Need Help Choosing Art Style

Recommended Posts

Hi all!

New member here.

Need help... I'm stuck between two styles for a game I'm working on. Basically, one is based more comics based and the other is my first attempt at digital painting. Can I ask for some criticisms and suggestions. It's my first attempt so please be gentle.

The game is a mix of Mark of the Ninja and the missions the Thieve's Guild has in Skyrim. So it will compose of interiors with a medieval theme.

Thanks.

-DFox

 

sample_1.jpg

sample_2.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you're in doubt of what style to go with, here's a suggestion: flip a coin. If it's heads you go with the comic style and if it's tails you go with the hand-painted style.

If you flip the coin and go "oh, no..." (disappointed at the result), then you finally found out which style you really prefer.

 

Going a different way, though, you could pick the style that's enjoyable and easy to work with so you can move on and make your game -- since you worked with both styles, you're the best person to gauge which one has these qualities.

One thing that I would do differently is to make a full mock-up of a game screen, including characters, ui elements etc. Maybe one of these styles will clash with something in an unexpected way, so you should give yourself more visual information to make a good decision.

Edited by Kryzon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Art style priorities depend on the type of game and what the player needs to see clearly and interact with. For example:

  • In a scrolling beat'em up or shoot'em up without significant height changes or platforms (for instance, Final Fight and Deathsmiles have plenty of indoor levels) everything in the sample pictures would be in the background, the player would interact only with simple wall shapes and with foreground sprites, and both styles would be needlessly detailed and confusingly colorful and high contrast. Foreground sprites should be easily distinguishable from relatively bland backgrounds.
  • In a turn-based battle game with a 1d layout there would be no need to follow moving objects, only to see at a glance where a handful of characters are located, and both styles would be still extravagantly detailed, but probably not confusing.
  • In a puzzle/adventure game where the player needs to pick objects in the scene the important objects need to look different from the unimportant, ornamental ones: the strong outlines in the first example and the nonexistent outlines and softer shading in the second example would be the respective obvious choices for the two classes. Lower contrast walls would be probably needed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bottom one is definitely more appealing but both are bad, sorry. Aesthetics are extremely important in selling/marketing games today. 

My pro-tip: take a look at the Klondike Collective http://klondike.fr/ and try to emulate their minimalist, poppy art styles. I know your game is set in a medieval setting, but having some beautiful, popping colors in a medieval world would be super interesting because not many people have done it! In comparison, almost every game set in a medieval world has the brownish, grayish "realistic" style you are using right now.

IF YOU WANT TO SELL A GAME, IT HAS TO LOOK UNIQUE. Period.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that the bottom one looks more polished. However I think that's because you only use black for line art in the top screen. I think if you played with the colors in the line art, it could look quite good. Look around at other examples, you'll see that usually it's a dark color, but there are cases where the line art can be a very light color against a dark background, etc. It also can be utilized to give the art more character as well. If you can get that to work, I'd say go with the top, otherwise bottom.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 2017-09-11 at 4:49 PM, DfoxSouth said:

Hi all!

New member here.

Need help... I'm stuck between two styles for a game I'm working on. Basically, one is based more comics based and the other is my first attempt at digital painting. Can I ask for some criticisms and suggestions. It's my first attempt so please be gentle.

The game is a mix of Mark of the Ninja and the missions the Thieve's Guild has in Skyrim. So it will compose of interiors with a medieval theme.

Thanks.

-DFox

 

sample_1.jpg

sample_2.jpg

For me personally comics style looks moere attractive :) , and somewhat rare nowadays , I would go with it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      628766
    • Total Posts
      2984583
  • Similar Content

    • By Viir
      I am working on a multiplayer real-time strategy game.
      This game focuses on the core of real-time strategy, forgoing resource gathering, base building, and unit types.
      You can play the HTML5 version on https://distilledgames.itch.io/distilled-rts
      The current version contains an interactive tutorial and an option to play with bots.
      Note that the camera controls are not yet explained in the tutorial. Here is how to control the camera:
      Camera panning: Hold down right mouse button and drag to move the camera
      Camera Zoom: Use the mouse wheel to zoom.
       

       

       
    • By Viir
      This screenshot shows a game with the new bot and map.
      Screenshot from the DRTS Devlog at 
       
       
    • By NickMervy
      Hey, guys!
      This is our first game published in Google Play. We are dying to hear your feedback and share great experience!

       


      Introduction
      Tic Tac Toe is basic and all-known game. And to compete with other games we had to create something unsual, special. We analiesed market and came to conclusion that a lot of Tic Tac Toe games are overcomplicated without any reason - "too many clicks to play". That's why we decided to create on the one hand simple and on the other one contentful game. The idea was "Open game and start playing" -- no menus, no complex settings. All intuitive and comfortable!


      Features:
      Show him who is the Boss, beat the computer! (Player vs computer) Invite and challenge your friends in 2 player mode! (Player vs player) Play on different maps: 3x3, 4x4 and 5x5! Difficulties levels! Score meter to measure your strength! Everything fits in one screen! Great and beautiful sound effects! Innovative design solutions!  

      We decided to make this game totally FREE, so that everyone could play it!
      Here is some screenshots from the game:


        


        


      Conclusion
      All in all, it is only the begining! We will work hard and improve game! Your feedback and impressions are very important for us!
      Find us in Google Play: Tic Tac Toe – Puzzle Game Free
    • By Penelope Wece
      Hello everyone! My name is Penelope and I am currently working on a Visual Novel called Covet Angel`s. This will be a paid gig. I have been working on this game for a couple of months. Only now I realized I need to step up my game and get better writing in the game. There are 6 main characters that will have routes. 

      Requirements: 
      -Recognize`s at less some Japanese cutler
      -Need to write out teenager or young adult dialogues pretty well 
      -English is first language 
      -In experience in romance novels 

      What the game will have:
      At less 1-8 chapters for each character not including the prologue
      Good end, normal end, and bad end for each character
    • By janek29
      Hi, I want to present my game called "246! Fast counter" - an engaging mathematical challenge! Add quickly and train your brain!
      Download from here: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.threemgames.a246fastcounter

       
      Youtube video gameplay:
       
       
            
       
      Use math and sum up numbers to get the right result. The correct result gives you more time for further mamtematic operations. Do not let the numbers fill all the free fields, because it will be the end of your adventure with math.

       
      Act and add numbers quickly to get the right amount. Look for numbers in the borders and use them for adding - this will allow You to unlock more fields and get even more time. Collect as much as possible points - be simply the master of summation and the hero of mathematics!

       
      Train brain every day to be even better in mathematics.

       
      It is FREE!

       
      I am waiting for your comments.

       
      Please, give me feedback. If you notice any bugs please tell me.

       
      Thanks !
       
       
  • Popular Now