it will occur, whether you personally like it or not - and web content becomes just another form of retrievable content, the appeal of the standalone browser will wane.

Cheap shot: I believe open source works as a store of common knowledge, as a democratization mechanism for technology that has become infrastructure. At the point where open source provides a truly viable alternative to a proprietary solution across all critical usage contexts, the technology is basically a freebie and proprietary developers should move on to something else. The web browser is infrastructure, though the emphasis on Firefox over Gecko is hurting the perception, even among developers, of the web browser component as distinct and useful.

Frankly, if not for a few glaring deficiencies in Firefox (say what you will, but being able to seamlessly navigate my local machine from the web browser and navigate the web from my filesystem explorer is extremely useful; and the lack of COM interop hurts Windows intranet applications), I would say Microsoft ought to stop developing IE and just adopt Firefox as their browser of choice. Of course, that would hurt the public perception of Microsoft (because the press enjoys building IE vs Firefox up as some sort of meaningful "conflict" - bitches), so it's not going to happen.

Plus, you know IE7 is going to be badass. Microsoft has taken far too much heat, like they did with IE3, like they did with VC6 as it aged, not to come back with a killer product. Should be fun to see what they do with it.
Sign in to follow this  


Recommended Comments

I love Firefox, I can't get it to automatically log in to gamedev on my work system, but at home it works just fine... no idea why.

I have not experienced any slowdowns. There are however some mysterious memory leaks that I have encountered twice so far (very rare), but quite severe, the first time I noticed it, firefox was using 900,000Kb.

Anyway.. I hate IE, it feels like a gigantic flood gate through which spyware and adware rush in and install itself everywhere.

Share this comment

Link to comment
I love Firefox, I can't get it to automatically log in to gamedev on my work system, but at home it works just fine... no idea why.

Well, it works here [smile]

Anyway.. I hate IE, it feels like a gigantic flood gate through which spyware and adware rush in and install itself everywhere.

It's been vastly improved with SP2 - no more spyware/adware stuff. Also, you might want to get hold of the beta anti-spyware software by microsoft, it's nice.

Share this comment

Link to comment
This is not a debate of IE vs Firefox, so please take it elsewhere. I don't much care which you prefer. This is a discussion of the long-term prognosis of web browsers in abstract.

For the record, I don't prefer one or the other. Firefox has a lot of nice features, but it has certain detail annoyances and usability shortcomings. IE is robust and embeddable and componentized and a component container, but it has certain UI shortcomings such as the absence of tabbed browsing, low configurability (where are passwords stored? how do you switch off password storage or auto form fill?) and perceived security vulnerability.

It's a wash. So please keep pointless debates out of my journal.

Do you have any opinions on what I actually wrote about?

Share this comment

Link to comment
I had the not holding login information thing with IE when using GDNet actually but it didn't happen in FireFox.. but I agree this last update has really messed up the browser, half the time I have to click a link 2 or 3 times because it will keep telling me the page does not exist. :)

Share this comment

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Advertisement

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

We are the game development community.

Whether you are an indie, hobbyist, AAA developer, or just trying to learn, GameDev.net is the place for you to learn, share, and connect with the games industry. Learn more About Us or sign up!

Sign me up!