Sign in to follow this  

Unity Best Game Engine for Indie Game?

This topic is 2422 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Recommended Posts

Just a point about the NeoAxis engine, the free version is non-commercial. There is an indie license (Less than $100000 income from the product) as well as a commercial license (More than $100000 income from the product), which cost $95 and $395 respectively (http://www.neoaxisgroup.com/services/licensing).

Other than that, I have used one of the engines listed, Torque 3D or rather the earlier version, Torque Game Engine Advanced, however this was only brief so i can't really give you much of an opinion of it, but i suggest taking a close look at what you need, who you think your target audience is and so on, this should help you to make a choice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
@Undeadragonslayer

Thanks for the input. I didn't see anything about a commercial license on the website for NeoAxis, so I'll have to go double check that. To address your questions...

Quote:
i suggest taking a close look at what you need, who you think your target audience is and so on, this should help you to make a choice.

My target audience is primarily PC users, probably more hardcore (thus better hardware) gamers who enjoy FPS games. Although I suspect that 90% of people who would want to play would be Windows gamers with decent hardware, I would hate to have to unnecessarily alienate potential players.

As for what I need, basically I just need a complete game engine including tools to setup levels. I don't necessarily need the best engine ever with an event system, AI, etc.. as I can program all of that myself. It would be nice to have an engine that doesn't require high specs and is cross-platform, but I have no idea how many potential customers I would be alienating if I went with a high-spec, PC only engine like Leadwerks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
How many programmers do you have? With Torque 3D you only need licenses for the programmers that need the source to the engine. You're allowed to give a working build of your game to your artists so they can see their work (I'm not sure about leaving the script based editors in you'd have to ask about that), but either way, if they don't allow that there is a non-source license for $250 that you give to other members of your team, though I think they might be getting a little more lenient on this.

I haven't subscribed to it because I'm only a hobbyists and I now prefer C# over C++, so I'm working more with TX3D instead (which is not in the same league as T3D).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
@blitzwing

So far I am the only programmer, I wanted to look at all the engines and decide on a technology before getting any more programmers. The only real need for the $1k license was to get the "advanced lighting", which is just parallax maps and shadow maps it seems like. However, I'm going to need level designers to actually setup the levels, and I'm fairly certain they would also need the $1k license to view their levels in the scene editor with advanced lighting enabled.

@zebeste

I tried looking at the C4 engine earlier today. It looked like a pretty attractive offer on the website, but when I went to test the demo things didn't go so great. A couple times I tried to load a level and it just sat there for a while, eventually leading me to have to turn the computer off manually. Also, the physics seem very hoaky.. getting stuck on tiny cracks in the ground, really weird feeling collision detection. I only tested C4 on my laptop so I'll have to try again on my desktop later.. but it just left sort of a bad taste in my mouth. (Sorry if you're one of the developers on it, it's still an impressive engine.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nope, I'm not a developer of the engine (that title is reserved for Eric Lengyel). I don't know why it froze you laptop, but the physics in the engine is getting a complete overhaul in the next release. Also, one of the members maintains a PhysX integration which supposedly works quite well. Currently, the character uses a collision capsule for physics, which probably explains why it feels a little wierd, but as of the next release users will be able to use the world editor to use combinations of geometric shapes on models to represent more complex collision volumes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
@jyk

I had actually never heard of Unity before. I downloaded it and took a look, that's definitely a very nice, professional engine. I'll have to take a serious look into that one.

@zebeste

I don't want to take anything away from any developer that's worked on the C4 engine, I know it's a ton of work to do something like that, but I just don't feel like C4 is solid enough to use for a real game yet.


After doing a ton of testing, the NeoAxis engine is looking like the best option at this point. The downloadable demo is extremely impressive, and the ability to produce something worth playing with a free version definitely says something. At the moment, it is restricted to Windows only platforms, but in the future there are plans to expand to Mac, consoles, and web deployment which is a very promising feature.

On the other hand though, Torque 3D is still a proven, professional quality product and it's nice to know that there is a huge user community of support out there. My plan from here is to test out the actual programming of NeoAxis and see if it's suited for a real game. If not, I think I'll have to go with Torque 3D.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Try the A7 Engine but is not c++ is lite-c it cost $100.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Maybe look at Panda3d as well? It's got a track record. And it's free. And it's got a large community. And it's used in Python, but made in C++, so you can extend it in C++ and make your game in python. This may be a good or bad thing to you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
There is also this one:

http://www.esenthel.com/?id=news

Really awesome c++ engine, 0$, 200$ or 1000$, depending if you wish to use custom shaders and or sell the game.

Some even says its better then gamebryo ect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Why dont u try fps creator? Its the easiest engine for making fpses and fps creator x10 has directx10 graphics. Dont use leadwerks as its mostly a rendering engine. Id use unity as its been proven in a bunch of games and is really easy to use.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote:
Original post by NightMarez
http://www.esenthel.com/?id=news

Really awesome c++ engine, 0$, 200$ or 1000$, depending if you wish to use custom shaders and or sell the game.


I was just about to suggest you check it out, surprised to see that someone beat me to it. Esenthel is one of those little gems that has all of the pieces needed, you really just have to learn how to use those pieces. OOTB, it comes with a mesh editor and world editor, source updater (to keep it current), and tons of examples covering most stuff people are actually interested in for games.

This isn't to say it's the only engine you should consider, but it does have all of the things you said you were looking for, at a very attractive price if you're not going commercial or wanting more than the default shaders. Definitely worth it to check it out.

FlyingIsFun1217

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I put my vote in for Leadwerks, very nice features for it´s price. You can have a character controller with physics and fps camera up and running in minutes. When your game is finished most people will probably have SM 3 cards, check Steam´s hardware survey http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote:
Original post by bengaltgrs

@zebeste

I tried looking at the C4 engine earlier today. It looked like a pretty attractive offer on the website, but when I went to test the demo things didn't go so great. A couple times I tried to load a level and it just sat there for a while, eventually leading me to have to turn the computer off manually. Also, the physics seem very hoaky.. getting stuck on tiny cracks in the ground, really weird feeling collision detection. I only tested C4 on my laptop so I'll have to try again on my desktop later.. but it just left sort of a bad taste in my mouth. (Sorry if you're one of the developers on it, it's still an impressive engine.)


Hi bengaltgrs it seams you were misguided by the simplistic physics of the C4 demo, the engine can use any physics API and there are users with a PhysX and Bullet integration already done, also Eric is making a on house physics engine for C4 version 1.6 (the next version) and will do a revised demo to showcase the physics and the new terrain features. You say you add problems running the C4 engine demo, without your laptop specs i can only speculate, but it needs a fairly good GPU (NV 6600 or better ATI x1300 or better) to run also because of the new voxel terrain shader it will not run on Intel GPU's if your laptop as a Intel GPU them that's why it didn't worked well.

Quote:
I don't want to take anything away from any developer that's worked on the C4 engine, I know it's a ton of work to do something like that, but I just don't feel like C4 is solid enough to use for a real game yet.


About this, it is wrong, C4 engine is ready for real games and that's why there are already games for sell made with it.

Some examples:
http://www.world-of-subways.com/

http://www.questofpersia.com/main/index.html

Games in the making:

http://www.greysoul.net/

http://celestialspheregame.com/

http://www.perfectblackgames.com/tvd/

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KfltWNBLkAU

http://www.bleedingcolourstudio.com/php/adf.php

And more....

I hope this helps clear all misconceptions about C4 engine.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm developing an outdoor FPS, and I'm settling on C4 as my engine choice. Unity and Neoaxis are strong contenders. I also considered 3D Gamestudio A7, and I've heard good things about Panda3D as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If you ask any professional developer (indie or otherwise) I'm sure you'll find that there is no "Best Game Engine". There are always +'s and -'s when you talk about any game engine be it Unreal or Torque.

So for now what you want to look at is the "Best Game Engine" for your purposes. Which means evaluating things like:

1) Is the engine primaraly a FPS engine? If so then making another type of game such as a RPG or third person action game with it might not be feasable due to design decisions made.

2) Features. If you plan to use HDR and the engine doesn't support it...well you can see where this is going.

3) Support. The game engine you are using either needs to have support via it's developers or through a well established community (no startup engines here). Otherwise how are you going to get questions answered?

4) Tools, Your looking for an engine that has plugins for the modeling program you use, particle editors, ect. Buying an engine that only has max plugins is useless unless you actually have 3d studio max. Other tools for the engine itself help with your development/prototyping pipeline, if they suck then people are going to get frustrated and say "This engine sucks".

In short the best engine is what works for your needs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote:
Original post by HostileExpanse
I'm developing an outdoor FPS, and I'm settling on C4 as my engine choice. Unity and Neoaxis are strong contenders. I also considered 3D Gamestudio A7, and I've heard good things about Panda3D as well.


Wow, you must know quite a few programming languages pretty well.

FlyingIsFun1217

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote:
Original post by bengaltgrs
I tried looking at the C4 engine earlier today. It looked like a pretty attractive offer on the website, but when I went to test the demo things didn't go so great. A couple times I tried to load a level and it just sat there for a while, eventually leading me to have to turn the computer off manually.


An application by itself cannot freeze your computer to the point that you have to turn off the power. But a driver can. Either your graphics hardware is fried, and/or your graphics drivers are completely broken, and that's what should be putting a bad taste in your mouth. Levels in the C4 demo load in 1-2 seconds on properly working hardware with properly working drivers, and it would be an incorrect assumption to hastily conclude that any problems you had with the demo are the fault of the engine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I too got a little bit scared of the C4 demos, especially so because of the physics. Got stuck in some cave and had to restart. But C4 has support from it's awesome author which is more than you can say about Torque which I've been using since 2003 now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
what about 3DRAD ?

I have made a full game using 3DRAD. It's not hard at all, just requires some patience working around it's limitations.

check out my demo at :

http://tinystudents.com/3drad.html


YOUTUBE VIDEO :
=============

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpnvOvtNGiY

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This topic is 2422 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By red1m3n
      Hi I'm a hobbyist getting together a team to pursue game creation, we'll do both 2D and 3D games, we would definitely build different types of games, and hopefully have a great time doing it. you dont have to have much experience, just enough that you think you can fill the position. I have plenty of ideas for games that I'd love your help with, and am completely open to fulfilling your game ideas . As of right now this is a for fun project thing, but if me and my team are satisfied with our work it can be published to steam or other platforms. 
      The positions I'm currently looking to fill are:
      2D Pixel artist
      3D Modeler 
      C# programmer
      Musician/Sound engineer
      I am currently working on a project it is a 2D Merchant adventure game with survival elements. It does not have a name yet, that's because I'm bad with names. 
       
      If interested please feel free to leave me a PM or email at dealtavu@gmail.com so we can talk more about it..
    • By Aggrojag
      Hello!
      I'm working on a game that is quite personal to me. It touches on my own depression, obsessions, phobias, etc. It's a narrative driven dark comedy with some small aspects of platforming and puzzle solving. The project is rather small as well. It touches on topics such as suicide, mental illness, family, corruption, free-will, and redemption.
      First, I'm looking for a 2D animator that can compliment the style of the attached image. The player character's animations will be a bit more extensive than a typical platformer. There will be many death animations, and some other strange dealings with the character that will need animation. Other items will include some objects in the world that are in need of animation. All static pieces of art will be handled by the artist that drew the attached image.
      Second, I'm looking for a male voice actor. There will be at minimum two characters that will need to be brought to life through vocals. They are a very core part of the game, though they will never be shown on screen. As a reminder, this is a rather dark comedy, so be prepared for some insanity in your portrayal of these characters. The first voice is that of a game show host's voice, while the other will be a devilish voice (without SFX, I think it cheapens it, does not necessarily need to be a low voice, this is more about the portrayal than how the voice sounds).
      Last, I would love to have an editor on board. More than just avoiding disaster in the writing, I'm looking for someone that can elevate it. There is not a ton of writing that will be in the final project, but it's important enough of an aspect to be trying to bring someone in to help with it.
      To those interested:
      I have a crappy prototype that exists, along with a couple game design docs. More than anything, I'd like to present the project through a voice chat via discord to any interested. Discord - Bobdul Thundercuck#4590
      I do plan to post this on itch.io and wherever else I can put it that makes sense. I fully expect to make nothing off this project, as should you. However, in the case that money is made, a rev share model will be in place.

       
      Edit: Editor position has been filled, title has been changed to reflect this, and crossed out the section detailing this.
    • By William Edmeades
      Hey guys and girls,   Have you ever found yourself trying to apply for a job to be a game developer or a game artist? Maybe a sound engineer or a script writer? Only to not even get an interview due to lack of ‘experience’, teamwork projects or released game titles you have worked on? I have for sure. The game industry is hard and competitive to get into for someone new, especially when you might have a full time job or even have to support a family. So I have come up with an idea and I wanted to throw something out there to see if people could be interested in such an idea.   What if you could be part of a virtual game development company? A place where you can work on projects with a team of people from the internet, soon to be known as your colleagues, which could be from anywhere in the world all working at your own pace when you have time to do as little or as much as you want.   The idea is we can create the power of a company and release titles together. Not only do you then have a released game title you have worked on under your resume, but also work experience, team work skills, and the power of helping each other and learning from each other.    My dream idea is to create a solid place for people to join a party and develop ideas and create games and level up it experience points.   As far as money is concerned, the games would either be released for free or any money would go towards charity, it’s not about making money, it’s about building a career or justness having fun building games and socialising with like minded people.    I want to make something amazing, I think it would benefit me, and I think others who are serious would benefit greatly too.   I await your critasism on the ‘prototype’ idea, I just wanted to see how many people would be interested in such a concept. And if you are very much into the idea, let’s make it happen.   Thanks,   Will. www.feelingterrible.com
    • By NDraskovic
      Hey guys,
      Like the title says, I'm trying to find out if it's possible to automatically set which scenes will be built for different platforms. For instance, I have scenes that I want to include when building for PC, but exclude them for mobile platforms. Is it possible to do this automatically (by some settings file, or by coding some editor extension), or do I have to manually (de)select them each time I switch platforms?
      Google just keeps sending me to the documentation sites about the regular publishing, but I can't find information about this problem.
      Thanks in advance
    • By Slack Dragon
      Download here: https://slackdragon.itch.io/dungeon-chop-chop
       
      Dungeon Chop Chop is a Singleplayer / Co-Op Rogue-like Adventure game currently in development. 
      All feedback is greatly appreciated
       
      About:
      An admirable soul tainted by darkness has laid waste to 
      the land. He has robbed civilians of their riches and lurks in 
      a dungeon locked with sorcery and guarded by monsters. 
      With treasure to claim, demons to slay and eternal fame to 
      be won, adventurers travel from far and wide to test their 
      strength against this enemy. 
      Many have tried and not a single one has returned! 
      Will you be the challenger who finally breaks the seal and 
      restore peace to the land? 
       
      Consider supporting us at:     https://www.patreon.com/SlackDragon
      Check us out on Twitter:    https://twitter.com/SlackDragonDevs
      Designers:
      Lead   Shannon Stefan Programmers:
      Lead  Harrison Jack Artists:
      Jerome Tin David





  • Popular Now