I want to support as many platforms as possible for networking, is there a good popular choice? What does Unity use?
Jump to content
Posted 31 August 2013 - 08:33 AM
Is there any particular features you want? If not then, the sockets API is available on pretty much every platform with networking and requires only minimal platform dependent code to work with (basically just WSAStartup() on Windows).
Posted 31 August 2013 - 01:12 PM
Unity's built in networking is basically a wrapper around Raknet. Raknet is a fine solution and can do many things for you quite well but it is for the most part just a messaging and RPC solution which you build on top of. Of course, without further information it is difficult to say what it is you are looking for, so just a basic overview of things you can look at:
Lowest language level items: These items provide just the raw communications abilities, everything else is up to you.
C/C++/Most languages - the low level berkeley sockets API is the underlying item for most OS's.
Net/Mono - the async event solution is your best bet for scaling decently.
Mid level C/C++ items: Wrappers around the underlying Berkeley sockets API, most importantly they use appropriate OS support to supply fairly scalable asynchronous access to the sockets in a clean manner compared to the very aged (well aged; often confusing but not really bad) underlying API. Again, transport of data is left to you.
Libev or LibEvent
Higher level items: Actual message passing protocols, identification utilities, rpc etc.
plenty of others.
Without further information as to your level of interest and what you are trying to accomplish, this is the best way I can start you off. Go poke around at the various items and figure out what level you want to approach things first.
Posted 02 September 2013 - 11:50 AM
Thanks for the responses, the type of networking I want to add (or have the capability for) includes simple multiplayer games, cooperative game play, network classic dm style game play, database registration, online content streaming, scalable morpg server capability etc, chat server, voip server
I have got loads of ideas, however I can't easily implement all this myself so a good high level general purpose middleware solution (and hopefully free, gpl or mit) with hopefully some examples would be ideal ... I am not looking for the best of any, just need the platform coverage and stability ... this should more or less cover the network back end of any software project.
I might still use an engine for my current game, maybe unity or udk, however I prefer to see the code because I have experience.
Posted 02 September 2013 - 02:44 PM
ZeroMQ does not have any reasonable solution for authentication. You should not use ZeroMQ on an untrusted internet. Even the "gateway" pattern in ZeroMQ doesn't properly enforce authorization to talk on the messaging fabric.
Using protocol buffers with ZeroMQ may work OK -- just like any other marshaling framework. For games, you probably don't need the overhead of protocol buffers, but if you're building a system that should stay up and compatible with a variety of client versions all operating at the same time, it does provide some nice features.