• Advertisement
Sign in to follow this  

What if games were uncrackable?

This topic is 1897 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Recommended Posts

Re: Gavin Williams.

The data you present is fair and is good food for thought, but there are a couple of points to bare in mind...

1. How many of those people who participated in that study said what kind of games the play on their PCs? Are they playing the regular commercial releases such as StarCraft II, Call of Duty, Crysis or are they playing lots of free, cheap or low-spec games such as Mine Craft, Angry Birds or that sodding flash-driven Farming game? Or even playing on emulators for dead consoles or operating systems(DosBox)? o_O

2. How many PC titles, after their purchase, are bought back to the retailer when the customer demands they live up to "selling functioning goods"? The number of returned titles for the PC will out number those of returned console games. Some retailers even go as far as not selling PC titles, because of this.

...but something to also keep in mind is the topic at hand which is "what if games were uncrackable?" I just believe that piracy shouldn't be used as an excuse for PC game sales failing in comparison to console sales, when there are other factors to consider.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement
lol @ the farming simulator http://www.mcvuk.com/news/read/farming-simulator-sells-500-000-units/084560 but I don't think that was the one you were referring to. Who would have thought that would be a raging success. But it (kinda) makes sense, coz people love tinkering and working on things ala Sims. It might be quite a peaceful and satisfying experience.

PC game sales failing in comparison to console sales[/quote]
Not failing. Just selling comparatively less. The market is different now, there are a number of consoles and gaming systems, each with their own culture and following. Desktop computer's and laptops are one of those systems. PC gaming can be a pretty serious affair, while console gaming is more casual and 'personally' social. So they each have their place, but they might not be naturally equal in terms of usage trends. I watch TV and movies in the living room more than I do at my desktop. And that's got nothing to do with the quality of the media. Because my computer can produce far better image and sound quality. There is an overall experience, there is the need sometimes just to relax on the couch and be entertained.

But I agree that piracy is used as an excuse and there are other way more important factors. Like games being developed on console and ending up having a crappy UI on PC ie Skyrim - it's so bad using the in-game inventory and menus, it's totally written for using a gamepad, they just didn't bother recoding it properly, but that game still succeeded. And I don't think that's a factor in console games outselling pc games.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

lol @ the farming simulator http://www.mcvuk.com...00-units/084560 but I don't think that was the one you were referring to. Who would have thought that would be a raging success. But it (kinda) makes sense, coz people love tinkering and working on things ala Sims. It might be quite a peaceful and satisfying experience.

PC game sales failing in comparison to console sales

Not failing. Just selling comparatively less. The market is different now, there are a number of consoles and gaming systems, each with their own culture and following. Desktop computer's and laptops are one of those systems. PC gaming can be a pretty serious affair, while console gaming is more casual and 'personally' social. So they each have their place, but they might not be naturally equal in terms of usage trends. I watch TV and movies in the living room more than I do at my desktop. And that's got nothing to do with the quality of the media. Because my computer can produce far better image and sound quality. There is an overall experience, there is the need sometimes just to relax on the couch and be entertained.

But I agree that piracy is used as an excuse and there are other way more important factors. Like games being developed on console and ending up having a crappy UI on PC ie Skyrim - it's so bad using the in-game inventory and menus, it's totally written for using a gamepad, they just didn't bother recoding it properly, but that game still succeeded. And I don't think that's a factor in console games outselling pc games.
[/quote]

I have to hand it to you Gavin, your glass is half-full to my glass that is half-empty... ^_^

Skyrim had a great marketing campaign. Same as COD, BattleField, Assassins Creed, FIFA and The Sims. They are huge franchises where the PC ports will naturally sell because of the hype - everyone including our pets want them! If someone hasn't got a PS3 or 360 then chances are they will have a laptop and get so caught up in the hype they will take a risk on it working or not - or not even consider it.

For all the issues that I listed previously, there are certainly some strengths to the PC that make it piss all over the consoles...

1. Its a machine that any tom, dick or harry can write games for. You cannot do that on a console unless you are a licensed developer(or with a Xbox Live membership)...
2. The PC, with some basic knowledge, can upgrade their PC to produce unrivalled visuals. A Console simply cannot compete with a machine with multiple processors and graphic cards.
3. Free games! Seriously, with a bit of effort one can find some bloody good games that cost NOTHING.
4. Keyboard and mouse. Nuff said.
5. There are more Desktops/Laptops in homes than any console.
6. So many different peripherals that make even the Wii jealous!
7. Its the platform of choice for MMORPGs.

...I've always loved the PC more than the consoles, but like you say, PC games are being developed in a Console style, and its not being used to its fullest potential...some genres are being completely ignored because the don't work well on Consoles even though they are perfect for the PC(Space Combat simluators).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This would mainly benefit Indie developers more than anything. I like the idea of just screwing with people who use cracked copies of a game, so that if it is just a licensing issue or bug they can still play the game. For example if someone pirates Skyrim, then whenever they get on a horse they get flung into the air and die.
Not that practical but funny to the pirates out there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For example if someone pirates Skyrim, then whenever they get on a horse they get flung into the air and die.

Well, in this case, even a legit copy will do laugh.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Advertisement