Jump to content
  • Advertisement
Sign in to follow this  
3DModelerMan

References to other games in an XBox Live Arcade XNA game

This topic is 2542 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Recommended Posts

Is it allowed to reference other games in one of your own if you plan to sell it? For example, I want to make a game that's kind of a spoof of other ones. If my character was to come across a purple hilted sword in a pedestal, and say "Huh, this looks strangely familiar". Would that be okay? Or if there were blocks with "?" on them?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement

Is it allowed to reference other games in one of your own if you plan to sell it? For example, I want to make a game that's kind of a spoof of other ones. If my character was to come across a purple hilted sword in a pedestal, and say "Huh, this looks strangely familiar". Would that be okay? Or if there were blocks with "?" on them?


The answer is "maybe".

You might be okay, you might not. That is grey area. That means it is something decided by the courts on a case-by-case basis.

You might not be noticed. Or they might notice and ignore you. Or they might notice and take action. If the property owner does take action, what are you going to do when you get a Cease and Desist order? Are you going to take it into a lawsuit and fight it in the courts because you think you are right, or are you going to stop?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
"It depends." The sword probably wouldn't make the IP owner want to take action against you, but drawing attention to it might.
The block with a question mark on it probably wouldn't make the IP owner want to take action against you, unless you do it using pixel-for-pixel art, and make it behave exactly the way the original block acts, and also incorporate a number of other items from the same IP owner's games.

You asked "is it allowed if I" -- that's the wrong question. The right question is "might the IP owner take action against me if I"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Spoofs are not ilegal. In fact I think the law says you can spoof anything you want. I know for a fact that celerbies are not allowed to sue someone for making spoofs based off them. As long as its clearly a joke I don't think they can do anything. To be safe do not copy anything exalty. Make everything a "likeness" of the object and give it a parody name. Also don't mention games by name because then they can get you for product placment charges. And most of all do not copy the games companies logo. They can defanitly get you for that. You can make fun of other games plot but don't have your charactor "follow" the plot. Basicly don't copy the game itself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Spoofs are not ilegal. In fact I think the law says you can spoof anything you want.
2) I know for a fact that celerbies are not allowed to sue someone for making spoofs based off them.
3) As long as its clearly a joke I don't think they can do anything.
4) To be safe do not copy anything exalty. Make everything a "likeness" of the object and give it a parody name.
5) You can make fun of other games plot but don't have your charactor "follow" the plot.

Bad advice.


Even if you are legally in the right, you still may face a lawsuit. It can cost a fortune to defend such a suit, even if your use is perfectly legal. Are you prepared to mortgage your home or go into six-figure debt to fight such a fight? If no, then don't do it.


1) There are very strict guides that fall entirely within the court's judgement. The line between "parody" and "defamation", or between "parody" and "derivative work" is sometimes very thin. Only the courts get to make that determination.

2) The thing that you "know for a fact" is quite wrong. Many celebrities take legal action against those who use their names or likeness, even in parody. They are very much within their rights to sue. The same is true for businesses who sue when their names, products, or other intellectual property is used. In many cases they actually must sue in order to protect their rights; if they knew about it and did not sue it could dilute their protections.

3) Something that is "clearly a joke" to one person may be "infringement" to another. That type of thing has been taken to courts many times, often ending very badly for the infringer.

4) A "likeness" is exactly what the law covers. If the object is at all similar (in the opinion of the court, not you) then it could be infringing.

5) You don't need to follow their plots exactly. Having a sufficient similarity to their world, to their objects, or to their characters can be a violation of IP rights. The original creator has the rights to make derivative works, and that includes incorporating the items in other games.


Claiming parody is an affirmative defense. That is, you can easily be sued. When you get to court, your claiming it is a parody means that you did knowingly infringe, but that your parody is a permitted exception under the law. If the judge doesn't agree that it fits the narrow definition of parody then you have very little recourse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name='Discount_Flunky' timestamp='1317655988' post='4868582']
1) Spoofs are not ilegal. In fact I think the law says you can spoof anything you want.
2) I know for a fact that celerbies are not allowed to sue someone for making spoofs based off them.
3) As long as its clearly a joke I don't think they can do anything.
4) To be safe do not copy anything exalty. Make everything a "likeness" of the object and give it a parody name.
5) You can make fun of other games plot but don't have your charactor "follow" the plot.

Bad advice.


Even if you are legally in the right, you still may face a lawsuit. It can cost a fortune to defend such a suit, even if your use is perfectly legal. Are you prepared to mortgage your home or go into six-figure debt to fight such a fight? If no, then don't do it.


1) There are very strict guides that fall entirely within the court's judgement. The line between "parody" and "defamation", or between "parody" and "derivative work" is sometimes very thin. Only the courts get to make that determination.

2) The thing that you "know for a fact" is quite wrong. Many celebrities take legal action against those who use their names or likeness, even in parody. They are very much within their rights to sue. The same is true for businesses who sue when their names, products, or other intellectual property is used. In many cases they actually must sue in order to protect their rights; if they knew about it and did not sue it could dilute their protections.

3) Something that is "clearly a joke" to one person may be "infringement" to another. That type of thing has been taken to courts many times, often ending very badly for the infringer.

4) A "likeness" is exactly what the law covers. If the object is at all similar (in the opinion of the court, not you) then it could be infringing.

5) You don't need to follow their plots exactly. Having a sufficient similarity to their world, to their objects, or to their characters can be a violation of IP rights. The original creator has the rights to make derivative works, and that includes incorporating the items in other games.


Claiming parody is an affirmative defense. That is, you can easily be sued. When you get to court, your claiming it is a parody means that you did knowingly infringe, but that your parody is a permitted exception under the law. If the judge doesn't agree that it fits the narrow definition of parody then you have very little recourse.
[/quote]




What if you were to E-Mail the IP owner? Would it be unrealistic to assume that I could get written permission?


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


What if you were to E-Mail the IP owner? Would it be unrealistic to assume that I could get written permission?



What about it?

Of course you can ask! You didn't mention that at all in your post, you simply talked about potential IP infringement.


If they are a tiny shop there is a non-zero chance they would just let it slide rather than requiring payment.

If they are a major shop or publisher they are much less likely to go for it without some sort of licensing agreement, usually involving significant amounts of real money.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Frob is technically correct, someone can sue you over almost anything. It can be prohibitively expensive (in time and money) to mount a legal defence rather than cease and desist.

However, in the real world you will be facing mostly rational legal entities. In particular, most companies cannot financially afford to behave less than rationally.

You are unlikely to be the target of a frivolous lawsuit for an honest parody by a rational adversary. If your opponent is not rational, the chances of a frivolous lawsuit are about the same whether you include the parody or not.

That said, if you want to be sure, get the advice if a lawyer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You are unlikely to be the target of a frivolous lawsuit for an honest parody by a rational adversary. If your opponent is not rational, the chances of a frivolous lawsuit are about the same whether you include the parody or not.

That said, if you want to be sure, get the advice if a lawyer.


Assuming the OP is creating a game, and assuming he wants the game to become successful and widely deployed, when the product reaches a large enough size it will (eventually) attract the attention of the IP owner.

If you are thinking small, you have no assets and resources, and you aren't planning on a big release to anywhere like XBLA, and probably only your few friends will ever know about it, then rip-off is right that you aren't yet worth the resources. Eventually you may become worth the resources, and you don't get much advance notice to when you have crossed that line.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
No, my point wasn't that small fry aren't worth the resources to pursue. I never made any reference to the size of the audience or whether the game would attract the attention of the IP owner. These are irrelevant in legal terms. My point was that a "real" parody is not worth pursuing seriously. If I were really parodying your game, would you actually sue me? You might threaten to sue, sure. I don't think you'd actually take me to court because you would lose.

Your first post seemed to say "you could be sued, is it worth it"? My response is that anyone can sue you for almost anything, so that is a weak reason not to do something. The real issue is to understand the risk. My point about rational entities is aimed at finding this true risk.

This thread is quite different from 95% of similar threads here, in which the OP wants to outright copy a game. Parody is perfectly protected. I don't think it is right or fair to discourage people from making parodies. They are not mere vessels through which copyright can be evaded, they can be creatively brilliant in their own right.

My advice to the OP is - understand what parody means, legally. If you expect even a small audience, or you want to sell it, definitely get a lawyer for some advice to be sure your planned game will be able to use a fair use defence. You do not need a licensing agreement to make a parody, you do not need permission at all.

Then it is up to you. Someone could still threaten you, but you have enough information to try call their bluff, if you want. If your lawyer says your game is a parody under fair use, the chances are the legal department in any company will come to the same conclusion, and will not pursue through the courts. Risk is a two player game* - this was my point about rational legal entities.

* [size="1"]Legal risk, that is, . Risk, the board game, is a little different I believe =]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Advertisement
×

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

We are the game development community.

Whether you are an indie, hobbyist, AAA developer, or just trying to learn, GameDev.net is the place for you to learn, share, and connect with the games industry. Learn more About Us or sign up!

Sign me up!