Jump to content
  • Advertisement
  • 06/08/16 11:53 PM

    Procedural Generation: Pros and Cons

    Graphics and GPU Programming


    Originally posted at procgen.wordpress.com Doi8ovs.jpg In this article I discuss the pros and cons of using procedural generation (ProcGen). This type of analysis is a good way for you to understand when you should use it and it varies depending on what you want to do. Some case examples in my previous post here.

    The root cause for some of these arguments in favor or against might be the same. Here are a few of the most common pro and con arguments:

    ([+] for pro, [-] for con, [+/-] for depends)

    [+/-] Efficiency: How fast we can design our scenes? Whether ProcGen is more efficient than manual content sculpting, really depends on what you are doing. If you want to model a single 3D building, for instance, then maybe ProcGen might not be as efficient as the manual method. On the other hand, if you are to create 10, 50 or 100 buildings for a city then you could reconsider. In short, ProcGen can have a larger overhead than manual modelling but after you "break even" timewise, ProcGen can become infinitely more efficient.

    [+/-] Cost: How much time and money does it take to create? When it comes to the cost of using manual vs ProcGen, efficiency plays a big role when you consider the saying "time is money". Another factor that influences cost is whether you create your own ProcGen system or use existing solutions such as SpeedTree, Houdini or Sceelix (shameless plug). Although you need to pay for the licenses, it may compensate the time your team saves.


    [-] Control: The ease to define certain designs and properties. When you want to create content with total control and specific details your best bet is to create the content manually. For your time, wallet and sanity's sake.

    [+] Monotony free: If you have to create 100 3D buildings by hand, that can be a very tiresome and repetitive job. This is a point commonly made by game designers in favor of ProcGen.

    [+] Scalability: The ease to create small scenes as well as large. Once you determine the properties and parameters of the content you want to generate procedurally (which generates the overhead previously mentioned), the time it takes a PC to generate any amount of content depends solely on the limitations of the PC. Basically, from making 10 building to 100 can be a matter of seconds.

    [+] Compression: As you may remember from the high ProcGen purity game from my previous post, a whole 3D first-person shooter level fit into a 96kb executable because all its content (3D meshes, textures, sounds) were generated procedurally. When the game loaded up it used up over 300mb of RAM.

    [+] Paranoia: Is this tree distribution random enough? Or the number of branches and sub-branches for that matter? Aaahhh... ProcGen can give you more peace of mind in that sense, if you feed truly random seeds to a properly bounded system. Testing is always important specially if generation is at runtime.

    [+] Consistency: The guarantee that elements follow the same style and working principles. Almost in the opposite side of the spectrum from the previous point: Do these trees look like they're from different planets? If you have a well rounded ProcGen system or tool specification, you can better guarantee greater consistency between content of the same type than if you did them manually. If you don't, it can be a problem. Again, testing is important.

    [+] Reusability: Being able to make the most out of your work. Some ProcGen systems have a high reusability factor. Changing a few parameters could generate a whole new set of content. This also brings value you should consider, if you decide to create one. The more you can reuse it, the better the investment is of creating or specifying one.

    [+/-] Manageability: The ease of controlling the resulting output. If you are talking about creating large quantities of content, ProcGen can give you centralized control over the overall result. If you are dealing with small quantities, manual creation will give you more control. Some ProcGen tools also give you more control by giving you visual languages (normally node-based) with parameterization.

    [+] Adaptability: change to obey the rules you defined in your system. If you make a building double its original height, then the number of floors could automatically double. If the ProcGen system you use is well developed, you may change one of its parameters and the resulting output will adapt to meet the constraints you have in place.


    These are the broad strokes. There are also some general considerations you should have when you use procedural generation, but that I'll leave for my next post.

      Report Article

    User Feedback

    Your ProcGen editor is super slick.  I'm curious what it was built with.

    Share this comment

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Yes, there are advantages and disadvantages to procedural generation. In my opinion, nothing beats creating something piece by piece - as far as visual quality, but it is sooooo time consuming. Procedural editors are slowing becoming better at both productivity and quality of the finished scene. Some are even using a little artificial intelligence to create more natural looking randomness in a scene.

    Share this comment

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    Have you ever combined procedural generation with manual design? E.g. using a procedural generator to generate an initial map, saving it and tidying it up and making it less computer generated by letting an artist loose on it? This also has its advantages and disadvantages which would have been good in this article... good work though!

    Share this comment

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Advertisement

Important Information

By using GameDev.net, you agree to our community Guidelines, Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

GameDev.net is your game development community. Create an account for your GameDev Portfolio and participate in the largest developer community in the games industry.

Sign me up!