Sign in to follow this  
plainoldcj

Artifacts on Intel HD Hardware

Recommended Posts

plainoldcj    1068

Hi everyone!

 

I'm experiencing strange rendering artifacts when running my program on Intel graphics hardware. According

to Google that's not unusual, so I'm hoping you guys have some advice for me smile.png

 

See the attached image. I have a NVIDIA Optimus laptop setup. On the right side you see the output

of the dedicated NVIDIA GPU, which i consider to be correct. On the left side you see the output of the

Intel HD 3000 onboard GPU, using the most recent drivers, showing some kind of white stripes, which

flimmer when moving the object or the camera. I think this looks like z-fighting.

 

I'm doing pretty basic multiple pass lighting, with this setup:

Pass No.  DepthMask DepthFunc

0              TRUE          LESS

1              FALSE        EQUAL

>1            FALSE        EQUAL

The problem does not show up if I render only one pass.

 

I tried to eliminate the most likely reasons for z-fighting:

On both GPUs the depth buffer is 24bit in size. (checked using glGet*(GL_DEPTH_BITS)

and QGLFormat::depthBufferSize())

In my projection matrix, I set [zNear, zFar] to reasonable values, eg. [0.1, 100], [1, 40].

Playing around with glPolygonOffset didn't solve the problem.

 

The white stripes are still visible, when I draw the mesh in solid black, by setting the lighting

color to black.

When I disable blending, the stripes become black and the problem remains the same.

 

So basically, I have no idea what to do smile.png Do you guys have any advice or idea

what might be the problem?

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mhagain    13430

Yup, it's almost certainly Z-fighting.

 

I'd advise forgetting about polygon offset for starters; it's not intended as a general-purpose solution to Z-fighting, and the specification allows it's effects to be implementation-specific - in other words, it's fairly useless.

 

Instead, have a look at how you're drawing - specifically how you're transforming - the polygons that fight.  Do they share the same geometry as other scene polygons?  Are you using ftransform for one set but matrix multiplication for another?  Or fixed pipeline for one set but programmable for another?  Because OpenGL isn't a pixel-exact specification, and because you may be using paths where invariance isn't guaranteed, it's entirely possible that the Intel behaviour is actually within spec (i.e. not a bug) but just undesirable nonetheless.

 

Ultimately the solution of last resort may be to adjust your source geometry so that this kind of thing doesn't happen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
AgentC    2352

Yeah, was going to say the same what mhagain just said, are you transforming the vertices the same way in all lighting passes?

 

Also, if there are actually overlapping polygons in the same model, it may lead to double-lighting artifacts in light passes.

Edited by AgentC

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
plainoldcj    1068

Hey guys, great tips!

 

You were right about the vertices being transformed differently in different passes.

Here is what caused the z-fighting:

Pass0:
gl_Position = uProjection * uTransform * aPosition;
 
Pass1:
vec3 worldPos = (uTransform * aPosition).xyz;
// ...
gl_Position = uProjection * vec4(worldPos, 1.0);

 

Simply using the same expression for gl_Position in every pass

solves the problem:

(at least in my case, I think it depends on compiler optimizations)

Pass0:
 
vec3 worldPos = (uTransform * aPosition).xyz;
gl_Position = uProjection * vec4(worldPos, 1.0);

 

It's even simpler than that. The following code solves the problem

as well and is a great example for non-associativity of floating 

point arithmetic:

(glsl multiplication is left-associative)

Pass0:
gl_Position = uProjection * (uTransform * aPosition);

 

Cool :) Thank you guys very much!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this