• entries
    1212
  • comments
    1738
  • views
    1139430

Thinking of changing a game

Sign in to follow this  
johnhattan

130 views

I've gotten to do something in my six daily puzzles that I haven't really done in my previous games (with a couple of exceptions). And that it, playtest them extensively. I've played all six games maybe five times a week (I'm "Flyman" in the high score tables and I stunk up the place yesterday, not getting first place in ANY of 'em).

Anyway, I got a lot of playtime in the games now. And I like 'em all. Shelly's not wild about ChessCards and BaffleBees, but that's mainly because she hasn't been able to wrap her brain around 'em. I've wrapped my brain around all of 'em and have gotten proficient at 'em. ChessCards, in particular, I've botten particularly good at even though "Contrail" regularly beats me at it. The games all have their charms. Shi Sen is a bit mechanical and only has the barest of strategy (basically choosing which tiles should be uncovered first if you have a choice), but it's so quick to play that it doesn't bother me.

Oh, and credit to TANSTAAFL for thinking up the idea for BaffleBees (and yes I did pay him for it), although it was rather a hexagonal version of my old Quinto, which was itself a version of an old game from a "50 Games in BASIC" book, but it honestly wasn't all that good of a game and was later done better by Tiger Electronics as "Lights Out", so the credit is certainly due for improving it the way TANS did.


Pop Pies, though, has a flaw. The best strategy (as most have discovered) is to try to make the biggest "chain" of pies possible early in the game. That is, you look at the board, say "I think I can chain together a load of red pies" and then set about doing it. If you manage to make a 20 or 30 or 40-pie chain, you'll make big points. After you make one or two of these big chains, though, any further moves you make are in-comparison trivial and only serve to finish out the game.

That is to say that the game, after you make one or two huge KABOOMS, is a bit of a letdown. I think I have a solution, though, and I'd like to run it past you folks.

One thing I had early on was the concept of a bonus for killing off a column, thus causing the pies to all "collapse" to the right. I took it out because it really didn't have any strategic value compared to the score for chains of pies, but now I see that it could be something to give the game more strategy (and hence more fun) near the end.

How about this. You get a 50 point bonus for collapsing a column sideways. And that bonus increases by 50 points every time. Next column you collapse is worth 100, then 150, etc. That way there's a point to the game when you get near the end and there's no possibility of anything other than trivial scores.

Whattya think?
Sign in to follow this  


1 Comment


Recommended Comments

My basic strategy for poppies is this.
At the start, try to estimate the most common color.
Then see if that color is in every coloum, or at least most of the coloums.
Color saturation at the middle and top is more important then colors at the bottom, as I can control how far those fall more easily and properly line up a chain across.

Then I start blasting away from the other colors, worrying more about lining up a single large chain, rather then going for small chains in these off colors. I start at the top on one side, and work to eliminate blocks, and looking down the coloums to do the occasional blast to line one or more things up at top.

I don't always remove ALL colors from a coloum either, some stuff is left in as "supports" for the chain so that it lines up.

Also not above removing isolated color blocks of what I am making the chain out of if there is no other way to line things up.

As such it's not uncommon for a single chain to be worth 2-3k points. Highest score i ever got iirc was ~5k total.

Also, i'm ORBIT on the boards ;)

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now