Jump to content
  • Advertisement
Sign in to follow this  

Collision detection with an ECS

This topic is 1496 days old which is more than the 365 day threshold we allow for new replies. Please post a new topic.

If you intended to correct an error in the post then please contact us.

Recommended Posts



Since two weeks i  work with/learn to use  the artemis framework. But know i found 

a problem which i can't solve by myself in my eyes. The problem is:


The function i use to detect a collision found always a collision!


Obliviously i checked the function. But there i did not find a mistake. I look also up from

where i had this function ( lazyfoo.net ) but also here i cannot find a mistake. Here the function

i use:

bool CollisionSystem::check_collision_PP(std::vector<SDL_Rect>& A, std::vector<SDL_Rect>& B)
            //The sides of the rectangles
            int leftA, leftB;
            int rightA, rightB;
            int topA, topB;
            int bottomA, bottomB;

            //Go through the A boxes
            for (int Abox = 0; Abox < A.size(); Abox++)
                //Calculate the sides of rect A
                leftA = A[ Abox ].x;
                rightA = A[ Abox ].x + A[ Abox ].w;
                topA = A[ Abox ].y;
                bottomA = A[ Abox ].y + A[ Abox ].h;

                //Go through the B boxes    
                for (int Bbox = 0; Bbox < B.size(); Bbox++)
                    //Calculate the sides of rect B
                    leftB = B[ Bbox ].x;
                    rightB = B[ Bbox ].x + B[ Bbox ].w;
                    topB = B[ Bbox ].y;
                    bottomB = B[ Bbox ].y + B[ Bbox ].h;

                    //If no sides from A are outside of B
                    if (((bottomA <= topB) || (topA >= bottomB) || (rightA <= leftB) || (leftA >= rightB)) == false)
                        //A collision is detected
                        return true;

            //If neither set of collision boxes touched
            return false;

My second idea where the error lies was the way I collect all entities to check for collision was may be the error but also here if i debug, the numbers are fine; even if i see on the screen that two entities intersect with each other the result doesn't change( which confuse me the most):

void CollisionSystem::processEntity(artemis::Entity& e)
            //Collect all entities of one group
            artemis::Bag<artemis::Entity*>* collisionbag = world->getGroupManager()->getEntities(world->getGroupManager()->getGroupOf(e));
            //just in case create an Bag without gaps
            artemis::Bag<artemis::Entity*> bag = *collisionbag->getGapless();


            //looks like here is something go wrong, but what???
            for(int i=0; i < bag.getCount();i++)
                if(this->check_collision_PP(hitboxMapper.get(e)->box,hitboxMapper.get(*bag.get(i))->box  ))
            //this part works absolutly fine :D
            if (positionMapper.get(e)->getY() <= MinY ||
                    positionMapper.get(e)->getY() + hitboxMapper.get(e)->Height >= MaxY)
                velocityMapper.get(e)->velocityY *= -1;
            if (positionMapper.get(e)->getX() <= MinX ||
                    positionMapper.get(e)->getX() + hitboxMapper.get(e)->Width >= MaxX)
                velocityMapper.get(e)->velocityX *= -1;


If someone have a clue perhaps what i am doing wrong or what i could check also to find my mistake i would really appreciate it.

Edited by exOfde

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

It could be i found my own stupid mistake... the collision detection doesn't work without coordinates.

so obvious but takes more than 2 days to find ....unsure.png

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Suggestion: when you run into an error like that, after you've examined your code for obvious coding errors, set breakpoints and step through your code, examining the values of variables to determine if the values are correct. Continue stepping through the code until you find a line or function which has good data being input, but results in bad or incorrect data.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Advertisement

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

We are the game development community.

Whether you are an indie, hobbyist, AAA developer, or just trying to learn, GameDev.net is the place for you to learn, share, and connect with the games industry. Learn more About Us or sign up!

Sign me up!