Sign in to follow this  
Paarth

Why is it that game designers should not have emotions for their ideas?

Recommended Posts

Paarth    286
I mean seriously why shouldn't they have any emotions for their ideas and stories? Why should they let go of it immediately if the idea sucks or won't work? there have been bad games lately. Why Should I take it from heart? Then I won't feel like it if its something I make which I don't feel right about it and you know....Awkwardness?

Have many of the game designers feel like this? Or am I the only one here?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DarklyDreaming    367
[quote name='Cap'n VG' timestamp='1322248539' post='4887687']
So you're saying that its bad to get attached to the ideas?
[/quote]
Attachment is bad if you can't let go, yes. It provokes irrational behaviour.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
frob    44904
It is good to have deeply felt but loosely held attachment. You can feel strongly about it, but be prepared to let it go when that is okay.

The skill, confidence, and self-assurance is invaluable when people can say: "I feel strongly that this is the best design. Here is why. ... Now I am willing to let this design go if anyone can convince me of a better one."

Too many people (and politicians) get stuck with the giant ego that their view is right and others are inferior. The preson unable or unwilling to change their view when presented with new information deserves failure.

Your desisn is not perfect. As a mere mortal your designs and plans are going to be flawed. Sometimes you will be flat-out wrong. Sometimes you will rethink a long-held belief and reach a different conclusion. Sometimes it takes a bunch of friends and coworkers to convince you that the project will absolutely fail dispite your beliefs. Learn from it, listen to feedback, reframe views as neccasary, pick an improved direction, and move on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Katie    2244
Writers refer to this as "Be willing to kill your children."

You must be ruthless. You must be objective. You may think it's a neat idea, but *YOUR* opinion is not important. Your readers are the important ones. If it's not the very neatest idea, then it's not a neat idea at all and it must go.

Without that ruthlessness -- that willingness to kill ANY of your ideas in the service of the greater story, you will be self-indulgent and great writing is never self-indulgent.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cowsarenotevil    3002
[quote name='Katie' timestamp='1322259680' post='4887732']
Without that ruthlessness -- that willingness to kill ANY of your ideas in the service of the greater story, you will be self-indulgent and great writing is never self-indulgent.
[/quote]

Self-indulgent writing may or may not ever be great, but it is often profitable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Washu    7829
[quote name='cowsarenotevil' timestamp='1322267025' post='4887758']
[quote name='Katie' timestamp='1322259680' post='4887732']
Without that ruthlessness -- that willingness to kill ANY of your ideas in the service of the greater story, you will be self-indulgent and great writing is never self-indulgent.
[/quote]

Self-indulgent writing may or may not ever be great, but it is often profitable.
[/quote]
Or you end up with the Skyrim skill window, which is terrible to work with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Paarth    286
So...All this time you're saying that passion is not a great thing to have for a game designer?

I can't believe this. Then you guys are just making games for the players but not that you like the idea or hate the idea, you just do it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
frob    44904
[quote name='Cap'n VG' timestamp='1322279654' post='4887800']
[quote name='frob' timestamp='1322258433' post='4887727']
Your desisn is not perfect. .
[/quote]
What design are you talking about?

[/quote]

The context of the thread; the designs that "game designers should not have emotions for their ideas" designs. All of them.

Be prepared to let any of them (or all of them) go.


Yes, be passionate about them. But don't hold them so closely that you refuse to advance. Game designers should have strong emotions for their ideas. If they didn't, I'd question if they were passionate enough to make great games. You just should be prepared to let them go, or as was stated above, kill them if necessary.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
frob    44904
Hidden
[quote name='Cap'n VG' timestamp='1322279654' post='4887800']
[quote name='frob' timestamp='1322258433' post='4887727']
Your desisn is not perfect. .
[/quote]
What design are you talking about?

[/quote]

The context of the thread; the designs that "game designers should not have emotions for their ideas" designs. All of them.

Be prepared to let any of them (or all of them) go.


Yes, be passionate about them. But don't hold them so closely that you refuse to advance. Game designers should have strong emotions for their ideas. If they didn't, I'd question if they were passionate enough to make great games. You just should be prepared to let them go, or as was stated above, kill them if necessary.

Share this post


Link to post
Paul Franzen    334
[quote name='Cap'n VG' timestamp='1322279568' post='4887799']
So...All this time you're saying that passion is not a great thing to have for a game designer?
[/quote]

I don't think anyone's saying that. You just have to be objective, too--or, if you're having trouble with that, playtest the game in its earliest stages to see how people react to it. I'm working on a comedic adventure game right now, and if things that seemed hilarious in my head didn't warrant so much as a polite chuckle during playtesting, then I cut then. I did that [i]because [/i]I was passionate about the game and wanted it to be the best it could be, despite my own limitations.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
davepermen    1047
you should be passionate and everything. but you have to know, and always consider, that you can be wrong on something. you're not perfect, sometimes someone else is right. and you have to accept that not everything you invented is pure gold and pure genius.

if you can't let go of ideas that failed/will fail, you're not good at your passion. because your main goal and passion is and should be making a good product. not a product with a feature you've invented, even if that feature is completely bollocks.

so put your passion into a higher level: the actual product (be it a game, a webpage you're designing, what ever).

an idea getting dismissed doesn't mean the idea itself was bad. it means it doesn't fit right now, right here. focus on the project, not your idea.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FLeBlanc    3141
I love these kinds of threads where someone invents a thing/problem, then proceeds to attack some kind of nebulous 'they/them' over perceived wrongs. What's the point of crap like this, really? Why are you letting this ethereal 'they/them' say what you can or cannot do? And why do we have to listen to you whine about it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this