• Advertisement
Sign in to follow this  

Using Sonic pictures

This topic is 1770 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Recommended Posts

An independent artist created a sonic the hedgehog sprite sheet and as long as I give him credit, I can use it. My questions is: Is there a legal disclaimer I can put on the screen that says this is not made by sega...etc to avoid being sued. I simply want to make a sonic game for fun on the iphone and provide it free of charge to anyone. Will I get sued for doing that or is there a way I can state this is for fun and the graphics were independently. Or is this a shady idea?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement

An independent artist created a sonic the hedgehog sprite sheet and as long as I give him credit, I can use it. My questions is: Is there a legal disclaimer I can put on the screen that says this is not made by sega...etc to avoid being sued. I simply want to make a sonic game for fun on the iphone and provide it free of charge to anyone. Will I get sued for doing that or is there a way I can state this is for fun and the graphics were independently. Or is this a shady idea?

 

You absolutely can't distribute a work that is using established IP like Sonic the Hedgehog regardless of who drew the artwork.

 

As to whether or not you would be sued, to be honest, you probably wouldn't be because Sega probably wouldn't notice, but you certainly could be sued, and probably would be if you were in anyway successful. Actually unless you were doing something really malicious, they'd probably send you a cease and desist letter first and then sue you if you didn't comply.

Edited by jwezorek

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

An independent artist created a sonic the hedgehog sprite sheet and as long as I give him credit, I can use it. My questions is: Is there a legal disclaimer I can put on the screen that says this is not made by sega...etc to avoid being sued. I simply want to make a sonic game for fun on the iphone and provide it free of charge to anyone. Will I get sued for doing that or is there a way I can state this is for fun and the graphics were independently. Or is this a shady idea?

 

You absolutely can't distribute a work that is using established IP like Sonic the Hedgehog regardless of who drew the artwork.

 

As to whether or not you would be sued, to be honest, you probably wouldn't be because Sega probably wouldn't notice, but you certainly could be sued, and probably would be if you were in anyway successful. Actually unless you were doing something really malicious, they'd probably send you a cease and desist letter first and then sue you if you didn't comply.

Doesn't have to be malicious.  If there's a trigger-happy lawyer, he could find a legal

letter in his mailbox telling him to stop or show up in court.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

An independent artist created a sonic the hedgehog sprite sheet and as long as I give him credit, I can use it. My questions is: Is there a legal disclaimer I can put on the screen that says this is not made by sega...etc to avoid being sued. I simply want to make a sonic game for fun on the iphone and provide it free of charge to anyone. Will I get sued for doing that or is there a way I can state this is for fun and the graphics were independently. Or is this a shady idea?

 

You absolutely can't distribute a work that is using established IP like Sonic the Hedgehog regardless of who drew the artwork.

 

As to whether or not you would be sued, to be honest, you probably wouldn't be because Sega probably wouldn't notice, but you certainly could be sued, and probably would be if you were in anyway successful. Actually unless you were doing something really malicious, they'd probably send you a cease and desist letter first and then sue you if you didn't comply.

Doesn't have to be malicious.  If there's a trigger-happy lawyer, he could find a legal

letter in his mailbox telling him to stop or show up in court.

 

I am taking offense to the trigger-happy comment!  You would be surprised at the amount of people who avoid us "trigger-happy lawyers" until the sheriff shows up at their door serving them  a complaint. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am taking offense to the trigger-happy comment! You would be surprised at the amount of people who avoid us "trigger-happy lawyers" until the sheriff shows up at their door serving them a complaint.

 

Whilst I don't disagree with your point Tboxx. It is fair to say that the profession of law in modern times has become one that is associated with many perceptions that are not just or equitable to the majority of lawyers. Given the ever-increasing complexity of the law within society though and the increasing difficulty of navigating through basic life because of that complexity this and other similar perceptions are unlikely to change for the better. That said, I would also say that many people avoid the dentist until their tooth begins to hurt, services that cost money tend to be avoided by many until they are needed and the cost of law has never been cheap...excepting pro-bono/legal aid etc.

 

 

 

 

1. Using Sonic pictures

2. Or is this a shady idea?

 

1. Don't.

2. Yes.

 

 

 

@Nick5454 As per Tom's answer. If you want to use Sonic's pictures get permission from the IP holder of Sonic i.e. Sega, otherwise find/create/commission something original to use. 

Edited by Stormynature

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

An independent artist created a sonic the hedgehog sprite sheet and as long as I give him credit, I can use it. My questions is: Is there a legal disclaimer I can put on the screen that says this is not made by sega...etc to avoid being sued. I simply want to make a sonic game for fun on the iphone and provide it free of charge to anyone. Will I get sued for doing that or is there a way I can state this is for fun and the graphics were independently. Or is this a shady idea?

 

You absolutely can't distribute a work that is using established IP like Sonic the Hedgehog regardless of who drew the artwork.

 

As to whether or not you would be sued, to be honest, you probably wouldn't be because Sega probably wouldn't notice, but you certainly could be sued, and probably would be if you were in anyway successful. Actually unless you were doing something really malicious, they'd probably send you a cease and desist letter first and then sue you if you didn't comply.

Doesn't have to be malicious.  If there's a trigger-happy lawyer, he could find a legal

letter in his mailbox telling him to stop or show up in court.

 

I am taking offense to the trigger-happy comment!  You would be surprised at the amount of people who avoid us "trigger-happy lawyers" until the sheriff shows up at their door serving them  a complaint. 

Ok... but how does that invalidate my comment that -- based on past actions of patent

trolls and the like -- there are more than a few lawyers working on their employer's dime

that are very glad to fire off a cease and desist letter (often times without verifying if they

are accurately aimed).

 

And if you assumed that I was addressing you specifically, well, that's your assumption to

make and hold.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The rest covered the IP basis of Sega owning Sonic the Hedgehog. All the spritesheet creator is asking is if you use the sprites from the sheet he made then you have to give credit. He isn't asking for credit for Sonic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The rest covered the IP basis of Sega owning Sonic the Hedgehog. All the spritesheet creator is asking is if you use the sprites from the sheet he made then you have to give credit. He isn't asking for credit for Sonic.

How about just asking the Sega lawyers directly?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How about just asking the Sega lawyers directly?

 

The rest covered the IP basis of Sega owning Sonic the Hedgehog.

 

Others covered that, as I said. I was merely stating the spritesheet creator's reasoning for credit: he took the time to put it all together.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's direct our comments to the OP and not to one another, please.  I don't like the argumentative tone this is taking.

Edited by Tom Sloper

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
To add insult to injury, it appears that Sega as of 2011 no longer owns Sonic the hedgehog. It's owned by Panders who created Archie and is currently suing Sega...Odd story, still shady

http://www.iptrademarkattorney.com/2011/06/copyright-video-game-sonic-hedgehog-infringement-lawsuit-sega-electronic-arts.html

I'd link but the site still has php errors

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 My questions is: Is there a legal disclaimer I can put on the screen that says this is not made by sega...etc to avoid being sued. I simply want to make a sonic game for fun on the iphone and provide it free of charge to anyone

 

This is an open and shut copyright violation of the image of Sonic the Hedgehog.  Sorry, there are no disclaimers, etc that will allow you to legally use the images, regardless of who made them.

 

Further, Apple would very  likely reject your app, since it would be in violation of the Apple Review Guidelines (which forbids apps that use 3rd party content without a license... they'd probably recognize sonic and  :))...

 

By all means make an app for yourself for fun with whatever you want.  But if you have any intention of putting it anywhere anybody could see it, then your best bet is  to stay away from 3rd party IP, unless you'd like a call from an attorney...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Advertisement