Jump to content
  • Advertisement
CrashyCartman

OpenGL Low framerate during first seconds

Recommended Posts

Hi gamedev !

I'm facing a really strange performance issue occurring during the first seconds of my app.
When launching the app, three scenarios:

  • Some erratic frames at the very beginning, then 70+fps.
  • Some erratic frames at the very beginning, then ~12fps, then, after a few seconds, BAM, 70+fps.
  • Some erratic frames at the very beginning, then stuck at ~12fps.


Camera is static, so is the scene.

I used nsight to try figure out what's happening, especially in case 2 where I can see what are the differences.
When it's rendering at ~12fps, some glDrawRangeElementsBaseVertex/glDrawArrays calls takes a lot of time, some SwapBuffers calls too, and after switching to "cruise speed", those calls are taking a more moderate amount of time:

Here is a capture of a nsight session timeline:


timeline.thumb.jpg.446f9edf22d15f37e50044c67d519cbe.jpg

1->erratic framerate at the beginning

2->KICKSTART !

3->stable and high framerate

Memory usage is the same in all cases.
CPU Usage is a bit higher when stuck at ~12fps, but nothing remarkable.

My scene is really simple (only a few cubes), but I use a lot of post process (SSAO, SSR). Reducing the framebuffer size to a smaller one doesn't change anything (although top speed is faster).
I also tried to disable all my post process, issue is still there but case 1 is the most common.

it is really similar to what's described in this post, although I'm not using vsync at all (double checked code, and also forced vsync off with the nvidia control panel) nor SDL.
https://www.opengl.org/discussion_bo...-slow-on-start

I also tried to put some glFlush()/glFinish() here and there in my code, without success.

A few specifications:
OS: Windows 7
CPU: Core I7 6700
GPU: Nvidia 560Ti
Drivers: 385.41
I'm stuck with this issue for months now, it's driving me crazysick.gif

Thanks for any help/advice/question/test to make

Edited by CrashyCartman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement

Throwing a dart in the dark here...

When you launch your app, everything is cold. Driver has to setup who knows what for your application in the background, compile your shaders, pass stuff to the GPU, etc. Once all of this stabilizes (say, you've used all your shaders at least once for actual drawing), everything runs as expected.

Drivers do a lot of lazy loading, specially for OpenGL where there are tons of paths to do the same thing and they might require slightly different things. You might ask the driver to compile a shader, and bind a bunch of state, but the driver might only actually do that work when you actually draw with any of them set, until that happens, the driver can just "pretend" it did what you told it to do. It saves up work if you say, change the raster state 3 or 4 times until you actually draw with it. Driver makers prefer to assume you're stupid rather than taking the backlash of XYZ big game that doesn't works as fast as the competition.

Also if you're using any kind of "managed language" (something that runs on top of the CLR or a JVM for instance), those have to do a lot of setup work too, usually concurrently with your application (say, HotSpot, a JVM, can run your code in interpreted mode, while it is compiling it at the same time, then later replace it with the compiled code when it finishes).

This is also true of native languages to a lesser extent for different reasons, big exe/dll/so/dylib/etc might take a while to load and the important bits might take a while until  they hit the CPU caches.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the answer:)

I know driver must be busy after resource loading, and could accept having some long frames at start, but in this case, 33% of time I've got a game completely unplayable.

I also made tests removing all of my threads, just to see if it was a concurrency issue, and unfortunately it didn't change anything.

Everything is in c++, no managed code.

I may add that if I run the exe by doing "Nsight/Start Graphics Debugging", everything is ok, of course I have some hiccups at start but then, game runs smooth every time.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ah right, I misunderstood the problem. Just in case, hows GPU memory usage? Most 560 have 1Gb, you might be threading in a line where sometimes you're running out of GPU memory and sometimes you don't, for whatever reason.

You can check it in a nice graph with something like MSI Afterburner or GPU-Z.

Check system memory too just in case.

Edited by TheChubu

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Alright here are the results of my quick benchmarks made using GPU-Z to track gpu memory.

During loading and the first erratic frames, gpu memory is full (1000MB).

After that, it falls down to around 800 MB, framerate is stable but low.

And if after a few seconds framerate increases, GPU memory goes to around 950MB, if not, it stays at 800MB/low fps forever.

So there is a real correlation between both memory usage & performance.

I tried changing the format of the few FLOAT16 RGBA  FBOs I use to RGBA8 in order to reduce size, but it didn't change anything to memory usage, which is strange.

System memory shows the same relationship between memory & framerate.

systemmemory.jpg.33a612cab7207080ff0e870e6bae7005.jpg

1: first run, app runs fine at 70 fps

2: second run, app is stuck at 12 fps.

3: third run, same as 1

As you can see, the difference is small (100 MB) but noticeable.

Thanks for trying to help me :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are you running in fullscreen at 4k or something? Say, on my Windows 7 desktop I get around 100Mb of GPU memory used constantly, the rest is available. So if you have anything else running that hogs VRAM, close it (games, videos, chrome, whatever). See how much your application is actually taking. Try running it in a 800x600 window.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Running in 720p, and yes, I find this crazy to have so much vram used, should have tracked that before. I use only a few small textures for the moment, no reason to have so much memory used.

Thanks for your help, I'll check what's wront and post the solution here :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Alright, here are the various causes :)

  1. I had some extra large (8k) textures I used to generate small sdf font textures, but never removed them after sdf generation.
  2. My shadow maps are packed into a single big GL_R32F atlas, and the depth buffer of this FBO is as large as the atlas, so it's a huge amount of memory. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think if I use GL_DEPTH_COMPONENT32F as a format I'll reduce memory used by 2.

Thanks again for pointing me in the right direction.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Advertisement
  • Advertisement
  • Popular Tags

  • Similar Content

    • By nOoNEE
      hello guys , i have some questions  what does glLinkProgram  and  glBindAttribLocation do?  i searched but there wasnt any good resource 
    • By owenjr
      Hi, I'm a Multimedia Engineering student. I am about to finish my dergree and I'm already thinking about what topic to cover in my final college project.
      I'm interested in the procedural animation with c++ and OpenGL of creatures, something like a spider for example. Can someone tell me what are the issues I should investigate to carry it out? I understand that it has some dependence on artificial intelligence but I do not know to what extent. Can someone help me to find information about it? Thank you very much.
       
      Examples: 
      - Procedural multi-legged walking animation
      - Procedural Locomotion of Multi-Legged Characters in Dynamic Environments
    • By Lewa
      So, i'm still on my quest to unterstanding the intricacies of HDR and implementing this into my engine. Currently i'm at the step to implementing tonemapping. I stumbled upon this blogposts:
      http://filmicworlds.com/blog/filmic-tonemapping-operators/
      http://frictionalgames.blogspot.com/2012/09/tech-feature-hdr-lightning.html
      and tried to implement some of those mentioned tonemapping methods into my postprocessing shader.
      The issue is that none of them creates the same results as shown in the blogpost which definitely has to do with the initial range in which the values are stored in the HDR buffer. For simplicity sake i store the values between 0 and 1 in the HDR buffer (ambient light is 0.3, directional light is 0.7)
      This is the tonemapping code:
      vec3 Uncharted2Tonemap(vec3 x) { float A = 0.15; float B = 0.50; float C = 0.10; float D = 0.20; float E = 0.02; float F = 0.30; return ((x*(A*x+C*B)+D*E)/(x*(A*x+B)+D*F))-E/F; } This is without the uncharted tonemapping:
      This is with the uncharted tonemapping:
      Which makes the image a lot darker.
      The shader code looks like this:
      void main() { vec3 color = texture2D(texture_diffuse, vTexcoord).rgb; color = Uncharted2Tonemap(color); //gamma correction (use only if not done in tonemapping code) color = gammaCorrection(color); outputF = vec4(color,1.0f); } Now, from my understanding is that tonemapping should bring the range down from HDR to 0-1.
      But the output of the tonemapping function heavily depends on the initial range of the values in the HDR buffer. (You can't expect to set the sun intensity the first time to 10 and the second time to 1000 and excpect the same result if you feed that into the tonemapper.) So i suppose that this also depends on the exposure which i have to implement?
      To check this i plotted the tonemapping curve:
      You can see that the curve goes only up to around to a value of 0.21 (while being fed a value of 1) and then basically flattens out. (which would explain why the image got darker.)
       
      My guestion is: In what range should the values in the HDR buffer be which then get tonemapped? Do i have to bring them down to a range of 0-1 by multiplying with the exposure?
      For example, if i increase the values of the light by 10 (directional light would be 7 and ambient light 3) then i would need to divide HDR values by 10 in order to get a value range of 0-1 which then could be fed into the tonemapping curve. Is that correct?
    • By nOoNEE
      i am reading this book : link
      in the OpenGL Rendering Pipeline section there is a picture like this: link
      but the question is this i dont really understand why it is necessary to turn pixel data in to fragment and then fragment into pixel could please give me a source or a clear Explanation that why it is necessary ? thank you so mu
       
       
    • By Inbar_xz
      I'm using the OPENGL with eclipse+JOGL.
      My goal is to create movement of the camera and the player.
      I create main class, which create some box in 3D and hold 
      an object of PlayerAxis.
      I create PlayerAxis class which hold the axis of the player.
      If we want to move the camera, then in the main class I call to 
      the func "cameraMove"(from PlayerAxis) and it update the player axis.
      That's work good.
      The problem start if I move the camera on 2 axis, 
      for example if I move with the camera right(that's on the y axis)
      and then down(on the x axis) -
      in some point the move front is not to the front anymore..
      In order to move to the front, I do
      player.playerMoving(0, 0, 1);
      And I learn that in order to keep the front move, 
      I need to convert (0, 0, 1) to the player axis, and then add this.
      I think I dont do the convert right.. 
      I will be glad for help!

      Here is part of my PlayerAxis class:
       
      //player coordinate float x[] = new float[3]; float y[] = new float[3]; float z[] = new float[3]; public PlayerAxis(float move_step, float angle_move) { x[0] = 1; y[1] = 1; z[2] = -1; step = move_step; angle = angle_move; setTransMatrix(); } public void cameraMoving(float angle_step, String axis) { float[] new_x = x; float[] new_y = y; float[] new_z = z; float alfa = angle_step * angle; switch(axis) { case "x": new_z = addVectors(multScalar(z, COS(alfa)), multScalar(y, SIN(alfa))); new_y = subVectors(multScalar(y, COS(alfa)), multScalar(z, SIN(alfa))); break; case "y": new_x = addVectors(multScalar(x, COS(alfa)), multScalar(z, SIN(alfa))); new_z = subVectors(multScalar(z, COS(alfa)), multScalar(x, SIN(alfa))); break; case "z": new_x = addVectors(multScalar(x, COS(alfa)), multScalar(y, SIN(alfa))); new_y = subVectors(multScalar(y, COS(alfa)), multScalar(x, SIN(alfa))); } x = new_x; y = new_y; z = new_z; normalization(); } public void playerMoving(float x_move, float y_move, float z_move) { float[] move = new float[3]; move[0] = x_move; move[1] = y_move; move[2] = z_move; setTransMatrix(); float[] trans_move = transVector(move); position[0] = position[0] + step*trans_move[0]; position[1] = position[1] + step*trans_move[1]; position[2] = position[2] + step*trans_move[2]; } public void setTransMatrix() { for (int i = 0; i < 3; i++) { coordiTrans[0][i] = x[i]; coordiTrans[1][i] = y[i]; coordiTrans[2][i] = z[i]; } } public float[] transVector(float[] v) { return multiplyMatrixInVector(coordiTrans, v); }  
      and in the main class i have this:
       
      public void keyPressed(KeyEvent e) { if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_ESCAPE) { System.exit(0); //player move } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_W) { //front //moveAmount[2] += -0.1f; player.playerMoving(0, 0, 1); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_S) { //back //moveAmount[2] += 0.1f; player.playerMoving(0, 0, -1); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_A) { //left //moveAmount[0] += -0.1f; player.playerMoving(-1, 0, 0); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_D) { //right //moveAmount[0] += 0.1f; player.playerMoving(1, 0, 0); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_E) { //moveAmount[0] += 0.1f; player.playerMoving(0, 1, 0); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_Q) { //moveAmount[0] += 0.1f; player.playerMoving(0, -1, 0); //camera move } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_I) { //up player.cameraMoving(1, "x"); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_K) { //down player.cameraMoving(-1, "x"); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_L) { //right player.cameraMoving(-1, "y"); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_J) { //left player.cameraMoving(1, "y"); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_O) { //right round player.cameraMoving(-1, "z"); } else if (e.getKeyCode()== KeyEvent.VK_U) { //left round player.cameraMoving(1, "z"); } }  
      finallt found it.... i confused with the transformation matrix row and col. thanks anyway!
    • By Lewa
      So, i'm currently trying to implement an SSAO shader from THIS tutorial and i'm running into a few issues here.
      Now, this SSAO method requires view space positions and normals. I'm storing the normals in my deferred renderer in world-space so i had to do a conversion and reconstruct the position from the depth buffer.
      And something there goes horribly wrong (which has probably to do with worldspace to viewspace transformations).
      (here is the full shader source code if someone wants to take a look at it)
      Now, i suspect that the normals are the culprit.
      vec3 normal = ((uNormalViewMatrix*vec4(normalize(texture2D(sNormals, vTexcoord).rgb),1.0)).xyz); "sNormals" is a 2D texture which stores the normals in world space in a RGB FP16 buffer.
      Now i can't use the camera viewspace matrix to transform the normals into viewspace as the cameras position isn't set at (0,0,0), thus skewing the result.
      So what i did is to create a new viewmatrix specifically for this normal without the position at vec3(0,0,0);
      //"camera" is the camera which was used for rendering the normal buffer renderer.setUniform4m(ressources->shaderSSAO->getUniform("uNormalViewMatrix"), glmExt::createViewMatrix(glm::vec3(0,0,0),camera.getForward(),camera.getUp())//parameters are (position,forwardVector,upVector) ); Though i have the feeling this is the wrong approach. Is this right or is there a better/correct way of transforming a world space normal into viewspace?
    • By HawkDeath
      Hi,
      I'm trying mix two textures using own shader system, but I have a problem (I think) with uniforms.
      Code: https://github.com/HawkDeath/shader/tree/test
      To debug I use RenderDocs, but I did not receive good results. In the first attachment is my result, in the second attachment is what should be.
      PS. I base on this tutorial https://learnopengl.com/Getting-started/Textures.


    • By norman784
      I'm having issues loading textures, as I'm clueless on how to handle / load images maybe I missing something, but the past few days I just google a lot to try to find a solution. Well theres two issues I think, one I'm using Kotlin Native (EAP) and OpenGL wrapper / STB image, so I'm not quite sure wheres the issue, if someone with more experience could give me some hints on how to solve this issue?
      The code is here, if I'm not mistaken the workflow is pretty straight forward, stbi_load returns the pixels of the image (as char array or byte array) and you need to pass those pixels directly to glTexImage2D, so a I'm missing something here it seems.
      Regards
    • By Hashbrown
      I've noticed in most post processing tutorials several shaders are used one after another: one for bloom, another for contrast, and so on. For example: 
      postprocessing.quad.bind() // Effect 1 effect1.shader.bind(); postprocessing.texture.bind(); postprocessing.quad.draw(); postprocessing.texture.unbind(); effect1.shader.unbind(); // Effect 2 effect2.shader.bind(); // ...and so on postprocessing.quad.unbind() Is this good practice, how many shaders can I bind and unbind before I hit performance issues? I'm afraid I don't know what the good practices are in open/webGL regarding binding and unbinding resources. 
      I'm guessing binding many shaders at post processing is okay since the scene has already been updated and I'm just working on a quad and texture at that moment. Or is it more optimal to put shader code in chunks and bind less frequently? I'd love to use several shaders at post though. 
      Another example of what I'm doing at the moment:
      1) Loop through GameObjects, bind its phong shader (send color, shadow, spec, normal samplers), unbind all.
      2) At post: bind post processor quad, and loop/bind through different shader effects, and so on ...
      Thanks all! 
    • By phil67rpg
      void collision(int v) { collision_bug_one(0.0f, 10.0f); glutPostRedisplay(); glutTimerFunc(1000, collision, 0); } void coll_sprite() { if (board[0][0] == 1) { collision(0); flag[0][0] = 1; } } void erase_sprite() { if (flag[0][0] == 1) { glColor3f(0.0f, 0.0f, 0.0f); glBegin(GL_POLYGON); glVertex3f(0.0f, 10.0f, 0.0f); glVertex3f(0.0f, 9.0f, 0.0f); glVertex3f(1.0f, 9.0f, 0.0f); glVertex3f(1.0f, 10.0f, 0.0f); glEnd(); } } I am using glutTimerFunc to wait a small amount of time to display a collision sprite before I black out the sprite. unfortunately my code only blacks out the said sprite without drawing the collision sprite, I have done a great deal of research on the glutTimerFunc and  animation.
  • Advertisement
  • Popular Now

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      631383
    • Total Posts
      2999687
×

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

Participate in the game development conversation and more when you create an account on GameDev.net!

Sign me up!