Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

alnite

custom weapons or items

Recommended Posts

alnite    3436
When I was taking shower this morning, this thought came to me. Usually you can only buy a crude-looking long sword +10 or a broadsword +12, but what if you can choose what your weapons look like and has a variable bonus damage? I mean, I can have a longsword +10, but I can also have a longsword +20. They can pick what their weapons look like, what materials they are made of, and pay a blacksmith to make it for them. For example, a custom sword. They pick the hilt, what it looks like, the color, etc. Then they pick the shape of the blade, curved, straight, short, long, thick, wavy, or other fancy shapes. Then they can specify the materials: steel, bronze, titanium, etc. In addition, they may want to add more metals/ingredients such as the rare metal they found in their adventure. These rare metals can provide some positive/negative bonuses. Some add magical elements to the weapons. So they can basically mix-match the ingredients and see what they turn to. Some materials are counter-productive against other materials and can cause some serious negative effects on the sword if mixed together. The more complicated it is, the more expensive and longer it takes to make it. They can make their own spear, axes, or maces too. But they can''t make their own kind of weapons. Do you think it would be a good idea?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think that having weapons being created within the game world is a better idea than finding magically awesome weapons from ages past. I''d like to see a character commission a fine weapon, and then have that weapon circulate around the world after the character dies or sells it or gives it away or something. You could spend months trying to track down the sword your previous character used, and then even more time trying to get it.

This of course will require master smiths. Maybe characters could become smiths, and maybe weapon-making could be a collaborative process. A level 8 blacksmith would get together with a level 8 wizard and a powerful warrior, and they would make a sword. First, they''d spend an inordinate amount of money on a big chunk of Mythril stock, and some dragonskin for the grip and scabbard. Then the smith would forge the blade while the wizard cast various augmenting spells on it and transferred some of the warrior''s skill and strength into the magical aura of the blade. The hilt would then be constructed, with different precious stones infused with magical properties being set into it, and some more of the warrior''s strength would be channelled into the pommel, which would contain a fragment of fingernail from the high priest of the kingdom.

What you wind up with is an item the cost a king''s ransom to build, permanently lowered the warrior''s stats, and pretty much makes whomever uses it invincible. It would require some unique items, some incredibly rare items, and an investment of time and money to gather them that could not be easily made. In an MMO world it might take years for a weapon of this magnitude to arise. In the meantime, that smith could manufacture commoner weapons to hone his skills, make a name for himself, and earn a living wage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
grbrg    126
Wow, Iron Chef Carnage, I fell in love with your description of the process... :D

------------------------------
There are only 10 kinds of people: those that understand binary and those that don''t.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
TechnoGoth    2937
There was a very interesting thread last year about this, you should take a look at it.


One size doesn''t fit all


The game I''m working on at present includes item creation and combination. Based on the the above discussion.

There is also a system of item experince called weapon souls. Which comes from the games mythology. Items can gain advantages the longer there owner use them. The first being the weapon becomes a named item. Once the weapon has aquired a name that means you can locate it should it be stolen or lost, it also means that npc can recgonize it.

-----------------------------------------------------
Writer, Programer, Cook, I''m a Jack of all Trades
Current Design project: Ambitions Slave

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueNexus    122
I think this is a concept that isn''t too far away. Star Wars Galaxies has a lesser version of what alnite described. Players make the weapons, they can even name them. The quality of the weapon is based on the skill of the smith and quality of the raw materials. There really isn''t any other uniqueness like alnite described, but I''m will to bet that it''s on the way in future games.

-B

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
alnite    3436
quote:
Original post by BlueNexus
I think this is a concept that isn't too far away. Star Wars Galaxies has a lesser version of what alnite described. Players make the weapons, they can even name them. The quality of the weapon is based on the skill of the smith and quality of the raw materials.
I don't know about Star Wars Galaxies, but Asheron's Call 2 did it too. You can make weapons, but the ingredients are determined. You need X amount of this material and Y amount of that material to make this weapon. Then the game throws a dice and if you successfully created the weapon, it will have a random damage and effects depending on how good you are.

However, this is not very customizable. I am envisioning players can define the shape and look of their weapons. However, it's still based on some sort of available templates. Think about Transport Tycoon or Uncharted Waters with their random face generator. You will notice that they define a set of shapes for each part of the face, and throw them in together to make a new random face.

For example, there are 10 kinds of eyebrows, 10 kinds of nose, 10 kinds of hair styles, etc. Then the program randomly picks one shape from each part, and creates a new face.

The same analogy for this idea. A sword has a hilt and a blade. So we provide a set of shapes for the hilt as well as the blade, and let the players to pick one for the hilt and one for the blade. The program then creates the weapon that they like. However, looks alone may not be suffice to be called a custom weapon. Then the idea of specifying what the blade is made of came to me. Steel is more sturdy and long lasting, so basically, it has more "damage potential" than let's say, bronze.

@TechnoGoth:
I wouldn't like to go into that further by adding size for each class etc, that seems way too complicated. I remember playing Might and Magic 7, I found this uber Elven Chainmail and just realized that nobody in my party is an elf. Now I think that allowing players to convert this armor back to metal and reconstruct a new armor isn't such a good idea either.

Allowing players to have metals in his inventory is a bloat already. Materials such as metals or rare items don't do anything, they only take up inventory space. In Might and Magic 7 and 8, these metals could take up 1/2 of one of my characters' inventory screen. And they only come from one dungeon. Although the size is only 1x1, but they are a lot of them. Now consider allowing players to convert armors/weapons to metals or whatever materials they are made of and allowing them to keep these metals so that later on they can construct a new weapon/armor. They could convert 100 useless armors and weapons they found to metals, thinking that they can construct a new super thick armor, and imagine how full the inventory screen could be.

So I restrict it to only rare items such as dragonskins as mentioned by Iron Chef, or maybe dragonskulls or Shadow Hound's fangs or [insert an item name] can be possessed by players. Leave the metals to the blacksmiths.

Something like this interface when players visit a weaponsmith

+---------------+
| Buy Weapon |
+---------------+
+---------------+
| Sell Weapon |
+---------------+
+---------------+
| Custom Weapon |
+---------------+

When the player choose Custom Weapon, a new dialog appear

Work In Progress:
+-----------------------------------------------------------+
| Weapon | Material | Status | Days remaining |
+-----------------------------------------------------------+
| My UberSword | Steel | In Progress | 20 days |
| | | | |
| | | | |
+-----------------------------------------------------------+

+-----------------------+
| Add new Custom Weapon |
+-----------------------+

When the player select "My UberSword" it will give a full decription of the weapon such as the pictures, custom materials added by the player, the price, etc etc.

When the player presses "Add new Custom Weapon" a new dialog pop up

Pick hilt: [hilt option]
Pick blade: [blade option]
Metal: [Steel/Bronze/Mithril/etc option]
Custom Materials: [a list of custom materials added by the players] [add button] [remove button]

[Create button] [Cancel button]


Something like that.

I think of this idea in single-player worlds, but Iron Chef brought it to the MMO world, assuming there is a blacksmith class.

[edited by - alnite on March 31, 2004 2:59:00 AM]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RuneLancer    253
An MMORPG called "Ragnarok Online" features a character class called "Merchant". After you work your character enough, you can upgrade to the "Blacksmith" class. With a blacksmith, you can forge your own equipment through the stuff enemies drop. However, you can''t really change your weapons as such; just the abilities they have. For instance, you can make a fire-based sword.

It''s a nice start, I guess.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
NeoMage    122
Yeah. I''m actually working on creating something a lot like this. I''m giving the player the ability to see exactly what each slain enemy is carrying and take what they want (instead of Final Fantasy''s random item crap), so if you''re ever looking for a certain thing to make a weapon out of or to incorporate into your weapon, it makes it a bit easier instead of wondering around aimlessly for hours looking for a simple mythril dagger or something.

I''m dying to find an RPG that does this. Actually the original Dark Cloud did a pretty job of this. You could turn your weapons into a pommel stone sorta thing when they reached a certain level, then you could stick them into a different sword for added stats. I loved it.

-NeoMage

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
EricTrickster    142
The first time I saw this in use was in a text-based MUD maybe 10 years ago. You could strip hide and bone from creatures you fought and then take it to a local NPC guild to have custom-made armor and clothing made for yourself, depending on the type of item you gave them.

The guild would charge you a fee and take the items, then give you a RT day to come back to pick up your new armor/cloak/vest/shield. I loved the concept.

Galaxies does use a version of this. You "mine" for organics (meats, grain, etc.), metals, ores, minerals or liquids; there are literally dozens of each kind available, all in varying qualities on different planets.

You can also (as a Scout) strip hide, meat and bone from animals you kill along the way.

EVERYTHING in the SWG universe can be player made, and requires general items to craft. One item, for example, may say you need 10 units of Organic, 5 units of Mineral and 12 units of Metal.

You are absolutely free to use different subcategories of each, and different qualities of each subcategory - all achieving different degrees of success. Part of the fun was discovering which combinations worked to the best results.

For example you may decide to use Tatooine Avian meat for your Organic requirement; another may choose Nabooian bone. A liquid hydrogen for your Mineral can be used instead of an ore.

I''d love to see similar designs in future games; let players go to other players for their crafted weapons and clothing, with Iron''s Master concept having the ability to combine with other Masters to create unique, magical/technologically superior items. Let these items and their crafters (and, hopefully, the item''s owner) become legends in their own right, instead of the usual:

"Hey, let''s go camp the [Generic Creature] and see if they''ll drop a [Generic Item]!"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Anonymous Poster   
Guest Anonymous Poster
U do know Horizons did this but not great.

It allows the smith to build a weapon after gaining enuff skill useing better materials to change the appearance of the weapons there makeing.

and usually most mmorpg''s have crafts.


nyway my view on crafting.

Is it needed:
Yes

I think smiths should not need to aquire formulas but a player as a shmith which sshould be a subclass that a player is not restricted to but a set of stas that increase with use.
Anyway a player should be able to experiment with ammounts of materials and Materials themselves.

A player should be able to take the bone of a fallen enemy and shape it into a dagger or sword. Using a Weapon design window built into the game kinda like a robot building thing it RA2 or Roboforge. that would be amaeing but the game would have to define how each material exsists and its stats.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
firewindshadow    112
I''ve worked on a similar game design like this before, where players can customize the how their weapon, armor, equipment looks. In the end, I grow to like the idea less and less; realized that the fundamental uses of these items outweight the looks. The main focus why player buy/forge weapons and armors is to kill monster, not to play dress up games; guns are made for the purpose to kill things, a highly decorated gun that have the same killing power really isn''t worth a lot more. The more efficiently they can kill monster, the better these weapons/armors are and the more they will want to have them. My suggestion is if want to innovate, take a look at how weapons have envolved. People used to fight one another with swords until the calvary arrived where you get poked to death by mounted lance before your sword gets in range. Then people got wised and attached axes and blade on a long stick turning into halberds, pikes, (i can''t remember those thing''s name) that cuts down calvary horse''s leg...

I''m not interested in making my own weapon, I''m interested in making a weapon that''s better than yours.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The cosmetic properties are of secondary importance. The main things that a system like this will accomplish will be a rational explanation for the existence of items (as opposed to finding the Holy Firebrand of Smiting on the corpse of a wolf) and adding gameplay that isn''t combat. It could be an excuse for teamwork, or a long-term goal (saving up those adamantium chips) or even as a status symbol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites