Jump to content
  • Advertisement

Looking for game critics!

This topic is 2825 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Recommended Posts

[color=#222222]I'm currently working on a new website that aims to gamify video game reviewing. The goal is twofold. Create a platform where aspiring game reviewers can hone their craft and get feedback on the quality of their reviews. The other goal is to get every Indie game available reviewed by someone.

[color=#222222]I am trying to figure out how much interest there is for something like this. So... Is this something people would like to do? If so please respond to this thread with a simple "I'm in" or email me at [email="contact@gamereviewhero.com"]contact@gamereviewhero.com[/email][color=#222222].

[color=#222222]I plan on contacting everyone who responds individually to talk more about their level of interest.


[color=#222222]Game Review Hero

[color=#222222]So you want to review a game. You come in, sign up. Now you start off with a reviewer score of zero. This means you can only review content that has not been review already. That will make more sense later. In order to review a game you need to call “dibbs” on it before anyone else does. Once you’ve called “dibbs” it will not be available for anyone to review for one week. Choose wisely though because you can only call "dibbs" on one game at a time. During that time you should be reviewing the eff out of that game and submit a write up before the end of your week. If you don’t submit a draft of your review within a week that game goes back to being “up for dibbs” by any other reviewer.

[color=#222222]After you submit a review one of our editors will look it over make sure it is not rife with profanity and miss-spellings and you will get approved. If however your review is just line after line of curse words or it is completely incoherent we will reject you. If you are rejected you have 3 days to resubmit. If not the game goes back up for "dibbs.” We’re not saying you can’t curse. We just think it should be used really drive a point home. Too much cursing causes it to lose its gravitas.

[color=#222222]Now, after you are approved, your review is posted on our main page for all to see! Applause! At this point people can rate your review. Depending on your ratings your reviewer score will go up. Remember I mentioned that earlier? Your review score gives you rewards as you get higher. First you will be able to review games that have already been reviewed. This gives you access to review the good ones that maybe someone else has reviewed already. People can also rate these reviews and you can improve you reviewer score even more.

[color=#222222]Here is a brief summary of how reviewer score will work:

icon_cry.gif[color=#222222] NPC (< 0 pts): You have been very bad and are not allowed to review or rate anything. Your reviewer score will increase plus 1 every day until it reaches 0 again.

icon_neutral.gif[color=#222222] Player (0 - 9pts): You are new to the site. You can submit games for review or review games that have not been reviewed and don’t have "dibbs".

icon_e_smile.gif[color=#222222] Game Review Apprentice (10 - 24pts): You have reviewed some games and people have liked it. You have tasted victory!

icon_e_wink.gif[color=#222222] Game Reviewer Adept (25 - 99): You can now review games that have already been reviewed. Getting positive feedback on these reviews is worth more than reviewing games that have not been reviewed. Your positive feedback of other reviewers has more value.

icon_e_biggrin.gif[color=#222222] Game Review Expert (100 - 199): You have our attention. You get priority pick on reviewing the latest games that are up for review.

icon_mrgreen.gif[color=#222222] Guest Columnist (200 - 499) Wow ok, you are really good at this. We will ask you to submit your first guest column. This can be about anything related to gaming. We really don’t want to limit you in any way. Do you want to talk about how much your cat likes watching you play Skyrim? Go for it. It just needs to be 1000 words or more. With great power comes great responsibility though. If you receive negative ratings for your columns you will lose points and you may drop back down to Expert.

icon_e_geek.gif[color=#222222] Columnist (500 - 999): Holy sh- I mean great job! You have written some amazing content and everyone loves your stuff. We upgrade you to full columnist. This means you get to write about anything every week. You get your own section of the website that is yours. It’s like an office, but totally not. We may start talking about money at this point.

icon_e_ugeek.gif[color=#222222] Editor (1000 and up): How the fu-- uh, I don’t know what to say. There is no reason we should not be paying you right now. As long as we can afford it we will do so. Also you get to be an Editor so congrats! You are a Game Review Hero!

[color=#222222]Best case scenario we will hope to bring some real gems into the spotlight and let them shine for everyone to see. We want to create a community which encourages developers to strive for greatness and not have to worry as much about toiling away in obscurity or paying advertisers to get their games out there. It is also an opportunity to inspire real and meaningful feedback other than “This game sucks” or “This game is awesome because I like it”. We’re hoping we can produce some power reviewers who can start changing how we talk about games as a whole. Causing us to expand our vocabulary and enriching our play experiences. Yay community and collaboration!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just a quick update. The site has gone live for beta testing. You can check it out at http://gamereviewhero.com. Email me if you would like an invite.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Advertisement

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

GameDev.net is your game development community. Create an account for your GameDev Portfolio and participate in the largest developer community in the games industry.

Sign me up!