Hello! What's your opinion of this tracks?

Started by
3 comments, last by BravadoWaffler 10 years, 11 months ago

Hello!

I'm doing music for free for other people's game and I'm always looking to improve. I would like to have some feedback in a few themes if possible:

This is a chiptune oriented track for a very simple and funny zombie game. Maybe too simple but it seems it works. What's your opinion?

https://soundcloud.com/estudioevergreen/01-estudio-evergreen-safe-in?in=estudioevergreen/sets/legenda-scintila-ost-2012

And now something more orchestral for a game that was the final thesis of a friend. The requisites was to be something funny and with a battle spirit all together:

https://soundcloud.com/estudioevergreen/03-sion-tower-fase-1?in=estudioevergreen/sets/sion-tower-bso-2011

I'm looking forward to your opinion smile.png. Thanks in advance

Best Regards

Estudio Evergreen.

Advertisement

The chiptune was interesting, and pretty cool. I think it would be better if the lead melody wasn't looping constantly, because I can see it getting annoying after a while (assuming the zombies are being held off for extensive amounts of time). I suppose if this wasn't something you wanted to do, you could change the sample for that lead sound to something that doesn't sustain as long, like a glockenspiel type sound?

The only thing I could suggests for the orchestral piece was that the lower range woodwind (I think) instrument sounded a little too much like a sample instrument, so maybe try some chorus, reverb, or edit each notes velocity to make it sound a little more human; by the time the arpeggiated part kicked in I really loved the track. I think it's really good and quite pleasant to listen to, so it'd be well suited to a game.

All in all, I dig :)

Thanks for the comments!

About the zombies, this was the song for the "city" so you are not supposed to be there a lot, lot of time, but anyways I will check it.

About the woodwind, you are totally right. It should sound more natural, I will probably try to resample this in the near future. With more human things. I will post it again when I have it ready ;)

A quick comment on the Sion Tower - Tema Principal; A struck of genius at 2:11, but it dies again at 2:14. The way you all of sudden mellowed down was beautiful, I just wish you'd stay there for a while.

Rune Hansen

Developer

10ahead Games


www.10aheadgames.com

The chiptune track is pretty nice. Reminds me of Sega/SNES a bit. Nice progression on the melody too, but it is just a bit repetitive. Something about the bass seems to stick out a bit to me too.

The orchestral one is just begging for some thundering Timpani rolls and hits, in my humble opinion :)

This topic is closed to new replies.

Advertisement