Would it be inappropriate to Rickroll her by engraving "Never gonna give you up" into the ring?

It would be inappropriate not to.

Proposals are big deals to women. She might end up feeling hurt badly and dump you.

However, do it, and let us know how it goes :D

Would it be inappropriate to Rickroll her by engraving "Never gonna give you up" into the ring?

A: How big of a geek is she?

B: How bad will you feel if she leaves you?

C: Do you have a camera to record this?

A: How big of a geek is she?
B: How bad will you feel if she leaves you?

C: Do you have a camera to record this?

D: should you really be taking life advice from strangers?

E: Why do you need a ring? Most places of the world don't. DeBeers popularized the fad about 50 years ago in US and parts of Europe to sell diamonds, but whatever.

E: Why do you need a ring? Most places of the world don't. DeBeers popularized the fad about 50 years ago in US and parts of Europe to sell diamonds, but whatever.

I got away without an engagement ring. Saved myself a few thousand dollars! I mean... I don't support the blood diamond industry.