• Advertisement
Sign in to follow this  

Tool for object Lifetime = unique_ptr; Tool for Memory Lifetime = ?

Recommended Posts

As I know, tools for managing object lifetime are :- 

  • std::unique_ptr
  • std::move
  • move constructor
  • move assignment
  • delete copy constructor
  • delete copy assigment

With those tools, it is very obvious to determine owner of any certain object - the owner is the one who stores std::unique_ptr as a field.

However, it is obscure which class actually controls memory allocation.

There are only few tools to help :-

  • the second template parameter of std::unique_ptr
  • the second template parameter of std::vector and other datastructure

None of them indicate which instance of allocator is the ownership of such address.

In a scope of class, it is alarming that underlying memory of a std::unique_ptr (that a class owns) can be deallocated any times. (e.g. from pop operation of scope allocators).

std::unique_ptr<SomeThing> a=scopeAllocator->makeUnique<SomeThing>();
//memory of "a" is invalid!

Are there any tools/techniques to help/prevent it, or at least make thing more obvious for coder?




Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
These tools are designed to work best when the object lifetime and allocation lifetime match exactly.

If the object was allocated from a scope allocator, then the scope allocator itself IS the owner. It's not a good idea to use a unique_ptr as well...

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
These tools are designed to work best when the object lifetime and allocation lifetime match exactly.

Thank a lot Hodgman!  It sounds very nice.  

How to make an allocator own the objects?   

  • Should I cache them by void* and cache the correct deleter (function pointer) for each one?   
  • If I understand correctly, any one-frame allocator should also return weak pointer. (?)

i.e. are there any good practice to follow?    

What if the return result is a bit obscure?

template<class T>class CustomVector{
     T* t;//
class AISystem{
    public: static CustomVector<NPC_ID> reportAllNearNPC(){
        //use "scopeAllocator" to allocate "CustomVector::t"
CustomVector<NPC_ID> a=aiSystem->reportAllNearNPC();
//"a.t" become dangling pointer

Your comment is very valuable - it is better than the chapter "allocator" in every C++ books I have read, thank!

I desire to know more.  If it is not too much to ask, may you recommend name of some good books :D please?

Edited by hyyou

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
When you allocate objects (not PODs) from a scope allocator, then the scope allocator is supposed to call destructors (and release memory). That's the entire reason for using it over a simpler linear allocator. Does it even make sense to wrap objects in unique_ptr then? You'd call destructors twice, and in the strictest sense you are telling lies because now two owners own the object although you say only one does (and only one should). That's really bad.

On the other hand, the calling of destructors and (conceptual) release of memory usually happens at the end of a scope, not when you manually call a pop() function (why would I even want to pop the allocator at an inopportune time?). End of scope may of course mean "end of frame" or "end of level", and it may "manually" call a pop function. But that point in time is exactly well-defined, it's not happening randomly when the objects are still being accessed afterwards. Which means it basically does the same thing unique_ptr would do as well, at the same time, only for a whole bunch of objects.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
the strictest sense you are telling lies

It is totally reasonable and also enlightens me, thank!   

What if the result value has some pointer inside?

For example, it is a data-structure that may or may not the owner of the underlying data,  should I create 2 classes like this? :-   

//old version
template<class T>class CustomArray{ //type of return result
    unique_pointer<void*> database; //underlying data

//new version
template<class T>class WeakArray{
    T* database;
template<class T>class StrongArray{
    unique_pointer_toArray<Bullet*> database;//just example
//inside a function of some system
WeakArray<Bullet> arr;
arr.t = scopeAllocator->makeWeakArray<Bullet>(5);//similar as new Bullet[5];
return arr;
Edited by hyyou

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Advertisement
  • Advertisement
  • Popular Tags

  • Advertisement
  • Popular Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Nimmagadda Subba Rao
         I am a CAM developer working with C++ and C# for the past 5 years. I started working on DirectX from past 6 months. I developed a touch screen control viewer using Direct2D. I am working on 3D viewer currently. I am very slow with working on Direct3D. I want to be a gaming developer. As i am new to this i want to know what are the possibilities to explore in this area. How to start developing gaming engines? Is it through tutorials? I heard suggestions from my friends that going for an MS helps. I am not sure on which path to choose. Is it better to go for higher studies and start exploring? I am currently working in India. I want to go to Canada and settle there. Are there any good universities there to learn about graphics programming? Sorry if I am asking too many questions but i want to know the options to choose to get ahead. 
    • By Bokchee 88
      I am animator by hand, and i am doing game animation for at least 8 years so far. During the last 2 years, i came with a idea for game and maybe some day, i want to start indie game company. As i am thinking to start game company, i am also thinking what kind of value i can give to the company. For example, am experience in animation,sales(I was selling web development services, before i jumped to gaming), bit of rigging- just not for production, i am learning on the side as well. The rest of the gaming production, like modeling, concept art, texturing, i am total noob or to say better, i am no near interest to do modeling for example, don't have such a patience to do it. But before characters and things are made for animating, what the hell i am would do?
      Also, what is the ideal size of the founding team of a game company? Positions to be filled mostly are, Concept artist, Modeler/Texture artist, programmer, animator-rigger. And later would need more people to join, like more animators, programmers, sound, fx,etc.
      And lastly, do i need to have something,like a prototype, to show people and get them interest, or should i ask someone i know, for skill that i lack, for example, Modeling would be great, texturing and rigging, and to start all together from scratch?  
    • By Terry Jin
      Hi everyone! 

      I am from an indie studio that has received funding for our concept and is ready to create the next generation 2D Pokemon-inspired MMORPG called Phantasy World. This ad is for a volunteer position but hopefully will transition into something more. Our vision is to create a game that draws inspiration from the series but is dramatically different in both aesthetics and gameplay as the work would be our own.
      We are hoping that you can help us make this a reality and are looking for game developers familiar with the unreal engine and would be happy to work on a 2D top down game. Sprite artists are also welcome as we are in desperate need of talented artists! Join our discord and let's have a chat! https://discord.gg/hfDxwDX

      Here's some of our in game sprites for playable characters while moving around the game world! Hope to see you soon!

    • By Karol Plewa
      I am working on a project where I'm trying to use Forward Plus Rendering on point lights. I have a simple reflective scene with many point lights moving around it. I am using effects file (.fx) to keep my shaders in one place. I am having a problem with Compute Shader code. I cannot get it to work properly and calculate the tiles and lighting properly. 
      Is there anyone that is wishing to help me set up my compute shader?
      Thank you in advance for any replies and interest!
    • By Katie Byrne
      F.OB: Forward Operating Base is a military themed base building and resource management game.

      I am currently about 6 weeks into development. still implementing core game mechanics. The game is playable in a basic sense right now but there are no objectives or missions or anything motivating really lol. 

      I have been inspired by games such as prison architect and rimworld. both in visual style and general gameplay ideas. Here is a quick 2 minute video i put together that hopefully communicates the general feel of the game and what gameplay is like. Any feedback or criticism is welcome
      I have been keeping a development diary on my youtube channel and i hope to have more developments on this project very soon. 

      So i decided to upload the current build. hopefully get some feedback.

      Its still incredibly incomplete and poorly documented so please feel free to ask me any questions about how to do tihngs. I am working on better documentation and more intuitive interactions.

      Any feedback would be a huge help. positive or negative.


      It's just a zipped Unity build. simply unzip and run the .exe no need to install anything

      Oh yes, there will be bugs  but please let me know if you find any and i'll do my best to fix them 
  • Advertisement