Sign in to follow this  
Hodgeka

Irrlicht vs Ogre3D

Recommended Posts

I'm looking to develop some simple games.
I'm thinking of starting with a game engine and I ran into Ogre3D and Irrlicht.

Which one do you think is better, and why? ( documentation, flexibility, etc )



Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi,
They both are good [b]graphics engines[/b] with excellent documentation and helpful communities. Neither engine is a game engine: alone these libraries only cater for graphics.

To me, the choice of one graphic engine boils down to personal preference.

Irrlicht has a little less features than Ogre 3D straight out of the box (though you can easily expand Irrlicht to add more features). But it is completed by other toolsets:
- a 3d world editor (irrEdit)
- a 2d and 3d sound engine (irrKlang)

As a lone programmer, I prefer Irrlicht because of its available toolsets which let me focus on realizing a game. When I started with Irrlicht a few years ago, it had a simpler interface than Ogre 3D. I do not know if it is still true today as Ogre 3D also improved its interface.

For my games, I use Irrlicht for graphics, Irrklang for sound (though it can be replaced by another sound library), SFML for network management and multithreading interface. Note that most of my time is not spent in programming, but creating the resources for a game (especially in turn based wargames). This is why I favored simple interface and existing toolsets.

Hope that helps,

Ghostly yours,
Red.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Also, another question:

What really is the difference between say Irrlicht and OpenGL?
And what would you use to implement physics?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote name='Hodgeka' timestamp='1298041186' post='4775887']
What really is the difference between say Irrlicht and OpenGL?
And what would you use to implement physics?
[/quote]

Hi,

1) Irrlicht vs OpenGL
OpenGL is a graphics library. It provides low level functions for displaying 3D graphics. Implementing effects, model loading and display, organizing the scene is the responsability of the developper. Irrlicht is a graphics engine which provides high level functions to display effects, load and animate models, display a scene. Irrlicht is built on top of a graphic library (even 3 as it let you choose between 3 underlying graphics libraries : OpenGL, DirectX or a software emulation).

2) Physics engine
Since I prefer turn based games, I have no use for physics engine. Basic physic implementation is enough for my own projects. I haven't compared existing physics engine so I can't really answer your question there.
My own methodology to compare libraries is to:
a) check what are my needs
B) list all libraries that fufill my needs (checking if they have direct documentation for implementation)
c) look at the libraries interface to see which are the easiest to use.

That's all.

Ghostly yours,
Red.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm using Ogre3D and I quite like it. I've never tried Irrlicht so I can't really comment. Ogre3D can use a variety of API/frameworks (OpenGL/Directx etc) under the hood without you really needing to change much at all. It has lots of things going for it. I have a sort of fps game with it at the moment with menus/ui/animation/particles all working very well. I will say that the particle editor I use is fairly buggy, as is the ui editor. I pretty much end up having to write out xml/particle scripts without the editors they cause me so much trouble.

I use PhysX for my physics which was relatively simple to to get working with Ogre. I use blender for modelling (exporter works well). Over all I am quite pleased with Ogre, its just the ui/particle editors that are somewhat poor in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hey thanks much for the replies, I think I am starting understand how things work a little better. I think I'm going to get Ogre3D and start working with it, along with learning some OpenGL since we will use that in my Computer Graphics course. I will check PhysX out as well!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this