Jump to content
  • Advertisement

Legal Is it possible to sell a serious game to a brand but retain full IP ownership rights?

Recommended Posts

Hello, I am developing my first game which is a serious game about renewable energies. Basically, my idea is to sell the game usage rights(of a branded version) to a National Electricity Company (in a small European country aka Portugal). Then use the core mechanic to produce a paid (PC) version to sell worldwide. This version will have different graphics, different in-game goals, more depth but the same core mechanic.

What do you think about this? Does this route make sense to you?

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's certainly theoretically possible; as the owner of the intellectual property you can more or less craft whatever license terms you want to licensees. 

Whether it's practically viable is hard to say, as it seems predicated heavily on the NEC actually wanting this, which they might not, in which case it doesn't matter.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, you can simply offer a license without giving up IP ownership. But as already noted, that reduces the value (to the licensee) and thus the likely amount- and the likelihood of making a deal.

And you are always free to reuse your serious game's play mechanic in other games.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for your input. 

Regarding the value, the company would create social value (big companies benefit from this) by distributing the game online for free for everyone (it can be used in schools). I guess they lose nothing if a similar version is released (paid) internationally later down on the road. Also, the version they buy is supported by a masters degree investigation that models the national grid, this value is only for them as this investigation will not be present in the paid version. So it is an additional value they receive.

I think companies want to do this, I can name a handful of energy games distributed for free and backed by electric companies.

For example, Duke Energy in the United States did this, and Genesis Energy in New Zealand too.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I just received some input that might make things easier, it will be two different games (the national and international one) so I can give IP ownership of the first and then produce the second that is different but uses the same core mechanic.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Tom Sloper said:

Yes, you can simply offer a license without giving up IP ownership. But as already noted, that reduces the value (to the licensee) and thus the likely amount- and the likelihood of making a deal.

And you are always free to reuse your serious game's play mechanic in other games.

The thing I said about ip ownership and value? Disregard. For your serious game, the licensees surely don't need to own the ip. The game is a marketing tool for them, not a product.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

If I were in that position, I would simply ask them to pay me a lump sum for permission to distribute the game under the terms of the GNU GPL. That way, they can change the game however they want to suit their interests, but you can take any of the improvements they make into your version just by also distributing your version under the GNU GPL; or if you'd rather keep your version proprietary, you can do that and ignore their changes (and in turn they won't be able to use your changes either). Either way, it prevents them from competing unfairly with you.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd be careful about using a GPL licence to try to sell to an energy company. Having any changes they make submitted back to your own version may sound attractive, but in practice there's a reasonable chance they'll just reject the proposal entirely in case they make changes they don't want to share.

GPL is great when it works well, but it's often avoided (or very carefully separated from everything else) in the commercial world.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for your input, it is very valuable for me to hear from more experienced developers.

I think you are missing one point, the game will be sold to an Electric Company, they don't produce the game and they don't make changes.

They will tell what they desire in terms of design/brand and scope of the game and we (me and my team) deliver. I am not concerned about them competing with me. I think they have no problem with me using the core mechanic to produce an international paid version,  I am looking for a way to craft a deal that allows me to do that.

Thanks again!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Game mechanics aren't subject to copyright,so there's no issue using the same ideas in other projects. Individual assets (art files, source code files, compiled binaries) are. You don't have to sell (reassign ownership) to make a product for a client -- you usually just "licence" your IP instead of selling it outright. 

You can accept money from someone in exchange for granting them the right to distribute your assets, while maintaining ownership of them yourself.

We develop a "serious games" product, which we "sell" to a client (give them exclusive rights to distribute the program), while we retain ownership of the assets/code and are able to reuse them in our other products. The client doesn't even have source code access!

Just get your own IP lawyer to write your contracts, or if your client is writing them, don't be afraid to negotiate on the terms that you want.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Advertisement
  • Advertisement
  • Popular Tags

  • Similar Content

    • By GameDevRT
      The Concept is simple, The user can load .mp3 files from a folder into the game at runtime. After loading, the user can animate the lights in the game based on the music. Once done, The user can play the music while playing the game during online multiplayer too. If the user hosts a server, he/she can play the loaded audio files from his/her computer, if the user is a client then there is an option to send the user's audio files and lighting animation to the host So the host can play them. Everyone the on the server will be able to hear the music.
      So, my question is, If the user places .mp3 of a song by an Artist which I don't have license to(because I can't tell what the user will put in the folder) and then plays the music during online multiplayer, Will it be a copyright infringment? Can I get sued for licensing issues? Even if I didn't provide those music files with the game? I need to decide whether to put this feature in the game or not.
      Thanks for your help.
    • By Tom Sloper

      thordsenlawoffices.com 714-662-4990 sthordsen@lendinglaw.com
    • By Aaron Marsden
      Aaron is hosting an AMA in the GameDev.net Business and Law forum. Click here to participate!
      “$100. Gone.”
      Jonas leaned back in his chair, staring at his screen in disbelief. His social media ads had failed.
      A few weeks before, he had launched the beta for his first game, Startup Company, and planned to use the ads to drive pre-release sales, but to no avail. Frustrated and out $100, Jonas started looking for another marketing method — one that could successfully generate the excitement and sales he needed for Startup Company’s launch. And that’s when he found influencer marketing.
      His plan was simple: gather a list of YouTube and Twitch influencers, send them free Startup Company keys, cross his fingers, and hope they play it on stream/video. After hours of searching for and sending 500+ emails, Jonas waited.
      The result?
      The game took off.
      Within two weeks of its launch, hundreds of influencers were playing Startup Company and sharing it with their viewers. His success began to snowball — as more people starting playing the game, more content creators started making videos about it.
      With the help of those creators, Startup Company sold over 50,000 copies within its first two weeks on Steam.
      Jonas had made a hit.
      After seeing successes like Startup Company’s, many game devs have begun looking at Twitch influencer marketing as a means of spreading their game across the gaming community.
      The only problem?
      They have no idea how to start.
      The world of Twitch influencer marketing is frightening. But by educating yourself on the platform and learning the proper methods for conducting sponsorships, you can use Twitch to achieve your sales goals just like Jonas.
      But before you do anything….
      1. You must formulate detailed goals.
      To succeed on Twitch, you have to know why you want to work with influencers in the first place.
      Are you trying to…
      Drive beta users for QA testing? Collect feedback? Generate hype around your launch? Develop a tight-knit community? Promote a new patch/feature? Or blast your game to as many people has possible? Be sure to set your goals early. They’ll provide a framework for the rest of the campaign you’ll build shortly.
      2. Next, set a budget.
      How much money can you realistically spend promoting your game?
      Your budget should reflect your goals — if you want to maximize awareness around your launch, you’ll have to hire more influencers than someone looking to drive a few beta users. 
      We’ll talk more about promotion strategies and pricing shortly. But for now, go ahead and map your available funds.
      3. Now brainstorm promotion ideas and their requirements.
      Many game devs think there’s only one way to work with Twitch influencers:
      Don’t get me wrong — that strategy will work occasionally (just look at Jonas). But if you want to run long-lasting campaigns that help you reach your specific goals, you’ll have to go deeper. 
      There are thousands of ways to promote your game on Twitch — too many to list. But here are a few to jog your mind: 
      Sponsoring an event between streamers from the same Twitch community (e.g. the “Binding of Isaac” game directory) would work great for developing your game’s community within a tight-knit group.  Paying a large streamer to play your game for 1–2 hours would allow you to generate brand awareness, hype an upcoming launch, and/or increase sales. You could even give them a discount code to share with their viewers if your goals are sales focused.   Offering social media promotion to streamers in exchange for on-stream promotion could be a great way to generate buzz on a low budget.  On top of promotion ideas, you’ll also need to plan the smaller aspects of your promotions. For instance, do you want your streamer(s) to: 
      Place your branded graphic in their info section? A streamer’s “info section” is a small section below their stream where they place links to social media pages, gear lists, and most importantly, sponsored graphics (like in the image above).
      Post timed discount codes in their chat? (Most chat bots have this capability, so ask your streamer which one they prefer.) Promote sponsored content on their social media channels (e.g. post to Twitter announcing your partnership)? This is your time to get creative. The more engaging, entertaining, and easy your promotion ideas, the faster you’ll reach your goals.
      4. Gather a list of streamers.
      After you’ve set your goals, defined a budget, and planned a promotion strategy, it’s time to find the streamers who will spearhead your campaign.

      Streamer delivering sponsored content to their viewers, circa 2018.
      …but before you start searching, it’s important you understand some key Twitch influencer marketing metrics:
      Followers: How many users have chosen to see a streamer’s broadcast in their “Following” list. Average Concurrent Viewership: The average number of viewers in a streamer’s channel.  Follower Growth: How many followers a streamer is gaining daily. This number should always be positive. Monthly impressions: The number of unique visits a streamer had on their broadcasts throughout the month.  Engagements: The number of chat messages sent during a given stream or over the period of days or months. The higher the engagements, the better. ACV is the main determinant for how much money you have to pay a streamer for sponsored content — as their ACV increases, so must your budget (generally). 
      There are a few ways you can discover new streamers and measure their analytics: 
      1. Do it manually.
      Head to Twitch, click on a game, and start watching streamers that pique your interest.
      Measure how many viewers they receive on a daily basis and how many followers they gain. Observe how active and positive their chat rooms are. Determine whether you like their personalities. If everything matches up with your goals and your budget, you’ll know the streamer is a good fit to promote your game.
      This method is pretty monotonous, but it can work if you’re just starting out.
      2. Use a tool.
      Twinge.tv is great for discovering new streamers and viewing their metrics. 
      Or, if you’re looking for something more powerful, PowerSpike is a good option. It has all the metric measurement features of Twinge and more. The platform also allows you to post a “campaign” to a marketplace where streamers can apply (like a job board) — this is great if you don’t feel like manually searching for streamers.
      Full transparency: I work with PowerSpike so I’m biased towards our platform, but any tool will work for your needs.  
      Once you have a list of potential streamers…
      5. Find their contact information.
      If you manually searched for your list of streamers, you’ll have to manually find each of their points of contact.
      There are a few common places you can look for contact info:
      1. The info section.
      This is where most streamers link to their emails or Discord servers. 
      If a streamer’s info section is crowded, just Control + F and search for “@,” “gmail,” or “email.” If nothing comes up, you’ll have to look elsewhere.
      2. Twitter descriptions.
      If the contact info isn’t in their info section, there’s a good chance they’ve linked it in their Twitter bio.
      You can usually find a streamer’s Twitter account from their info section. If it’s not there, however, you can Google “[streamer name] + Twitter” and (if they have an account) it will appear.
      6. Send a sponsorship proposal.
      We’re finally getting to the good stuff.
      A “proposal” is an email that introduces you to a streamer and informs them of your sponsorship offer. It usually acts as your first impression, so it’s important to get right. 
      Here’s the process I use to write proposals for custom-managed campaigns at PowerSpike: 
      Greet the streamer and tell them a bit about yourself and your game. Briefly mention how you discovered their stream. Make it personal. Next, tell them you want to send them a free copy of your game and let them know you want to sponsor them. Give a brief description of your promotion idea. Then, provide an offer for how much you’d pay them for completing the sponsorship. Let them know when you’re looking to start the deal. Lastly, encourage ongoing communication by inviting them to a short voice call to further discuss the deal. Once your proposal is completed, send it to the streamer on Discord, Twitter, or email.
      Then wait.

      If the streamer accepts your proposal, great! You can move on to the next step. 
        If they want to negotiate your price or requirements, that’s fine too. Talk it out with them. Be honest about what you’re able to offer and how far you can go in terms of pricing. If the offer goes out of your range or they decline to accept, it’s no big deal — thank them for taking the time and move on.
      7. Send the necessary deal and promotion materials.
      Once a streamer accepts your proposal, there are only a few things left to do: 
      If money is involved, send a contract. You can skip this step if you’re using PowerSpike.  Set a time and date for them to complete the sponsorship. It’s best to let them choose this time, but don’t hesitate to propose your own time frame if it’s important.  Send the necessary resources (e.g. game keys, branded info section graphics, tracking links, documents that restate your requirements, etc.). Lastly, ensure the streamer knows to include #ad or #sponsored in their stream titles or social media posts during sponsored content. If you‘re unsure whether this FTC rule applies to your sponsorship, more info can be found here.  Almost done! 
      8. Watch the sponsorship. 
      There are several reasons why you’d want to watch your sponsored content live:
      Viewers like to interact with devs. You’ll make them feel like they’re a part of your project by talking with them in the chat, and that’s cool. You can collect feedback and answer questions.  The streamers and the viewers will know you care. Just be sure you aren’t micromanaging from the chat. Let your streamers do their thing and you can interact with their communities.
      9. Record results, pay the streamer, and restart.
      It’s done. And now it’s time to measure the results.
      How many clicks did your website get? How many game copies did you sell? How much feedback did you receive? Did the streamer provide high-quality content? Were they professional? Did you set the grounds for an ongoing relationship? And most importantly:
      Did you achieve the goals you set in step one?
      I hope so. But if not, you can always learn from your mistakes and try again later.
      Once all your requirements have been fulfilled, you can pay your streamers and restart the process!
        By now, you should have a great understanding of how you can sponsor Twitch streamers to achieve your marketing goals as a game developer. To quickly recap the process:
      Formulate your goals. Set your budget. Brainstorm promotion ideas. Gather a list of streamers. Find their contact information. Reach out and propose the promotion ideas and sponsorship offer. Send necessary deal and promotion materials if they accept your offer. Observe the sponsored content. Record results, pay the streamer, and restart. And that’s it. 
      Good luck out there! 
      If you're interested in trying PowerSpike for free to kickstart your influencer marketing efforts, feel free to DM me and I'll help you out! 
      Originally posted on Medium at https://medium.com/@aaronmarsden/a17045c32611.
    • By Aaron Marsden
      Hey everyone! 
      My name is Aaron and I’m a writer, gamer, and marketer/campaign manager for PowerSpike, a startup in the Twitch space. For the past two years, I’ve had the opportunity to build and run professional Twitch influencer marketing programs for some great brands (a few clients include Soylent, Camp Mobile, CreativeLabs, and more). 
      I’ve been obsessed with Twitch as both an entertainment and marketing platform since 2014. Before entering the world of marketing, I was a broadcaster and a content creator myself and made YouTube videos in my spare time. 
      Recently many game developers have shown interest in collaborating with Twitch streamers to promote their games -- and I think I can help! 
      I’ve learned so much about entertainment and community development from studying the growth of popular streamers since then, and my current position has allowed me to learn an incredible amount about the process of promoting a product/game/service’s message to a large audience with the help of Twitch streamers. 
      I’d love to share what I’ve learned with anyone who has questions. Ask me anything! 

      If you’d like, you can follow me on Medium at https://medium.com/@aaronmarsden -- that's where I'll be posting both personal and PowerSpike articles on game dev marketing. I also just released my first article, "The Ultimate Guide for Promoting Your Game with Twitch Influencers," here on GameDev.net! You can check it out here:
      Thanks everyone!
    • By Alicia Cos
      Free tickets are available to The Business of Indie Games Virtual Summit happening next month from July 24-27, 2018. There will be 30+ well respected indie devs, producers, and industry veterans speaking about strategy, finance, and marketing of indie games.
      You can easily sign up on the website at https://businessofindiegames.com/info.

      View full story
    • By Alicia Cos
      Free tickets are available to The Business of Indie Games Virtual Summit happening next month from July 24-27, 2018. There will be 30+ well respected indie devs, producers, and industry veterans speaking about strategy, finance, and marketing of indie games.
      You can easily sign up on the website at https://businessofindiegames.com/info.
    • By WooksMain
      Hey guys,
      I've now spent a good amount of time to finish my first Game. The software is as good as ready for a Release, however I'm not! I've come up with so many questions regarding the release of my first Game and i don't know who to ask them. My Questions/Problems are:
      Do i have to claim Copyright on my game, and if so, how do i do that?
      Do i have to create a Company to release the game (regarding the copyright and the taxation of the Patreon income [I'm living in Germany])
      3.Release Platform
      I'm yet not sure how i want to release my Game. As my budget is as of now limited to 0$ a free release-platform is the only way to go. I thought about Itch.io or launching an download-website just for this Game.
      I hope that you guys have some advices for me regarding these Questions. Please keep in mind that I am a 100% Rookie on this field and excuse me for all the times i sound like a complete idiot.
      I'm thankfull for any Answers!
      Cheers, Wooks
    • By Corbbin Goldsmith
      Hi, everyone,
      For the last month, I've been building out my news site for developers of all sorts, and I cover games, apps, web apps, SaaS, you name it! 
      If you want to have an article written about your game, contact me so I can get started!
      A "playable" game A good idea behind it Um, that's about it. Just send me a message through my site.
      Articles I've written:
    • By Fritz1
      QuizTime.live is a new quiz platform, a collection of skill games where you can win a LOT of money!
      The games are played in real time, with 1, 2, 3, 4 or 5 players.
      At special times there are tourneys, with an unlimited number of participants.
      The prize money depends on the number of players.
      I would appreciate your feedback.
    • By Re.Far

      We succeed to publish a small game on googleplay named "sting attack"


      Now we need help of someone experienced in marketing.
      We expect you be active and update our different pages each week and maybe each day. You should market this game and our other game (which is a large scale game for PC) and starts newly for develop.

      If you are interested please let me know and please send your resume too.

      Contact info: rezfar_8@yahoo.com
  • Advertisement
  • Popular Now

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

Participate in the game development conversation and more when you create an account on GameDev.net!

Sign me up!