Quote:
Original post by JonC
green? I recall that blue one getting pwned on the mushroom planet, but not a green one. perhaps I need to watch it again. ;)

Yeah Sorry I meant blue. She is Aayla Secura

She is Hawt!! I want to make half human babies with her. She will be the subject of my dreams tonite.

Quote:
Conner McCloud:Star Wars doesn't take place in the future. So there's no telling how useful such a change would be. :P

Ainokea:A long long time ago...

I figure it happened a long long time ago in their own galaxy or theirpart of the world, but is still in our future.

More to the point though, what does the fact that cities like that exist in the star wars universe a long time ago matter. They still dont exist here in our world. So I still have to wait till we develop that much.

Pointless timeline talk. The most important thing is that Aayla is HOT!! and i want her to have my kids. (blue as they may be)

Here are some of my complaints:

-I didn’t think Padme would die so soon after giving birth. Leia said her mother was very sad and very kind which would have been consistent if they had let her live maybe a few years longer. I mean what happened? Did they just have some women pretend to be Leia’s real mom and stage her death?

- Obi-wan told Luke his father wanted him to have the light saber when he was old enough. Anakin didn’t even talk to obi-wan about his children.

- What “new powers” did Anakin gain? He mentioned on MT. Doom that he had new powers.

- I really didn’t like the sudden transition Anakin had to the dark side.

- Yoda gave up the fight with the emperor pretty quick. He didn’t really seem that hurt after the fall he could have continued.

- The ending Vader scream.

- Granted the Emperor saved Vader’s life, but why would Vader still stay loyal to him after the Emperor told him how the dark side can save Padme. Basically the Emperor ruined his life. Also, Anakin knew she was still alive after the choke. Wouldn’t it have come across his mind that the Emperor may have killed her?

- Jar Jar is still alive.

It was good, but I was a little let down with a few things.

1. I didn't buy that Anakin could be a good guy one minute, then 20 minutes later be killing children.
2. I didn't like the "Wrath of Kahn" style "Noooooooooooo" from Darth Vader.
3. I didn't feel like the Emperor seemed all that tough... I was a little disappointed.
4. I didn't fully understand why Yoda went into hiding. It was kinda like "Well I gave it a shot, but I couldn't kill the Emperor... oh well"
5. The Jedi seemed way too easy to Kill.
6. I was disappointed with how Obi Wan defeated Anakin.
7. I'm not sure why Anakin burst into flames when his feet (stumps) touched the lava.
8. I'm not sure why Obi Wan just let him (Anakin) burn... for the love of god put him out of his misery. Or if you don't want to kill him, help the brother out.
9. Didn't like how Windu (not sure if I spelled that right), fell out of a window and died. Would have preferred to have seen more of a fight between Anakin and Windu.


Great Special effects though. Overall, I liked it, just a few things bothered me.

Quote:Original post by ManaStone
Here are some of my complaints:

-I didn’t think Padme would die so soon after giving birth. Leia said her mother was very sad and very kind which would have been consistent if they had let her live maybe a few years longer. I mean what happened? Did they just have some women pretend to be Leia’s real mom and stage her death?

Perhaps Leia had been aware of her adoption, but not entirely filled in on the details of her lineage?

Quote:Original post by ManaStone
- Obi-wan told Luke his father wanted him to have the light saber when he was old enough. Anakin didn’t even talk to obi-wan about his children.

Padding to encourage Luke.

Quote:Original post by ManaStone
- Granted the Emperor saved Vader’s life, but why would Vader still stay loyal to him after the Emperor told him how the dark side can save Padme. Basically the Emperor ruined his life. Also, Anakin knew she was still alive after the choke. Wouldn’t it have come across his mind that the Emperor may have killed her?

Well, that wouldn't have made much of a story for the original trilogy, would it? [grin]

I enjoyed it. Some of the guys I went with were disappointed, especially with the somewhat hypes non-character that was General Grevious (a Darth Vader tech demo, tbh). Grand Moff Tarken at the end was a nice touch (I missed some of the other "hidden" elements mentioned), Chewie was unnecessary, and Alderan looked like a hell of a holiday spot.

Whats really bothering me, however, is one line from ANH. I have the trilogy ordered on DVD, but its bugging me to see if this line was changed. There is the scene on the Death Star where Vader enters the room and declares that the Emperor has finally dissolved the Galactic Senate. Now, ANH is set 19(?) years after RotS, so after declaring an Empire, why would it take so long to finally gain absolute power?

Quote:Original post by doodle_sketch

Whats really bothering me, however, is one line from ANH. I have the trilogy ordered on DVD, but its bugging me to see if this line was changed. There is the scene on the Death Star where Vader enters the room and declares that the Emperor has finally dissolved the Galactic Senate. Now, ANH is set 19(?) years after RotS, so after declaring an Empire, why would it take so long to finally gain absolute power?

Systems that are still loyal to the jedi? Systems that didn't like the way the Empire was going so they stopped obeying them. Wars take a long time to finish.

did anyone else think Vader must've spent the years between III and IV in the gym? He's nowhere near as broad as he is in the classic trilogy. I didn't think it was

Apart from that my only major disappointment was that none of the wookies tore anyones arms out of their sockets! A prime oppurtunity to back up Han's assertion and it was missed.

My final niggle was that I felt too many of the sabre fights were shot too tight. You couldn't really see the fighting.

Other then that I really liked it. Actually it pretty much occupied my thoughts all day yesterday after seeing it. It really depressed me both from a plot point of view and for the fact it's the last star wars movie.