Sign in to follow this  
nickwinters

Why are vertices represented as 4f, but normals and light positions as 3f?

Recommended Posts

I'm using GLSL specifically and attempting to reproduce the diffuse side of phone shading.  I've noticed in all example code I've seen, positions are represented as a vector of size 4, but normals and light positions are stored in vec3.  Why do positions need the fourth value but normals and lights do not?

 

Thank you for your help.

 

-Nick

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I should mention that using w=0 is fine for directional lights (they are at a point at infinity, which is what w=0 means), but for normals this doesn't always work. The 4x4 matrix that describes the affine transformation has a 3x3 submatrix that describes a mapping from vectors to vectors, but in general you should apply the inverse transpose of that matrix to a normal vector. If your 3x3 matrix is a rotation, it is its own inverse transpose, so plugging in w=0 will work. But it's good to know why it works and in which circumstances it might not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To develop the above posts a bit, vectors can be used for positions, differences between positions, directions, and normals/tangents/bi-normals/bi-tangents.

 

* A position vector denotes, well, a point in space.

 

* A difference vector has no beginning and no end in the sense of positions, it has just a direction and a length. This may be confusing, but look at it so: It is easy to find two different pairs of positions where the difference vectors are identical; you cannot tell which one resulted from which pair of positions by looking at the vectors components.

 

* A direction vector is a vector with its length set to 1 (unit length), so that the vector still has a direction but no distinguishable length. A difference vector can be made to a direction vector by "normalization".

 

* A normal/... vector is a direction vector with the constraint to have a specific angle to a line, surface, and/or other vectors.

 

In a homogeneous co-ordinate system a position vector has the homogeneous co-ordinate, say w, set to a value unequal to zero, where w==1 denotes the normalized case (all cases can simply be converted to the normalized case by dividing by w). All other vector kinds have a w==0. In an affine co-ordinate system the w is implicit (you as the programmer have to remember and think of which kind of vector you're dealing with). In a homogeneous coordinate system you have w as a helper, but still need to remember and think of the special constraints on normals/tangents/... as mentioned by Álvaro.

 

I'm sure (not to say I'm hoping) that the examples you found on the internet do consider this in the one or other way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this