Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Friction.....

This topic is 5121 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Recommended Posts

I have a physics problem, that is written below, and I have a question about it. Here is the problem: A box is given a push so that it slides across the floor. How far will it go, given that the coefficient of kinetic friction is .2 and the push imparts an initial speed of 4.0 m/s. Now, I''ve been thinking about this problem for a while, and I don''t really know what to do. Wouldn''t you need to at least know the mass of the object or the time it takes for the object to come to rest? Any help is appreciated. Thanks in Advance, --BioX

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Now, I''ve been thinking about this problem for a while, and I don''t really know what to do.

Write out the equations, leaving whatever you don''t know as a symbolic parameter. Then work from that.

Wouldn''t you need to at least know the mass of the object or the time it takes for the object to come to rest?

No you don''t.

Any help is appreciated.

Homework questions don''t belong in here.



[ Start Here ! | How To Ask Smart Questions | Recommended C++ Books | C++ FAQ Lite | Function Ptrs | CppTips Archive ]
[ Header Files | File Format Docs | LNK2001 | C++ STL Doc | STLPort | Free C++ IDE | Boost C++ Lib | MSVC6 Lib Fixes ]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If you''re in middle/high school, then there''s usually homework clinics at school, or at a community center near you.

If you''re a freshman taking "basic physics you should have gotten in middle school for liberal arts majors 101" then there''s SURE to be TAs who can help you with these problems.

If nothing else fails, why don''t you call the teacher who gave you the homework in the first place, and tell him that you''re having trouble with this question, and what kinds of clarity can he give? Or search him out during recess and ask the same thing.

Or, worst case, pay a tutor.

Anyway, the crazy thing is that you already GOT all the help you need! Fruny is right on the money. If you''re too lazy to do even that, then you should save yourself some time, and take a job flipping burgers or something right now. School''s harder than that, and real life''s even worse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I just want an answer to this one problem so I can know how to do problems like it. I don''t need to enroll in some clinic or community center you moron. I can''t believe you even suggested that. I tried google already...no luck. And I wouldn''t dare dream of calling my teacher....who the f--k does that? I''m going to get the answer tomorrow, I just wanted to see if there was anyone willing to help me out before tomorrow. I guess not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Anonymous Poster
he told you everything already. Write down the damn equations and just solve them. Your problem is very basic. Just write down the damn equations on paper.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bioagentX,

I''m the moderator of this forum, and I set the policy on homework, which you can review in the forum FAQ:

Forum FAQ

There are two basic reasons why homework isn''t appropriate for these forums. First, this is a game development sight, and homework usually is not about game development. Some of these questions are a misuse of our expensive bandwidth. But, of course, some homework questions are relevant and so some of them are allowed to remain open. But we ask that you follow the guidelines in the FAQ.

More importantly, though, there are a bunch of people out there who will cheat on their homework if given a chance. Now, many students really do want to learn but there have been quite a number of posts here where the poster was obviously just trying to get a complete answer so that they could pass a test or homework, without doing hard work themselves. In 10 years they will wish they had done the work. This forum does not wish to help students cheat because it just will not help those folks in their jobs or life once they graduate. It surely will not help them find and keep a job in game development---there''s twenty thousand other hungry kids and adults who are better than that scrambling for the same job. Cheating kills a person''s problem-solving skills. Those skills don''t come for free, and take time to develop. And so we try to close threads that are homework, suggest that students discuss problems with their fellow students and teachers, and educate the community about the forum policy---what it is and why.

As you can see from the comments from other forum members, folks here are mostly aware of the policy and are very good at helping me to enforce the policy.

As for your question, its tangentially relevant to game development. Games have boxes that slide across the floor. Games have physics. And you didn''t ask for a direct answer so as far as I''m concerned your post can remain open. BUT, I hope that forum members will not just solve the problem for you and give the answer. That would disturb me.

The forum FAQ does provide you with links to more homework-oriented sites (e.g., Dr. Math).

Graham Rhodes
Senior Scientist
Applied Research Associates, Inc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
quote:
Original post by bioagentX
And I wouldn''t dare dream of calling my teacher....who the f--k does that?


I hope you do come back to read replies to your thread. To answer your question, I asked my teachers. Now I have a Masters degree, 75% of a Ph.D, and a stable, excellent paying job that gives me the freedom to pursue just about any damned thing I want (which is game development and 3D graphics). I didn''t get here because I''m a natural genious. I got here because I asked. Smart folks aren''t afraid to ask. Your high school peers may laugh for about 30 seconds, but not the smart ones. And even the stupid ones will forget about it in about a minute. Its silly not to ask. You may actually learn something if you do.



Graham Rhodes
Senior Scientist
Applied Research Associates, Inc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The mass of the box is needed to solve this problem. Coefficient of friction is force of friction over normal force. Since there is no vertical acceleration, normal force = mass times g (9.80 N/kg). Using the coefficient of friction, you then find the net force on the block which is the force of friction, and use the equation a = delta v over delta t to find delta t, or whatever you need to find. This is basic grade 12 physics.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nathaniel Hammen, you''re not that much better yourself, you still need MASS, BUT it may be a semi-null variable for the given question so you don''t need a VALUE of MASS, but mass itself is still needed.

I must say I hate questions like the first one of the topic,... but they are not that hard if you lay out all the variables you have values for, and then lay out all your given equations. If you don''t have the equations given to you in a text book or something, then why are you doing a question like that, cause you likely are not schooled enought to be needing something like it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LOL, we're doing this EXACT kinda thing here in new mexico, and I think that the equation you need is Fnet = Ufriction*Fnormal. Sorry if I violated a policy, but this stuff is fresh on my mind, and I'd like to help out. In fact, can you just rearrange future questions so that they look like game programming questions? I.e. I have a box in my game world, and I'm trying to apply a physics model to it...

[edited by - bjmumblingmiles on December 2, 2003 11:09:40 PM]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
quote:
Original post by intrest86
quote:
Original post by grhodes_at_work
...First, this is a game development sight, ...


[SpellingNazi]
You mean site, right? :-P
[/SpellingNazi]


Yah, mon. My bad.



Graham Rhodes
Senior Scientist
Applied Research Associates, Inc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Folks,

Lets try to be friendly here. You do not save face or become a champion by attacking someone else who makes a minor mistake or fails to include every tiny infinitesimal detail of an algorithm. Please do correct mistakes, but do it in a friendly manner so that people will want to actually continue reading the thread beyond your post.

Graham Rhodes
Senior Scientist
Applied Research Associates, Inc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
quote:
Original post by bjmumblingmiles
In fact, can you just rearrange future questions so that they look like game programming questions? I.e. I have a box in my game world, and I''m trying to apply a physics model to it...


Surely you can. If you do such a thing just to sneak a homework problem in so that you can cheat, well then, you might just pull the wool over our eyes and get the treasure you seek---the free answer to your immediate problem. But, in the long run, what goes around comes around and you will discover you have cheated yourself.

I''m not saying that it is never good to be given the answer. Sometimes it is. An answer can sometimes just cause something in your brain to snap, leaving you with a clear understanding of a theory or algorithm. BUT, it is best to be given the answer by an educator, a professional, who is equipped---and paid---to spend extra time trying to push you beyond the question whose answer you were given. You aren''t guaranteed of that in school, but there''s a much better chance that your teacher will push you beyond than anyone here will. Everyone here helps out for free, with no guarantees. And by my estimate most of the people here do not have formal training or professional experience. There are lots of damn smart folks here who know there stuff. Both the gamedev staff/moderators and regular members. But, know that you gets what you pays for. One way or another.

Remember that hard work is a form of payment that produces most excellent rewards.

Graham Rhodes
Senior Scientist
Applied Research Associates, Inc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
quote:
Original post by grhodes_at_work
Now I have a Masters degree, 75% of a Ph.D, and a stable, excellent paying job...


How do you have time to be doing a PhD and have a job at the same time? Or did you give up on the PhD at 3/4 of the way through?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
*blink* I thought you needed the mass for the slowing down factor...

OK.
Theres going to be a friction acting, right?
So you need to figure out something that makes the box slow down.
Its a really simple problem(sorry), so I can''t help more than that.


Reread your book, I''m pretty sure it has something like this in the examples(even given a crappy book).
Also hit up your classmates for answers, and talk to the teacher.

Talking to teachers might be considered gauche and sucking up to them, but trust me, in my 2.5 years of college it helps far more than it hurts.



~V''lion

Bugle4d

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Anonymous Poster
Homework clinics are free (and don''t need enrollment, usually; walk-ins welcome). Calling teachers is free. Heck, asking your parents is free, as is asking your classmates, or maybe even people from the class above.

Unfortunately, all of these solutions involve actual face-to-face (or telephone) contact with real people. I know that can be scary at times, because it''s so hard to keep up your stone hard teenager attitude.

The teenagers that actually end up mattering ten years from now (that is, in the unimaginably distant future) are the ones that know how to drop the facade, and talk to people.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I wish people would stop saying its a simple problem. Simple is so relative. And it''s considerably harder if you don''t know the constant acceleration formula (you know the one I mean), you start going into calculus to derive the damn thing. (or messy algebra).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Y
^ V0=4 m/sec
| N k=0.2
| /\ --->V0
| |
| |
| f<----*
-------------------|------------------>X
|
\/
mg

( I dont know why the drawing doesnt shows right at the post, it does at edit mode :/ )

N is the counter force working on the body
N=mg

1st Law of Niuton on Y axis ( no acceleration )
=============================
the sum of all forces = masa * acceleration
N-mg=0
since you havent specified the masa of the body i presume its 1
and g=9.8 round it up to 10, g=10 and since the gravity working against axis Y g=-10

N=1*-10=-10 N=-10

2nd Law of Niuton on X axis
===========================
f=ma

f=k*N=0.2N=0.2*-10=-2
-2=1*a
a=-2 // the acceleration on the x axis is -2


Now you got all you need to solve this problem

X(t)=X0+V0x*t+a*t^2/2

(a) X(t)=0+4*t-2*t^2/2

the speed equation:
V(t)=V0+ax*t
when the body will stop its speed will be 0
V(t)=0
0=4-2*t
t=2sec // after 2 sec the body will stop
now we put t=2sec in equation (a)
X(t=2sec)=4*2-2*4/2=8-4=4 meters

So the bodey will stop after 4 meters

[edited by - spree on December 5, 2003 1:48:52 AM]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites