The Gimp

Quote:Original post by CaptainJester
The Gimp

no no no, the guy asked for a GOOD, free image editor.

pixia is another option, but again, it only passes on that *free* mark.

You can't even run Pixia on a mac/linux/unix/solaris/anything-but-windows-box!

I can get everything that I need to get done in GIMP faster then I can in Photoshop... Now its true that it isn't as intuitive but it is not that hard to learn.

Anyway, my short little rant [smile]

Quote:Original post by H_o_p_s
You can't even run Pixia on a mac/linux/unix/solaris/anything-but-windows-box!

I can get everything that I need to get done in GIMP faster then I can in Photoshop... Now its true that it isn't as intuitive but it is not that hard to learn.

Anyway, my short little rant [smile]

to bad:
A) The quality of the filters and effects are terrible, I can almost always pick out a Gimp picture
B) it doesn't support tablets
C) worst of all, it is actually impossible to USE a tablet, unless you know an arcane config setting
D) the interface is the spawn of satan. This is a design program. Brilliant.
E) it's buggy as hell, it crashes on me all the time (and not just in windows)

the Gimp has to be the worst piece of image editting software I've seen since Microsoft PhotoEd.

Quote:Original post by capn_midnight
to bad:
A) The quality of the filters and effects are terrible, I can almost always pick out a Gimp picture
B) it doesn't support tablets
C) worst of all, it is actually impossible to USE a tablet, unless you know an arcane config setting
D) the interface is the spawn of satan. This is a design program. Brilliant.
E) it's buggy as hell, it crashes on me all the time (and not just in windows)

the Gimp has to be the worst piece of image editting software I've seen since Microsoft PhotoEd.

I understand now why you assume that Pixia is a better program. Tablet support is a problem with The GIMP. However I have to disagree with you on several of your assertions.

I'll work in reverse.
E) I've been using GIMP on my mac for more then a few years. I have yet to have GIMP crash on me. Now, I also have to say that Photoshop hasn't crashed on me either, so maybe it is just a platform issue.

D) Since the creation of Docks became available the whole crappy UI idea is out the window.

note: just slopply rendered bg etc... just for showing me workspace.
-=EDIT=- hmmm... seemed to have two layer panes docked.... usually the right one is the color channels -=/EDIT=-

C & B: Valid claims for people who use tablets.

A) I have to disagree with this one. If you'd like I'll load up any images that you send me and perform the same filter in both Photoshop and GIMP and have you guess which one is the GIMP.

Overall I have to state again that GIMP works for me better then Photoshop. It might not for someone who uses tablets, but the majority of people don't.

-=EDIT=-
Just went through and looked at the gdnet comic, I like your drawings! Do you have a portfolio or somethingt that I could look at?

[Edited by - H_o_p_s on March 19, 2005 12:28:08 AM]

Quote:Original post by H_o_p_s
E) I've been using GIMP on my mac for more then a few years. I have yet to have GIMP crash on me. Now, I also have to say that Photoshop hasn't crashed on me either, so maybe it is just a platform issue.

Lucky punk. :)

Quote:
D) Since the creation of Docks became available the whole crappy UI idea is out the window.

Ah, you have just demonstrated what I mean. Check out your task bar, with it's 57 different items for just one program. As for the organization of the windows on the screen, I find the gimp boxes much larger than the photoshop boxes, but overall photoshop has the same "I'm a tool box and I'm floating infront of your picture" problem.

Quote:
Just went through and looked at the gdnet comic, I like your drawings! Do you have a portfolio or somethingt that I could look at?

yeah, I have two places, on deviant art (which I'm trying to get away from), and on my own site.