Jump to content
  • Advertisement
Sign in to follow this  
MARS_999

OpenGL Question on .x files and saving a mesh

This topic is 4396 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Recommended Posts

I am thinking about a few things with DX that I could do easier/faster than my OpenGL terrain engine can do. One thing that comes to mind is the ability to save out a .x file with a mesh you have created with the DX utility functions. So this is what I have come up with, with my mapeditor I could save out the 2D mesh for my terrain as a .x file and load that as my terrain, now with the attribute groups you save with mesh, couldn't I use them to break my terrain down into patches and render those patches with the DrawSubset() and use view frustum culling to determine which patches I can see and call them? Now if this is ok, my next question is calling DrawSubset() a fast call... What I mean by that is with OpenGL if you use VBO's you typically are rendering your mesh as fast as OpenGL can vs. immediate mode. Thanks for the help.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement
Yeah, it'd work fine the way you described it.

But I'd almost go so far as to put money on it being possible to get substantially better performance from a custom solution.

Some of the details behind efficient terrain rendering can be a bit tedious to implement and test, but if you sit back and think through them they are usually very simple. For example, a quad-tree is not a complex data-structure...

But, I suppose if you want simple code with minimal effort then meshes are a reasonable choice [smile]

hth
Jack

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oh, to actually answer your question....

DrawSubset() should be setting up the VB, IB and declaration and then issuing a Draw call. Not the fastest in the world, but probably not bad.

Drill into it with PIX if you want the gory details.

hth
Jack

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks for the reply Jack! I am as of now using a patching system with brute force to do my rendering with VBO's and triangle strips... With DrawSubset() is that the only way to render a mesh in DX for .x files? or is there some kind of element function call to say render x amount of indicies at a time from a mesh... Yeah basically I am looking at a simple but effect method to render a terrain mesh, due to I have a decent amount of work done in OpenGL and really don't want to redo all my work in DX if I can come up with a simple but fast enough method... :) Anyway I will keep it in mind now that you think my idea should work. Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If you want to use the built-in easy mesh drawing functions, then DrawSubset() is as far as it goes.

However, you can easily do slightly better by coding your own; either by snarfing the vertex buffer out of the Mesh object and getting the attribute ranges, or by entirely loading the file yourself (using an EnumObject to parse the file, etc).

When it comes down to it, though, the big savings in terrain is doing some kind of LOD for distant blocks, rather than drawing everything at full rez. I know Carmack says differently, but he's not trying for a 20 km visible horizon on last-generation hardware. He may be excused if he believes the world consists mostly of sewers and deep, winding canyons :-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks for the reply hplus. My reasons for using the .x file to store the terrain mesh is that with .x files I can use the built in calculatetangent() to get my tangents for my terrain, and DX will calculate my normals also. So with DX doing both of these this saves me more time if I move to DX from OpenGL... I am looking at what DX has to offer me in terms of getting me back to where I am at currently... I am assuming the calculateTangent is only for .X files...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
D3DXCalculateTangent is for D3DXMesh. Not .x files. Do not mix the two, D3DXMesh != .x file.

.x files are just a format you can use to store data.
You can load stuff from an .x file into a D3DXMesh, do the tangent calculations, and then get the vertex and index buffers from the D3DXMesh interface. Then render it in your own way. AFAIK DrawSubset calls SetVertexBuffer each time it is called, and that is not good. Expensive. With terrains, usually index buffer manipulations provide good results.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote:
Original post by darkelf2k5
D3DXCalculateTangent is for D3DXMesh. Not .x files. Do not mix the two, D3DXMesh != .x file.

.x files are just a format you can use to store data.
You can load stuff from an .x file into a D3DXMesh, do the tangent calculations, and then get the vertex and index buffers from the D3DXMesh interface. Then render it in your own way. AFAIK DrawSubset calls SetVertexBuffer each time it is called, and that is not good. Expensive. With terrains, usually index buffer manipulations provide good results.


AFAIK DX can't calculate tangent vectors unless your data is in D3DXMesh data format? My issue is I don't want to code more code to calculate tangent, normals ect... if DX can/will do it for me. I am also guessing that instancing works with the D3DXMesh format also?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
D3DX can calculate tangents and normals in any object of type ID3DXMesh, if that object has space for a tangent frame and normals in its vertex declarator.

You can create a ID3DXMesh with space from an ID3DXMesh without space by using CloneMesh().

You can put data from a .X file into an ID3DXMesh by using the convenient load functions; you can also write an ID3DXMesh to a .X file using the convenience functions.

However, you can also create an ID3DXMesh with data that comes from somewhere else, by just locking the index and vertex buffers and putting data into them.

Similarly, you can write data from an ID3DXMesh object to whatever file format you want, by just locking the vertex and index buffer and reading the data back out.

When you're creating an ID3DXMesh object to operate on like this, rather than drawing, then your best bet is to create it in SYSTEM or SCRATCH pools, which will give you better performance on computation. If you want to draw the mesh, use MANAGED pool.

.X files are swell for easy loading and saving of baseline mesh functionality. You can also bend them several ways, with subsets, materials, and using the LoadMeshHiearchy function to load. However, for a full-on scene graph or graphics engine, you'll probably find those functions too limited, and instead load your own; either using an enumeration object for the .X file, or by using your own file format.


Clear as mud?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Advertisement
  • Advertisement
  • Popular Tags

  • Popular Now

  • Advertisement
  • Similar Content

    • By LukasBanana
      Hi all,
       
      I'm trying to generate MIP-maps of a 2D-array texture, but only a limited amount of array layers and MIP-levels.
      For instance, to generate only the first 3 MIP-maps of a single array layer of a large 2D-array.
       
      After experimenting with glBlitFramebuffer to generate the MIP-maps manually but still with some sort of hardware acceleration,
      I ended up with glTextureView which already works with the limited amount of array layers (I can also verify the result in RenderDoc).
      However, glGenerateMipmap (or glGenerateTextureMipmap) always generates the entire MIP-chain for the specified array layer.
       
      Thus, the <numlevels> parameter of glTextureView seems to be ignored in the MIP-map generation process.
      I also tried to use glTexParameteri(..., GL_TEXTURE_MAX_LEVEL, 3), but this has the same result.
      Can anyone explain me how to solve this?
       
      Here is an example code, how I do it:
      void GenerateSubMips( GLuint texID, GLenum texTarget, GLenum internalFormat, GLuint baseMipLevel, GLuint numMipLevels, GLuint baseArrayLayer, GLuint numArrayLayers) { GLuint texViewID = 0; glGenTextures(1, &texViewID); glTextureView( texViewID, texTarget, texID, internalFormat, baseMipLevel, numMipLevels, baseArrayLayer, numArrayLayers ); glGenerateTextureMipmap(texViewID); glDeleteTextures(1, &texViewID); } GenerateSubMips( myTex, GL_TEXTURE_2D_ARRAY, GL_RGBA8, 0, 3, // only the first 3 MIP-maps 4, 1 // only one array layer with index 4 );  
      Thanks and kind regards,
      Lukas
    • By mmmax3d
      Hi everyone,
      I would need some assistance from anyone who has a similar experience
      or a nice idea!
      I have created a skybox (as cube) and now I need to add a floor/ground.
      The skybox is created from cubemap and initially it was infinite.
      Now it is finite with a specific size. The floor is a quad in the middle
      of the skybox, like a horizon.
      I have two problems:
      When moving the skybox upwards or downwards, I need to
      sample from points even above the horizon while sampling
      from the botton at the same time.  I am trying to create a seamless blending of the texture
      at the points of the horizon, when the quad is connected
      to the skybox. However, I get skew effects. Does anybody has done sth similar?
      Is there any good practice?
      Thanks everyone!
    • By mmmax3d
      Hi everyone,
      I would need some assistance from anyone who has a similar experience
      or a nice idea!
      I have created a skybox (as cube) and now I need to add a floor/ground.
      The skybox is created from cubemap and initially it was infinite.
      Now it is finite with a specific size. The floor is a quad in the middle
      of the skybox, like a horizon.
      I have two problems:
      When moving the skybox upwards or downwards, I need to
      sample from points even above the horizon while sampling
      from the botton at the same time.  I am trying to create a seamless blending of the texture
      at the points of the horizon, when the quad is connected
      to the skybox. However, I get skew effects. Does anybody has done sth similar?
      Is there any good practice?
      Thanks everyone!
    • By iArtist93
      I'm trying to implement PBR into my simple OpenGL renderer and trying to use multiple lighting passes, I'm using one pass per light for rendering as follow:
      1- First pass = depth
      2- Second pass = ambient
      3- [3 .. n] for all the lights in the scene.
      I'm using the blending function glBlendFunc(GL_ONE, GL_ONE) for passes [3..n], and i'm doing a Gamma Correction at the end of each fragment shader.
      But i still have a problem with the output image it just looks noisy specially when i'm using texture maps.
      Is there anything wrong with those steps or is there any improvement to this process?
    • By babaliaris
      Hello Everyone!
      I'm learning openGL, and currently i'm making a simple 2D game engine to test what I've learn so far.  In order to not say to much, i made a video in which i'm showing you the behavior of the rendering.
      Video: 
       
      What i was expecting to happen, was the player moving around. When i render only the player, he moves as i would expect. When i add a second Sprite object, instead of the Player, this new sprite object is moving and finally if i add a third Sprite object the third one is moving. And the weird think is that i'm transforming the Vertices of the Player so why the transformation is being applied somewhere else?
       
      Take a look at my code:
      Sprite Class
      (You mostly need to see the Constructor, the Render Method and the Move Method)
      #include "Brain.h" #include <glm/gtc/matrix_transform.hpp> #include <vector> struct Sprite::Implementation { //Position. struct pos pos; //Tag. std::string tag; //Texture. Texture *texture; //Model matrix. glm::mat4 model; //Vertex Array Object. VertexArray *vao; //Vertex Buffer Object. VertexBuffer *vbo; //Layout. VertexBufferLayout *layout; //Index Buffer Object. IndexBuffer *ibo; //Shader. Shader *program; //Brains. std::vector<Brain *> brains; //Deconstructor. ~Implementation(); }; Sprite::Sprite(std::string image_path, std::string tag, float x, float y) { //Create Pointer To Implementaion. m_Impl = new Implementation(); //Set the Position of the Sprite object. m_Impl->pos.x = x; m_Impl->pos.y = y; //Set the tag. m_Impl->tag = tag; //Create The Texture. m_Impl->texture = new Texture(image_path); //Initialize the model Matrix. m_Impl->model = glm::mat4(1.0f); //Get the Width and the Height of the Texture. int width = m_Impl->texture->GetWidth(); int height = m_Impl->texture->GetHeight(); //Create the Verticies. float verticies[] = { //Positions //Texture Coordinates. x, y, 0.0f, 0.0f, x + width, y, 1.0f, 0.0f, x + width, y + height, 1.0f, 1.0f, x, y + height, 0.0f, 1.0f }; //Create the Indicies. unsigned int indicies[] = { 0, 1, 2, 2, 3, 0 }; //Create Vertex Array. m_Impl->vao = new VertexArray(); //Create the Vertex Buffer. m_Impl->vbo = new VertexBuffer((void *)verticies, sizeof(verticies)); //Create The Layout. m_Impl->layout = new VertexBufferLayout(); m_Impl->layout->PushFloat(2); m_Impl->layout->PushFloat(2); m_Impl->vao->AddBuffer(m_Impl->vbo, m_Impl->layout); //Create the Index Buffer. m_Impl->ibo = new IndexBuffer(indicies, 6); //Create the new shader. m_Impl->program = new Shader("Shaders/SpriteShader.shader"); } //Render. void Sprite::Render(Window * window) { //Create the projection Matrix based on the current window width and height. glm::mat4 proj = glm::ortho(0.0f, (float)window->GetWidth(), 0.0f, (float)window->GetHeight(), -1.0f, 1.0f); //Set the MVP Uniform. m_Impl->program->setUniformMat4f("u_MVP", proj * m_Impl->model); //Run All The Brains (Scripts) of this game object (sprite). for (unsigned int i = 0; i < m_Impl->brains.size(); i++) { //Get Current Brain. Brain *brain = m_Impl->brains[i]; //Call the start function only once! if (brain->GetStart()) { brain->SetStart(false); brain->Start(); } //Call the update function every frame. brain->Update(); } //Render. window->GetRenderer()->Draw(m_Impl->vao, m_Impl->ibo, m_Impl->texture, m_Impl->program); } void Sprite::Move(float speed, bool left, bool right, bool up, bool down) { if (left) { m_Impl->pos.x -= speed; m_Impl->model = glm::translate(m_Impl->model, glm::vec3(-speed, 0, 0)); } if (right) { m_Impl->pos.x += speed; m_Impl->model = glm::translate(m_Impl->model, glm::vec3(speed, 0, 0)); } if (up) { m_Impl->pos.y += speed; m_Impl->model = glm::translate(m_Impl->model, glm::vec3(0, speed, 0)); } if (down) { m_Impl->pos.y -= speed; m_Impl->model = glm::translate(m_Impl->model, glm::vec3(0, -speed, 0)); } } void Sprite::AddBrain(Brain * brain) { //Push back the brain object. m_Impl->brains.push_back(brain); } pos *Sprite::GetPos() { return &m_Impl->pos; } std::string Sprite::GetTag() { return m_Impl->tag; } int Sprite::GetWidth() { return m_Impl->texture->GetWidth(); } int Sprite::GetHeight() { return m_Impl->texture->GetHeight(); } Sprite::~Sprite() { delete m_Impl; } //Implementation Deconstructor. Sprite::Implementation::~Implementation() { delete texture; delete vao; delete vbo; delete layout; delete ibo; delete program; }  
      Renderer Class
      #include "Renderer.h" #include "Error.h" Renderer::Renderer() { } Renderer::~Renderer() { } void Renderer::Draw(VertexArray * vao, IndexBuffer * ibo, Texture *texture, Shader * program) { vao->Bind(); ibo->Bind(); program->Bind(); if (texture != NULL) texture->Bind(); GLCall(glDrawElements(GL_TRIANGLES, ibo->GetCount(), GL_UNSIGNED_INT, NULL)); } void Renderer::Clear(float r, float g, float b) { GLCall(glClearColor(r, g, b, 1.0)); GLCall(glClear(GL_COLOR_BUFFER_BIT)); } void Renderer::Update(GLFWwindow *window) { /* Swap front and back buffers */ glfwSwapBuffers(window); /* Poll for and process events */ glfwPollEvents(); }  
      Shader Code
      #shader vertex #version 330 core layout(location = 0) in vec4 aPos; layout(location = 1) in vec2 aTexCoord; out vec2 t_TexCoord; uniform mat4 u_MVP; void main() { gl_Position = u_MVP * aPos; t_TexCoord = aTexCoord; } #shader fragment #version 330 core out vec4 aColor; in vec2 t_TexCoord; uniform sampler2D u_Texture; void main() { aColor = texture(u_Texture, t_TexCoord); } Also i'm pretty sure that every time i'm hitting the up, down, left and right arrows on the keyboard, i'm changing the model Matrix of the Player and not the others.
       
      Window Class:
      #include "Window.h" #include <GL/glew.h> #include <GLFW/glfw3.h> #include "Error.h" #include "Renderer.h" #include "Scene.h" #include "Input.h" //Global Variables. int screen_width, screen_height; //On Window Resize. void OnWindowResize(GLFWwindow *window, int width, int height); //Implementation Structure. struct Window::Implementation { //GLFW Window. GLFWwindow *GLFW_window; //Renderer. Renderer *renderer; //Delta Time. double delta_time; //Frames Per Second. int fps; //Scene. Scene *scnene; //Input. Input *input; //Deconstructor. ~Implementation(); }; //Window Constructor. Window::Window(std::string title, int width, int height) { //Initializing width and height. screen_width = width; screen_height = height; //Create Pointer To Implementation. m_Impl = new Implementation(); //Try initializing GLFW. if (!glfwInit()) { std::cout << "GLFW could not be initialized!" << std::endl; std::cout << "Press ENTER to exit..." << std::endl; std::cin.get(); exit(-1); } //Setting up OpenGL Version 3.3 Core Profile. glfwWindowHint(GLFW_CONTEXT_VERSION_MAJOR, 3); glfwWindowHint(GLFW_CONTEXT_VERSION_MINOR, 3); glfwWindowHint(GLFW_OPENGL_PROFILE, GLFW_OPENGL_CORE_PROFILE); /* Create a windowed mode window and its OpenGL context */ m_Impl->GLFW_window = glfwCreateWindow(width, height, title.c_str(), NULL, NULL); if (!m_Impl->GLFW_window) { std::cout << "GLFW could not create a window!" << std::endl; std::cout << "Press ENTER to exit..." << std::endl; std::cin.get(); glfwTerminate(); exit(-1); } /* Make the window's context current */ glfwMakeContextCurrent(m_Impl->GLFW_window); //Initialize GLEW. if(glewInit() != GLEW_OK) { std::cout << "GLEW could not be initialized!" << std::endl; std::cout << "Press ENTER to exit..." << std::endl; std::cin.get(); glfwTerminate(); exit(-1); } //Enabling Blending. GLCall(glEnable(GL_BLEND)); GLCall(glBlendFunc(GL_SRC_ALPHA, GL_ONE_MINUS_SRC_ALPHA)); //Setting the ViewPort. GLCall(glViewport(0, 0, width, height)); //**********Initializing Implementation**********// m_Impl->renderer = new Renderer(); m_Impl->delta_time = 0.0; m_Impl->fps = 0; m_Impl->input = new Input(this); //**********Initializing Implementation**********// //Set Frame Buffer Size Callback. glfwSetFramebufferSizeCallback(m_Impl->GLFW_window, OnWindowResize); } //Window Deconstructor. Window::~Window() { delete m_Impl; } //Window Main Loop. void Window::MainLoop() { //Time Variables. double start_time = 0, end_time = 0, old_time = 0, total_time = 0; //Frames Counter. int frames = 0; /* Loop until the user closes the window */ while (!glfwWindowShouldClose(m_Impl->GLFW_window)) { old_time = start_time; //Total time of previous frame. start_time = glfwGetTime(); //Current frame start time. //Calculate the Delta Time. m_Impl->delta_time = start_time - old_time; //Get Frames Per Second. if (total_time >= 1) { m_Impl->fps = frames; total_time = 0; frames = 0; } //Clearing The Screen. m_Impl->renderer->Clear(0, 0, 0); //Render The Scene. if (m_Impl->scnene != NULL) m_Impl->scnene->Render(this); //Updating the Screen. m_Impl->renderer->Update(m_Impl->GLFW_window); //Increasing frames counter. frames++; //End Time. end_time = glfwGetTime(); //Total time after the frame completed. total_time += end_time - start_time; } //Terminate GLFW. glfwTerminate(); } //Load Scene. void Window::LoadScene(Scene * scene) { //Set the scene. m_Impl->scnene = scene; } //Get Delta Time. double Window::GetDeltaTime() { return m_Impl->delta_time; } //Get FPS. int Window::GetFPS() { return m_Impl->fps; } //Get Width. int Window::GetWidth() { return screen_width; } //Get Height. int Window::GetHeight() { return screen_height; } //Get Input. Input * Window::GetInput() { return m_Impl->input; } Renderer * Window::GetRenderer() { return m_Impl->renderer; } GLFWwindow * Window::GetGLFWindow() { return m_Impl->GLFW_window; } //Implementation Deconstructor. Window::Implementation::~Implementation() { delete renderer; delete input; } //OnWindowResize void OnWindowResize(GLFWwindow *window, int width, int height) { screen_width = width; screen_height = height; //Updating the ViewPort. GLCall(glViewport(0, 0, width, height)); }  
      Brain Class
      #include "Brain.h" #include "Sprite.h" #include "Window.h" struct Brain::Implementation { //Just A Flag. bool started; //Window Pointer. Window *window; //Sprite Pointer. Sprite *sprite; }; Brain::Brain(Window *window, Sprite *sprite) { //Create Pointer To Implementation. m_Impl = new Implementation(); //Initialize Implementation. m_Impl->started = true; m_Impl->window = window; m_Impl->sprite = sprite; } Brain::~Brain() { //Delete Pointer To Implementation. delete m_Impl; } void Brain::Start() { } void Brain::Update() { } Window * Brain::GetWindow() { return m_Impl->window; } Sprite * Brain::GetSprite() { return m_Impl->sprite; } bool Brain::GetStart() { return m_Impl->started; } void Brain::SetStart(bool value) { m_Impl->started = value; } Script Class (Its a Brain Subclass!!!)
      #include "Script.h" Script::Script(Window *window, Sprite *sprite) : Brain(window, sprite) { } Script::~Script() { } void Script::Start() { std::cout << "Game Started!" << std::endl; } void Script::Update() { Input *input = this->GetWindow()->GetInput(); Sprite *sp = this->GetSprite(); //Move this sprite. this->GetSprite()->Move(200 * this->GetWindow()->GetDeltaTime(), input->GetKeyDown("left"), input->GetKeyDown("right"), input->GetKeyDown("up"), input->GetKeyDown("down")); std::cout << sp->GetTag().c_str() << ".x = " << sp->GetPos()->x << ", " << sp->GetTag().c_str() << ".y = " << sp->GetPos()->y << std::endl; }  
      Main:
      #include "SpaceShooterEngine.h" #include "Script.h" int main() { Window w("title", 600,600); Scene *scene = new Scene(); Sprite *player = new Sprite("Resources/Images/player.png", "Player", 100,100); Sprite *other = new Sprite("Resources/Images/cherno.png", "Other", 400, 100); Sprite *other2 = new Sprite("Resources/Images/cherno.png", "Other", 300, 400); Brain *brain = new Script(&w, player); player->AddBrain(brain); scene->AddSprite(player); scene->AddSprite(other); scene->AddSprite(other2); w.LoadScene(scene); w.MainLoop(); return 0; }  
       
      I literally can't find what is wrong. If you need more code, ask me to post it. I will also attach all the source files.
      Brain.cpp
      Error.cpp
      IndexBuffer.cpp
      Input.cpp
      Renderer.cpp
      Scene.cpp
      Shader.cpp
      Sprite.cpp
      Texture.cpp
      VertexArray.cpp
      VertexBuffer.cpp
      VertexBufferLayout.cpp
      Window.cpp
      Brain.h
      Error.h
      IndexBuffer.h
      Input.h
      Renderer.h
      Scene.h
      Shader.h
      SpaceShooterEngine.h
      Sprite.h
      Texture.h
      VertexArray.h
      VertexBuffer.h
      VertexBufferLayout.h
      Window.h
  • Advertisement
×

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

Participate in the game development conversation and more when you create an account on GameDev.net!

Sign me up!