Sign in to follow this  
capn_midnight

3H-GDC m.IV (Winners announced)

Recommended Posts

Michalson    1657
Quote:
Original post by d000hg
Quote:
Original post by u235
Unfortunatley I couldn't get most of the games to run due to run time errors mostly. One said that it wasn't meant to be a stand alone application and exited, I couldn't get the one written in Java to run using the instructions so I made a web page and tried to use it that way but that didn't work either. The rest gave me that little wondows popup that says "an error occured, would you like to send it to MS or not?" The four that I got running are critiqued below:
1st: xaver
2nd: DrewGreen
3rd: ApochPiQ
4th: Michalson

Congrats to everyone who was able to push out a game in 3 hours. It takes talent.

-AJ
What PC are you using? Seems odd so many wouldn't work, and I thought mine was using pretty solid DX8.1 code. You must have DX9 though to get Michalson's to run (amusing he got 4th!) - can you PM me since I'm always keen to track down errors? You should have a log.html file you could send me, and a screenshot of any popups... oh and you did get the fixed .zip file because the first one was corrupted?


To not have that many entries run means there is likely something wrong with your system, or the way you are unpacking entries - in my case I can tell you that little pink boxes with X's mean that the png files where not found - as everyone else who has judged it will attest to, those files are right there. You might have something screwed up on your system (somehow changing paths) or in the way you unzip archieves that is preventing you from getting anything but the exe, the errors you got with our submissions could be due to missing DLLs that where included.

When you unpacked the entries, did you just open virtual zip folders and try to run the exes straight from them (in which case all other files in the zip would not exist), or did you properly unpack the zip files into new folders?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
zer0wolf    1022
Okay, Michalson, I got an exception saying that System.IO.FileNotFoundException has occured in your game.

edit: My bad, nevermind. I had to download and install the June MDX installer.

I'll take care of all of my technical difficulties and then post up reviews with my final order iin a few hours.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
d000hg    1199
Quote:
Original post by Michalson
Quote:
Original post by d000hg
Quote:
Original post by u235
Unfortunatley I couldn't get most of the games to run due to run time errors mostly. One said that it wasn't meant to be a stand alone application and exited, I couldn't get the one written in Java to run using the instructions so I made a web page and tried to use it that way but that didn't work either. The rest gave me that little wondows popup that says "an error occured, would you like to send it to MS or not?" The four that I got running are critiqued below:
1st: xaver
2nd: DrewGreen
3rd: ApochPiQ
4th: Michalson

Congrats to everyone who was able to push out a game in 3 hours. It takes talent.

-AJ
What PC are you using? Seems odd so many wouldn't work, and I thought mine was using pretty solid DX8.1 code. You must have DX9 though to get Michalson's to run (amusing he got 4th!) - can you PM me since I'm always keen to track down errors? You should have a log.html file you could send me, and a screenshot of any popups... oh and you did get the fixed .zip file because the first one was corrupted?


To not have that many entries run means there is likely something wrong with your system, or the way you are unpacking entries - in my case I can tell you that little pink boxes with X's mean that the png files where not found - as everyone else who has judged it will attest to, those files are right there. You might have something screwed up on your system (somehow changing paths) or in the way you unzip archieves that is preventing you from getting anything but the exe, the errors you got with our submissions could be due to missing DLLs that where included.

When you unpacked the entries, did you just open virtual zip folders and try to run the exes straight from them (in which case all other files in the zip would not exist), or did you properly unpack the zip files into new folders?


Apparently u235 has a 2nd PC he'd forgotten about. From a PM he just sent me it sounds like he's scrabbling to find it and see if the problematic entries fare any better...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
u235    359
Ok, the forgetten PC has been found and a couple more of the entries were able to run. Apparently there is something wrong with my system, although I did properly unzip all the entries and made sure that the required DLLs were there.

@Michalson: Was there supposed to be a directory structure for yours? I have the exe and all related file in the same directory as was unzipped by WinRar.

The new reviews are below and an updated ranking follows:

d000hg: I thought it was pretty good. I liked the timer which made me play more than once to see if I could beat my time. On the technical side, the collision detection was a little off. I would be obviously not touching anything but I still couldn't move. And there's a bug where you can just take the cart to the far right of the screen and finish at the top of the screen and not come anywhere near the exit sign. All in all, pretty decent for three hours work.

nagromo: Got it running, but I really couldn't do anything. I was able to move the cart around but that's about it. Those little flying things didn't really do anything and I couldn't figure out how to score any points. Instructions would have been nice. You get points for finishing.

[EDIT]Michalson: I decide to forgo getting the graphics to display as what counts here is gameplay. I can imagine the graphics based on the screenshot. As you stated earlier in the thread, there's not much to it. However I did like the stamina meter thing. Even with the pink boxes with Xs I could tell that it was going transparent the less stamina your horse had. And the jump animation was pretty smooth, so points for that.


Updated Rankings:
1st: xaver
2nd: DrewGreen
3rd: d000hg
4th: Michalson
5th: ApochPiQ
6th: nagromo


Note to Michalson: If you can help me get your game running, I will re-evaluate and update the rankings to reflect my thoughts.

-AJ

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
d000hg    1199
Results page updated
Is zero_wolf the last judge - I'm running out of colours...

I'm very interested to see which way round the obvious 1st/2nd entries come - Apoch started off way in front but has been a little less consistent. I wonder if anyone will spoil my 100% consist run of 3rds?!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
capn_midnight    1707
Quote:
Original post by ApochPiQ
Out of curiosity, which version of CartRunner has everyone been judging? The results are likely to be fairly skewed if some are using the original submission and some are running the fixed version that lets you play all 5 levels.


the one on the contest download site was the last one you linked to.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kSquared    1356
Congratulations to the winners. I sent ApochPiQ a PM earlier today with directions on how to claim his prize. Good work, everyone. Enjoy the cookies. =)

- k2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
d000hg    1199
Woohoo I get a prize: but how do I 'collect it'?
Thanks capn by the way, and all the judges too.

And congratulations to the 2 winners - I certainly reckon you are the best and both are pretty fun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kSquared    1356
Quote:
Original post by cowsarenotevil
Quote:
Original post by zer0wolf
Sorry for not getting my tallies in. I spent the day in jail. [sad]


How did you manage that?


By rolling doubles three times?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ApochPiQ    23059
Congrats everyone, and well played... I'm having to fight the temptation to play ICR instead of working [grin]


I kind of like DrewGreen's idea of finishing up and fully polishing the games... I might put a couple more hours into CartRunner and see if I can get some of the control glitches smoothed out, and make the code less of an abomination.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
zer0wolf    1022
Quote:
Original post by cowsarenotevil
Quote:
Original post by zer0wolf
Sorry for not getting my tallies in. I spent the day in jail. [sad]

How did you manage that?

Some crap that went down like almost a year and a half ago finally caught up with me (that I actually posted about back then, too)... along with some other BS charges just for the hell of it I guess. Bleh. I'm so f**ked, properly even. [sad]

More on topic, congrats to teh WINNARS!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ravuya    135
If you guys don't mind, I'm gonna unstick this thread because it hasn't been posted in since the 16th. If you want it re-stuck for whatever reason, PM me. Thanks [grin]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this